r/changemyview•
srelma

CMV:High takes on rich does not lead to them working less but more

FTFdeltaOP

The standard argument for tax breaks for rich is that this will increase the amount they work and since they by definition have high productivity (otherwise they wouldn't be paid that much) this will increase the size of the economy and be good for everyone.

I don't believe this to be true. My main argument is that people have certain expenses that they have to cover, but once these have been covered, they are much more likely to trade income for more free time. The classic question is that if you won in lottery, would you continue working. If the answer is no, this means that the reason you wouldn't work is that you would have so much money that the extra income (even at the low tax rate) would not make any sense. If you answer yes, this is mainly because you like your work other reasons than your pay. And this is the reason I think motivates most highly paid people, not their net pay.

I remember around year 2000 the highest paid worker in Finland was the CEO of Nokia Jorma Ollila. I think his salary was of the order of tens of millions of euros. He once commented that at that point the motivation for his work comes from something else than the pay (mainly from challenge to build the best mobile phone company in the world).

The same logic doesn't necessarily apply to the low end of the pay scale. If you can get a decent living from the welfare without working, going to work at lousy salary for a job that doesn't interest you may not sound very appealing.

So, my argument is that if the most highly paid people get more of their salary to themselves (=low taxes), they are more likely at some point of their career come to a conclusion that they have enough money for anything they need and there's no need to get more and then they stop working or reduce the amount they work. If the taxes are high, this situation will come later as it takes longer to accumulate such wealth. If they work for other reasons than pay, then tax rate has no effect on how much they work. Also if their motivation to work is just to get as rich as possible, the tax rate doesn't matter as they will work as much as possible regardless of how much they are taxed.

So this applies inside one country. Between countries this does not apply. A country with a high tax rate can lose its highest paid workforce if a neighbouring country with similar living conditions offers much lower tax rates.

So, high taxes will not reduce the amount the work the rich people do, but can make them leave the country.


This is a footnote from the CMV moderators. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views**! Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!

Posted Dec 15, 2017, 5:20 PM UTC

342
Loading comments…