ATTACK: You all missed the big thing about S.1241 (Modernizing AML Laws to Combat Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing). It criminalizes open mixers, which kills fungibility!
The recent post about S.1241 hit over 10k votes and over a thousand comments. I get that a bunch of people thought the attack was overstated, and that in their interpretation it only applied to a few financial institutions. Wrong! There is something new and bad in that bill. It makes running a TumbleBit server or a JoinMarket coordination server a regulated, trusted operation.
Bill S.1241 would amend the definition of ‘financial institution,’ in Section 5312(a) of title 31, United States Code, to include “an issuer, redeemer, or cashier of prepaid access devices, digital currency, or any digital exchanger or tumbler of digital currency.”
We need mixers, because we need fugibility for Bitcoin to be real money. Without that, two things will happen:
-
Coins from some hack will get blacklisted. Not at every service, but definitely at Coinbase (and Ms. Kathryn Haun Rodriguez will approve). But before the hack is even discovered, the hacker will have sold them! They will have planned out the pawn-off before executing the hack! Everyone else, knowing this type of thing may happen, will feel a severe chilling effect. You can imagine that, for large transactions, there will be a need to leave the transaction in limbo for a day so that hack reports can be unearthed, and coins checked against Chainalysis "Blockchain analysis". Whoops! Pretty soon we are all waiting 72 hours for settlement on a holiday, playing bankster AML/KYC games to simply buy a used car, and checking in constantly with centralized services...
-
The new millionares will stick out like sore thumbs, each coffee transaction pointing back to their net worth, acting as a big sign on them saying "kidnap me" and "try a targeted attack here". There will be a major chilling effect on making transactions with anyone who you didn't already trust to know your net worth. Pretty soon you are sending all transactions through a centralized corporation again. Now your personal safety depends on them not getting hacked. But they will get hacked (and they won't tell you for a few years)...
You see, this attack is too clever to say "fungibile bitcoins are illegal", because stolen fiat was made fungible hundreds of years ago, in order to make it usable. But that is what the attack is about.
Get back on hating that bill!
Posted Dec 10, 2017, 12:23 AM UTC
Couldn’t the tumbler server be ran offshore? This is basically what is being done with fiat, no?
Monero users not affected
Correct me if I'm wrong (I have very limited understanding of XMR) but doesnt monero mix inputs with other users by default and thats where the anonymity comes from? If thats the case, wouldnt that make every monero user affected by this? (as every monero user is providing a mixing service by default) I could see a lot of privacy-centric coins impacted by this, even though I seriously doubt this would pass anyway.
You're referring to ring signatures which are not exactly mixing but the effect is close enough ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_signature ). You can't tell where the coins came from, just like mixing, but the coins are not actually mixed.
The logic is that if everyone looks guilty, nobody is guilty. You can't realistically arrest everybody who ever used Monero, especially that usage is legal so far.
Monero uses 3 obfuscating features: stealth addresses ( the address to which the coins are sent is derived from your public address, but only you & the sender can tell that the stealth address belong to you), confidential transactions ( amounts are hidden ) and ring signatures ( coins can come from any of N randomly chosen outputs, but only the spender can tell which output is being spent).
Monero has advantages compared to Bitcoin but has drawbacks as well ( huge transactions, the UTXO set is essentially the whole blockchain ). I like them both, they have different use cases so I think that they complete each other.
That is my understanding as well. All monero users affected.
Discussion of the bill criminalizes concealment, which might mean they were planning to ask you about it, they way they do with FATCA. I'm not sure where the text of the bill makes that real.
I hear what you’re saying, but doesn’t the different address of each payment and change address of my HD wallet do the same thing?
Either way, if I’m asked, I can show my wallet’s transaction log with no intent to conceal, even though I may have obfuscated my path up until that point in which they asked.
You have to start with money that's fungible, otherwise it's an imperfect money, and might be replaced by something that really is fungible.
As long as bitcoin transactions don't start out anonymous enough, too obviously tied together, etc