"Marx's value theory was debunked" Starter Pack

Posted Dec 9, 2017, 8:24 AM UTC

Posted Dec 9, 2017, 8:24 AM UTC
Why Robinson Crusoe?
It's not uncommon to see people who try to refute Marx's theory of value using Crusoe's example of a individual stranded making racional choices, calculating risks (like an entepreneur), etc. Crusoe is the ideal bourgeois individual; these comparisons are the "robinsonades" Marx refers to. IIRC Böhm-Bawerk is one of the "refuters of Marx" that used this awful comparison, to justify the right of the capitalist (a Crusoe that deprived himself of the use of some immediate good to have more later) to extract surplus value from the worker (who did not take risks). Of course, this is pure fucking ideology.
That's actually stupid because Marx here is using Crusoe to prove his point that products of human labour don't need to be in a value-form.
That's all true but It seems half the time someone tries to "debate" the LTV they launch into a Crusoe-esque analogy, that's why i used it in this meme
I assume it's a reference to Marx's connection of political economists like Smith and Ricardo to the isolation of Robinson Crusoe:
The individual and isolated hunter and fisherman, with whom Smith and Ricardo begin, belongs among the unimaginative conceits of the eighteenth-century Robinsonades.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1857/grundrisse/ch01.htm
Oh come on, did you never see Crusoeonomics made by ancaps?
Your post history is one bad meme, lmao.
Indeed, I am subject of almost every shit*says possible
then perish,
God I wish I knew enough to get this joke.
These are common tropes that are supposed to debunk Marx's law of value or value theory in general. The mud pie argument is one where they attempt to say that if you put labour into anything then it should have value, so why not mud pies?
The one in regards supply and demand is I think a belief that Marx can't, or doesn't, explain it, even though he actually does talk about it a lot (in Value, Price and Profit for example).
The art one is similar to the mudpie argument, that you can't call art a commodity or that its value isn't related to the labour put into it.
I don't know what Crusoe has to do with it.
And the bottom right is marginal utility theory.
Marx's introduction to Grundrisse.
Also all over the first Das Kapital book
What's that?