r/gaming•
Shadowws

Sony will not refund Destiny 2 even though content was recently blocked from the game

Sony will not refund Destiny 2 even though content was recently blocked from the game

Posted Dec 9, 2017, 10:17 PM UTC

808126
RedditUserWho•

All content available prior to CoO was marketed in order to sell copies of the game. This content that was marketed, purchased, and playable by consumers is no longer completely intact after an optional paid update was implemented. Regardless of their EULA, and the level of ownership we have, false advertising remains illegal. EULA's do not supersede established law for the protection of consumers. When they utilized content to make a sale, and then after the sale remove what made them the sale, that's false advertising. It's bait-and-switch, and there are volumes of legal precedents protecting consumers from these tactics.

If you're looking for a refund and haven't been able to get one, you can continue to be denied by customer support from wherever you purchased the game, or you can be productive and make a consumer report to:

For complaints against Bungie - The Washington State Attorney General's Consumer Protection Department here: http://www.atg.wa.gov/file-complaint

For complaints against Activision Blizzard - The LA County Attorney General Consumer Protection Department here: https://iddweb.isd.lacounty.gov/dca_ecomplaint/

It took me 5 minutes and they will open a case to work with you personally to resolve your individual dispute. If enough people submit a complaint there, the state will file suit. It doesn't matter where you are in the world, you can submit a complaint to these organizations.

Edit: I made my own post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/7iqhoj/gamers_need_to_unite_against_predatory_publishers/

293
ShadowwsOP•

On it, I'm pissed. Got any pitchforks?

86
DRT_99•

I’m selling some torches. The flames are paid DLC though.

30
Halvus_I•

/unzips

Fine, what colors do you have?

4
BluKyanite•

I've got blue, red, pink, green, and yellow at 9.99$ I've also got the sense of accomplishment rainbow flame for 19.99$

Fine text: these will need to be repurchased at a random time. The 9.99$ Colors are not a package, they are separate.

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
BlueDragon101•

Wait, what specifically was blocked?

8
RedditUserWho•

Prior to CoO, players could access certain activities such as prestige raid, prestige nightfall, and trials. These previously accessible activities are now only available to those that purchased the dlc.

32
KingPhoenix•

... So same shit as destiny 1...i refused to buy it Becuase of that...

19
camelchunk•

It’s so sad because everyone knew that this would happen and that bungie is a shit company. Nobody should be surprised. You got what you paid for because you bought something from bungie. This shouldn’t surprise anyone.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-20
Baconator004•

It's great that they're changing it, but it's probably only because of legal pressure. It would take an astounding level of ignorance to do this unintentionally.

19
RedditUserWho•

They have contractual agreements with vendors that their trophy and achievement systems comply with vendor requirements. They only mentioned these systems, not any actual content. We don't know how they will handle changes. Either way, the advertising and sales took place prior to that announcement. By backpedaling, they seem to understand they've done something wrong in some regard.

3

Someone should get up the ACCC here in Australia. They hate shit like this.

4

You're right! I'll get right onto the air conditioner conditioner conditioner.

2

Of course. You yanks don't have air conditioner conditioner conditioners?

1

Little did you know, I'm just an Australian without an air conditioner conditioner conditioner.

The Plot Thickens...

2
Zran•

We should get on to everything we can unfortunately Australian sales probably aren't big enough to get a response

1
RS177•

You're cashing on the karma.

-17
RedditUserWho•

I don't care about karma. I care about helping people that feel they've been swindled understand they may have more options to resolve their dispute.

9
RS177•

Nevermind then. I didn't purchase Destiny 2 because the original Destiny didn't deserve the fame. I saw that the sequel didn't receive much media attention and hardly anyone was playing it. I heard that it was mediocre at best but when I found out that the DLC locked some previously unlocked content, I was furious. I had planned to wait a couple years and get the game for $8 like I did with the original but I've decided to avoid funding Bungie.

1
MrMathRock•

It isnt "optional" when it comes to the content listed. The dlc directly affects those game types. People with the base game can still play campaign.

Welcome to Mmos. Destiny2 dlc is stupid cheap in comparison to world of warcraft monthly fee+expansion paygate.

The servers are expensive. Would consumers have rather paid for a $80 base game and a $15 monthly fee? Or a $60 base game and a 1 time payment of $35.99(thats 2 seasons of dlc so 6 months of content )

-78
RedditUserWho•

Yeah, what's Blizzard thinking? They should require equipment from their latest expansion, Legion, to continue to do the same activities in their previous expansion, Warlords of Draenor. That way they could force people to buy a new expansion when it comes out too. This sounds like a consumer friendly way to do business. /s

29
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-25
hablomuchoingles•

He's making the comparison between Blizzard and Bungie that the previous user started. Try to keep up.

17
NateDogg414•

You misunderstood that. He was saying Blizzard should've done what Bungie did with Destiny, to WoW. It was a joke

9
Charlielx•

Also, this same shit happened with Destiny 1. The exact. Same. Shit.

How does that change anything? Shitty practices in one game just automatically justify them in sequels?

3
glytchypoo•

The servers are expensive.

HA HA HA HA HA HA HA

oh wait, you were serious? Let me laugh more

we're not in 1990 anymore

24
AlexStar6•

You’re right we’re not it’s the networking equipment from Cisco and HPE Aruba that’s expensive. Storage and Compute is dirt cheap.

Source: am network architect

9
NotAllThere_67•

All well and good, but it should have been stated from the outset what was going to happen, or they shouldn't have released the full game as it was.

I'd understand a whole lot more if they were up front in the first place and I'm sure the community would too. This is 100% on them for handling it as poorly as they did. They took a steaming turd on the gaming community. So did EA. I wish we could be unified enough to hit these devs where it really hurts...their wallets. Just straight up boycott them until they straighten themselves out.

4
Sno_Wolf•

No way.

~ Jose

The short version.

96
klkevinkl•

Some people are saying that the update violates Sony's policy on Platinum Trophies as Nightfall/Prestige Raid is required to get a Platinum. Might want to try that angle.

41
evilkillejr•

Did, doesn't work. All they will say is that we should take it up with bungie.

12
DestructiveNave•

This bait and switch is bullshit. Nobody will take accountability for what has happened. Bungie is notorious for not answering complaints, or issuing refunds. Chargebacks are too aggressive to be used, unless you want to be barred out of more in life. This is just ridiculous. Between this, EA, Net Neutrality, and the new Tax proposals.. I'm scared for the future. :/

20
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
StrifeDarko•

Hey Neutrality will cost you about 2-3 movie tickets for full access, so...?

5
GuyoFromOhio•

I pre-ordered the game through Amazon and contacted them today about this whole issue. I didn't expect much but surprisingly the customer service rep immediately said they would initiate a return and issue a full refund. Worth a try if you purchased through them.

37
AsocialReptar•

That is another benefit of not buying digital copies of games.

14
GuyoFromOhio•

My internet connection is super slow. I have to buy physical copies or it would take like a week to download.

7
voodoocabcad•

I digital ordered through amazon and they agreed to refund me for Destiny 2 today. I was kind of surprised but very happy.

4
ODST_Sharky•

Sony kind of has a reputation of being strict with refunds. Contacting Xbox for mine resulted in them telling me to contact Bungie. Be careful with a credit card chargeback, I’ve heard many stories about accounts getting banned after chargebacks.

27
Zaku0083•

Be careful with a credit card charge back, I’ve heard many stories about accounts getting banned after charge backs.

And I don't blame them for it. It isn't bungie who gets screwed when doing a charge back, it is Sony or Microsoft.

8
SireNightFire•

Yes that is the most aggressive form of refund. Back when Steam didn't do refunds I got completely scammed from a game that literally wouldn't run. The support wouldn't help me either. I did a chargeback via PayPal and was banned from buying Steam games for a year and banned from using PayPal. Thankfully the ban doesn't show on my record. I also was allowed to play the games I owned still. This was probably in 2012 or 2010.

7
Halvus_I•

DO NOT DO A CHARGEBACK ON SONY. They will suspend your PSN account, for me that includes the apps on my a6000 camera too.

5
Aturaku•

It must really suck to be one of these poor customer service people at the moment lol..

24
TheSumOfAllFeels•

at the moment

I'mma let you in on a little secret: it always sucks to be a customer service rep.

https://twitter.com/BrainFumbles/status/619712926555869184

16
TheGhostofSwitzer•

I wish I could press ctrl C and V for 15/hour.

1
CaptainPick1e•

Eh, these are all pretty much copy pasted responses.

0†
ayeenebother•

Yeah but they’re not the heads of the company fucking people over. They’re just doing their jobs.

12
CaptainPick1e•

Yes. They're getting probably most of the shit and it isn't fair to them.

3
rydan•

I'm sure they will be well compensated.

0
Pentafeel•

From someone who works in this field I can assure you they are not.

1
Thenuclearhamster•

Submit a formal complaint through the Federal Trade Commision or your country's version of it. You paid for a product that was not given to you.

15
SVXfiles•

But it was. There's nothing preventing you from running the prestige nightfall with your power cap being 305.

Back in D1 this exact same thing happened with the release of TDB and HoW. Level cap went up and it was still possible to play stuff with the higher level caps, just a bit tougher

-9
Deliwoot•

Dumbass, they raised the PL requirement of the Prestige activities to beyond the base game level, meaning you can't play without the DLC

3
SVXfiles•

You most certainly can play those activities with a lower PL than what it says. You won't walk through it though

1
NameUser54321•

The product was given to you. You obtained (and still have) a license to access the game. There is nothing in the implied contract of purchase that says they are not allowed to change the game. Heck, they could completely revoke your license entirely (by banning you) and that would be completely legal.

-10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
ballingout2215•

Ea vs Bungie

11
RedditUserWho•

Bungi[EA]

19
selemena•

No matter who wins, we all lose.

4
trainstation98•

I think we have been going about all this microtransactions and lootboxes the wrong way. We are holding the wrong people accountable.

EA, Bungie and whoever else will keep doing it and we will forever be giving them bad publicity and they will just continue.

We can stop this much, much quicker by calling out two companies. We need to go straight to the source.

We need to call out Sony and microsoft on these issues. They own the platforms. They let these games operate on their consoles. They need to be held responsible for these predatory tactics game companies are using.

They claim to be for the players, they claim to be the platform for gaming. We need to hold them to that. We go after these two companies and all this nonsense will end just as quick as it begun. If they ban games that employ predatory tactics like Battlefront 2 and destiny and to an extent cod the gaming companies would stop this instantly.

We need to push them to regulate their platforms, they are the ones who should be protecting the kids, and be responsible for the games and content on their patform.

This is the only real way this will end, otherwise it will never stop.

10
joshmac313•

Fuck em

6
NinjaGotBeef•

Sure glad i never bought it

4†
dmessina55•

Can't your do a credit card charge back ?

2
HistoricalDebates•

Sony bans accounts that do that, even if someone steals your PSN and charges a bunch of stuff to your credit card. I remember this being mentioned before after a PSN hack

8
grabbag21•

That's hilarious that they think that is justified. They aren't giving you anything when something is stolen. It's 1's and 0's they transmit to your location. They lose no money from charge backs.

Edit: They do lose money from charge backs, for a company like Sony worth about $40 billion dollars it is a near zero value as part of their budget. If they had a reasonable refund policy regarding fraud cases they could save themselves 9/10ths what they lose from a chargeback. They unlike someone that ships a flat screen TV don't lose stock when they give a copy to a fraud for free.

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
grabbag21•

First off they don't lose $25 for the game. It's a nonphysical product that already was produced from sunken costs. Those are just opportunities that may or may not materialize.

Second if they are selling large quantities, such as the 1300 in this example, to a single purchaser they should do their due diligence and make sure it is a reputable buyer.

Third if they had accepted the guy's claim that it was stolen and worked with him rather than fighting it would have cost the company about 50 bucks and they learn their lesson about the second point. Merchants get charged for about 2% each direction of charges and returns. They decided to fight it and got a $30,000 bill for their trouble.

0
Heartlanta•

First of all, they do lose money on charge backs. Credit card companies take a percentage of each sale made, and not only does that not get refunded when the card companies bill you for the money owed from the chargeback, they tack on fees in addition to that. Then there’s the overhead of labor to deal with revoking user access to the content that they no longer actually paid for.

If you think that the “1s and 0s” of a game cost nothing, you’re naive. Not even mentioning the overhead of running the servers and internet connections to get you the content, there’s the absurdly high cost to develop, license, and market the product which rivals the cost of a large Hollywood production. It’d be like saying “you’re already putting on the production of your play, it doesn’t cost you extra to let me in for free, right?”. I get that the big companies are doing some shitty things with gaming recently, and they deserve to be punished for it. But to say that no money is lost on a chargeback is absurd.

1
grabbag21•

It is effectively 0. Its a rounding error for all the other overhead that comes with production and publishing games. Those are sunken costs that don't relate to the fraud. It doesn't relate to the fraud case but it doesn't cost the play anything extra to let you see the play for free if they could magically make more seats which is nearly what the bandwidth and electricity to transmit a few GB is.

1
ValidatingUsername•

Your analogy is completely off base.

Movies are directed and shot with perceived future profits. Just because the investors THINK the movie will make 200M does not mean that the consumers have to buy a ticket or endure a movie that doesn't live up to the title.

If I bought a transformers ticket and walked in to the theater to see the first 3 minutes match up frame by frame to the trailer and then lead into transformers erotica I would absolutely ask for my money back.

I did not pay for transformers erotica, and we created consumer laws for this very specific reason. It is ON THE BUSINESSES SHOULDERS to bare the weight of any financial burden of creating and maintaining their product for the life of the product. If that responsibility includes charge back fees from the company that takes payments for their product that is also included in the cost of doing business.

Selling a game and then turning off features is like buying a tesla, driving it for a year, and then having your software downgraded into the casual mode unless you pay the premium to maintain your regular experience. If this was not discussed at the formation of the contract upon purchasing the vehicle IT IS ILLEGAL.

1
grabbag21•

If all sales are final why did they change your game without your permission? They broke the all sales are final rule first.

2
Loharo•

That’s not really how it works for online games, otherwise we would never have balance patches or mini updates. You still have all the files sitting on your computer, they have no obligation to let you access their servers.

Property law has not really kept up with the digital age.

3
grabbag21•

I understand how it actually works I'm saying that the line they give you about it being a hands off situation after the sale is complete is phony. If access to their servers is part of the sale TOC then yes they do have to give you access.

2
ShadowwsOP•

It was mostly copy/paste scripted conversation from Sony. If there was a time stamp you could easily notice.

1
Crazy_Wulf•

Well sure, you used chat support for some reason......That is all they are trained to do.

3
SpikyC•

Just a thought here, they can't give you a refund, but can they provide you the DLC for free instead?

1
Darkone539•

Sony and free stopped being friends when they noticed they were kicking xbox's ass.

1
SpikyC•

If customer service really understand and can't proceed with a refund, well they should have.

1
richpage85•

This infuriates me... Sony will not refund the game as they are not the ones who are at fault. You can still pick up the game and play it through with the storyline. Bungie/Activision are the ones who have screwed people over by making the changes, THEY are the ones who should be dealt with.

The game is not totally unplayable, you can still have fun with it, so Sony are well within their rights to stick to their guns and not issue a refund based on their terms of service. Bungie/Activision are the ones who will have to break and issue one.

Sony would be liable if they change their service. As an example, they change their PS+ service, where you can ONLY play online if you get the upgraded Platinum tier. NOW it would be perfectly viable, as when you bought the game you only needed the regular PS+ subscription, not this new tier they will be forcing you to upgrade to.

I'm a manager in a game store, if anyone came in trying to do what you've just done to that customer service rep, I would definitely deny you a refund and not even offer to trade the game in. Your passive aggressive treatment was not warranted. I understand you're frustrated, but there is no need, no matter how many 'Its not you, it's Sony's you give out

1†
Darkone539•

Actually Sony have to give the go ahead on updates so they are at fault from that standpoint.

If you bought it through Sony they are also at fault. You're their customer under law not budgie's. You bought the product from their store.

I'm talking about how uk consumer law works (it's like this in the whole eu) but your contract is with where you bought the game not the developers. It's upto Sony to go back to budgie and say "wtf" to them.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
richpage85•

Sony are only the retailer, so yeah, if the product is defective or faulty, then yeah, a refund would be viable. When you buy a digital title, you purchase the license to download the game, which is held by Bungie/Activision.

Download of this product is subject to the PlayStation Network Terms of Service and our Software Usage Terms plus any specific additional conditions applying to this product. If you do not wish to accept these terms, do not download this product. See Terms of Service for more important information. One-time licence fee to download to multiple PS4 systems. Sign in to PlayStation Network is not required to use this on your primary PS4, but is required for use on other PS4 systems. See Health Warnings for important health information before using this product. Library programs ©Sony Interactive Entertainment Inc. exclusively licensed to Sony Interactive Entertainment Europe. Software Usage Terms apply, See eu.playstation.com/legal for full usage rights.

68 GB hard drive storage space required as of September 2017. Subject to change. Requires broadband internet. See www.destinythegame.com/size-requirements for current requirements prior to purchase. Significant elements and functionality require PlayStation® Plus subscription, sold separately.

Using the software constitutes acceptance of the Destiny Software License Agreement at http://support.activision.com/license. Activision may modify or discontinue online services without notice at any time.

© 2017 Bungie, Inc. All rights reserved. Destiny, the Destiny Logo, Bungie and the Bungie Logo are among the trademarks of Bungie, Inc. Published and distributed by Activision. Activision is a registered trademark of Activision Publishing, Inc.

So yeah... they even tell you that in the product description.

Also, under UK law, you only have 30 days to claim for a product as faulty or not fit for purchase and ask for a refund. After 30 days, the retailer can repair or replace. As every copy of Destiny will be the same... it's going to be with the manufacturer that will deal with it, as every copy of Destiny I give you would end up being the same.

Now as I said elsewhere... yes, Bungie/Activision have pulled a hell of a dick move, I agree. Putting the shit onto retailers employees is the wrong place to protest.

1
Birdmanbob05•

Good thing I never bought that trash

1

Welp time to chargeback

1
Tom2973•

They have banned people from PSN for that in the past.

1

Win/Win situation

1
ShakaZangief•

Wow this is getting so old. No one cared in D1 why should they care now...? Video game companies do what the fuck they want until the right source complains, no matter how much ppl bitch on social media.

1
Deeyennay•

No matter the context, I will never believe people that keep saying “believe me”.

1