In what order and what works of Marx do you suggest reading?

I'm not opposed also to reading more modern summaries or synthesized versions of Marx as well.

Posted Dec 9, 2017, 10:53 AM UTC

1219
disinterested_dudeLearning•

I read his smaller works (Value, Price and Profit, Critique of the Gotha Program, Civil War in France, etc.) before tackling his longer, voluminous books and I think that worked out relatively well for me.

Reading Marx is somewhat convenient, in that he almost never requires you to have any prior understanding. He generally lays out everything that's needed for understanding a concept in a concise (though not necessarily brief or easy) manner, so you could reasonably read him in whatever order you wish.

22
CraveBoon•

So I don’t really have to slog through Capital to start?

13
doeslikecheesecake•

Of course there's no order you have to read Marx in. Like u/disineterested_dude, I've started with his shorter, "condensed" works like the Paris Manuscripts and A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, which I'm reading now, while I make excuses not to start Capital. And a few longer works here and there, like The German Ideology.

Edit: and, as long as we're talking about reading just Marx's bibliography (which you really shouldn't do, that sounds onerous) I also recommend checking out things that weren't his major works, like his letters and journalism, much of which can be found on MIA, and which contains imo some of his best jokes.

5
CraveBoon•

I’m reading some shorter articles by other people here and there, but Capital is the book that I’m working on right now, and i feel like I’m gonna come back to it later.

4
AlienElation•

I'm not opposed also to reading more modern summaries or synthesized versions of Marx as well.

Be opposed to it.

17
JuliuscaesarGGOP•

Why so? There's no good synthesized did?

2
Vladith•

Attempts to clarify, abridge, or even "update" Marx tend to be influenced by whatever leftist ideology the person involved subscribes to and can make further readings of Marx more confusing. 2/3 of summaries of Marx insist he believed "socialism comes before communism" despite this being Second International bullshit.

If you want to understand Marx then read Marx. He can be difficult sometimes, but just go through his work slowly and don't be afraid to reread.

10
Liquid_Blue7Learning•

I always recommend people start off with the German Ideology first and foremost. The first chapter that is. Maybe 30 pages.

17
Bigfluffyltail•

I agree somebody the other day was asking me questions about Marx and what they could read to get those answers (they trusted their reading abilities more than me) since they saw me read him and I told them to read that first chapter because it answered all their questions. Apparently it did because the next day they thanked me and said that it did indeed answer their questions.

6
doeslikecheesecake•

I honestly feel like I only really "got" The German Ideology after reading a Cyril Smith book and browsing this sub. Not to discourage reading it, only I found knowing something about idealism, materialism, the Young Hegelians, and alienation was wonderfully helpful with really understanding the book.

4
Liquid_Blue7Learning•

Which book are you talking about? And yeah, I agree, I had previously done a half-assed wikipedia investigation into Marx's history which helped with some of the context

2
doeslikecheesecake•

Sorry, "that book" in the last line is The German Ideology.

3
Liquid_Blue7Learning•

Oh no yeah, I got that hehe, I meant what Cyril Smith book.

2
BigB69Learning•

Sidebar

4

Just as an additional voice to go against the grain a bit, don't be to daunted by Capital. I've been reading it and I find it very engaging. It's not as difficult as it's made out to be. I'd say once you get past the antiquated writing style he lays things out in a straightforward way. The chapters where he describes literal working conditions of the 1800s using Factory Inspectors reports are fascinating from a historical perspective and really makes you appreciate the things the workers movements of the past have achieved even if communism hasn't happened (yet). Like, going to work sucks, but at least I'm not breathing in sulphur fumes for 14 hours a day in a 90 degree matchstick workshop since I was 8. It's also fascinating to see the same exact same garbage bourgeois arguments we see people make today. The world he paints is like a nightmare version of our own that has tons of eery structural similarities.

3

I should also mention that third world working conditions are probably a comparable hellscape to what Marx describes but I can't say exactly how. This is a pretty cushy western comparison.

2
hlafdig•

The Communist Manifesto should always come first!

2