Ram speed

This was included in a larger performance topic but I thought it deserved its own.

As it turns out, pancake Fallout 4 fps was heavily dependent on ram speed (unlike most games), with significant performance increase at higher frequencies.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.techspot.com/amp/article/1171-ddr4-4000-mhz-performance/page3.html

But here's the kicker, just because you bought ram advertised for a particular speed, doesn't mean it comes set at that speed. Because I'm stupid, I just realized that my ddr4 3200 ram had been running at 2133 for the 2 years I've had my pc! (Possibly downclocked automatically by Asus Maximus viii mobo?)

Whatever the reason, I increased it to full speed. Although I didn't do any precise testing, i can confirm that i was able to bump my .ini SS by 0.2 for a similar amount of reprojection. Give it a shot!

Posted Dec 18, 2017, 12:38 PM UTC · edited

629
ChiefJohnson•

That is completly normal, ram boots up with basic values. You have to select a proper XMP profile to use its full potential.
Fallout 4 VR is more dependent than most other VR games on CPU/Ram. Usually, GPU is the most dominant part. But F4VR is a complex game, running this at frametimes of 11ms and lower also demands some CPU/Ram power.

3
royalcankiltdyaksmanVive•

Only true with DDR4 RAM, IIRC. DDR3 RAM runs at advertised clock speeds w/o XMP profiles.

Edit: Turns out that I didn't remember correctly.

1
HappierShibe•

This is not true.
DDR3 Ram, can but rarely does run at specified clocks without configuration in bios.

2
Oddzball•

Is this true?? I dont think so, at least not with my MB.

1
ReasonabledwarfVive•

Not necessarily; I know my DDR3 required an overclock to reach advertised speeds, but I can't recall exactly what the situation was. I think my board detected it but required confirmation to go above standard clocks.

1
KDLGatesVive•

frametimes of 11ms and lower

Unfortunately, if I disable asynchronous reprojection and enable always-on reprojection, which in theory should give FO4 at least the ability to be much less CPU limited, I get severe judder in intense areas (outdoors in cities, Diamond City, etc) on a slightly overclocked 1080 GTX GPU.

It's frustrating because always-on reprojection appears to run so well indoors, etc., but I fell back on asynchronous reprojection.

Any advice on breaking the 11ms constraint? It seems like a miracle the game runs as well as it does, to be honest. It's a complete Wasteland simulator ffs!

I'm trying out the Texture Optimization mod soon in the hopes that it makes the difference between always-on repro. being an option vs. it having too much judder.

1
intoxxx•

I have a 1070 and a 2500k running at 4.7 ghz right now.

I'm still in Concord, but at 0.9 render scale, I was able to turn reprojection off entirely and get only an occasional missed frame, or turn always on for a pretty much perfect(no judder) experience.

Mind you, it was ugly as all fuck and I haven't tested any heavy areas in the game with it, but it definitely was smooth.

I had followed the Permafix thread by copying his ini tweaks and then used the following three mods:

*Texture Optimization Pack

*Insignificant Object Remover.esp

*No More Mist - No DLC Version.esp

Like I said, I'm also at 0.9 render scale and 1.0 SS, so it's ugly as hell, but I imagine with a 1080Ti you can use that as a starting point and work upwards. (not to mention my below min spec CPU and lowly 8gb of 1666mhz)

1
KDLGatesVive•

I appreciate the guidance. I applied the texture mod (TOP) and I've convinced myself the textures are slightly uglier (I'm a pessimist -- most say they notice little to no difference), but I enjoy the performance boost.

What were your impressions from the object and mist removing mods re: fidelity/performance changes?

I tried again after applying the TOP mod, but unfortunately the judder is still too significant for me so I returned to async.

Actually, if I'm honest, it's probably because I changed the render scale to 1.2. I just enjoy having clarity in the distance so much... :P If it comes down to light supersampling vs. always-on, I'll probably err towards SS, especially since I'm enjoying the performance now after applying TOP and that other poster's .ini file.

1
neuron_controlVive•

So I tried to check this using CPU-Z, this is what I got:

https://imgur.com/a/4SGzl

What do you make of this? What should I do? Sorry for the newb questions this is all new to me!

My mobo is a ASUS Z97-A btw

2
imguralbumbot•

^(Hi, I'm a bot for linking direct images of albums with only 1 image)

https://i.imgur.com/kbsWHID.png

^^Source ^^| ^^Why? ^^| ^^Creator ^^| ^^ignoreme ^^| ^^deletthis

2
Beepboopbob1OP•

The actual operating frequency is double the DRAM frequency, so you have DDR3 RAM running at 1600 MHz, which is pretty low for this game. If its rated higher than that then it is not operating at full speed. Since they didn't test DDR3, I'm not sure how much of an fps increase you could expect by increasing the speed, but it would probably be decent. On the other hand, if you upgraded to some fast DDR4 ram and the rest of your system is beefy, the difference would probably be huge. That's one of the advantages of DDR4, much higher clock speeds.

1
neuron_controlVive•

I just popped a memory module out and I have Corsair VengeanceDDR3 1600Mha, so maybe it's time for a memory upgrade. I have a Z97 mobo though which doesn't support DDR4 RAM.

1
XXLpeanutsVive•

I have the same dilema to upgrade my ram I either have to waste money on faster ddr3 or buy a new mobo and rebult my pc.

1
KDLGatesVive•

Sadly, this is the price. FO4VR is literally bleeding edge right now in terms of gaming hardware, both in terms of expense and hassle.

1
lenne0816Oculus•

That is very fast ddr3 at just cl9, afaik one of the fastest mainstream ddr3s you can get, do a mem bandwidth test and use that for comparisons.

1
UndeadCaesarVive•

If anybody can help me out here, I benchmarked my RAM and this is what I got with UserBenchmark. Looks like I'm in the middle of lower bellcurve for my RAM. I changed my XMP profile in BIOS to 3200Mhz, which should be what it's capable of, but it keeps being recognized as 2133Mhz.

Link to my benchmark.

 

edit: Picture of my BIOS settings.

 

edit2: Ok what the hell, it just crashed on load and now says 2133. But still says 3200 up top. I'm so confused.

 

edit3: Ok, computer won't boot when I apply the XMP profile. Will only boot in 'Auto.'

 

edit4: tried disabling my CPU OC and enabling XMP, still not booting.

 

edit5: set XMP back to 'Auto' but manually turned the clock to 3200Mhz. It worked! I've had this computer for two years now, holy hell how am I only just now doing this. Going to try re-enabling my CPU OC. Can anybody who knows let me know if clocking to 3200Mhz without enabling the XMP profile is harmful? Like did some other settings that should have changed, stayed the same?

 

edit6: Holy moly thank you OP! New benchmark. Hoping I see a huge difference in FO4VR, but even if not I should see a jump in everything else!

2
lenne0816Oculus•

Funny how the curve shows almost a third of the people dont run the xmp profile on their ram, they could have all saved some money and just bought plain 2133 ram :D

1
Beepboopbob1OP•

NP, glad to help!

We're you able to do any actual in game tests to compare performances?

1
UndeadCaesarVive•

I haven't been able to get in-game yet to test it out, going to run a full 3DMark benchmark as well to see how it stacks up. Do you know why my computer wouldn't boot when I applied the XMP profile but was able to boot when I had XMP in Auto and manually moved the clock to 3200Mhz?

1
xxTheGoDxxOculus•

Not trying to piss on your parade, especially since your tip should actually improve performance.

RAM speed should do zero for the amount of SS you can have. SS / render scale / resolution is only determined by your graphic cards raw performance and the memory bandwidth / amount of VRAM, but not by your main RAM's memory bandwidth or CPU speed.

1
lenne0816Oculus•

albeit true in many cases this could very well work like this: 10% reprojected frames due to cpu not feeding gpu fast enough for 90fps, 10% because gpu on its own not hitting 90 fps. Ram speeds make the the 10% cpu repro go away, can be traded for higher ss levels.

2
Beepboopbob1OP•

I didn't change anything else. I guess it could've been the placebo effect, as i said i didn't perform any tests.

So then what display settings would higher ram speed help with?

1
xxTheGoDxxOculus•

So then what display settings would higher ram speed help with?

Honestly, not completely sure, especially since RAM based improvements are really seldom. In general though it should help with stuff that is CPU related, like render distance or the amount of grass visible.

1
turbonutter666•

Might get extra 2fps at a push

1
KDLGatesVive•

This is slightly off topic, but I have a RAM speed problem with my Vive (almost certainly due to the motherboard, an ASUS Z170-A).

The RAM works perfectly in every other application, but when I use the XMP profile in combination with the Vive, the Vive loses tracking ("grey screen of death") consistently and within seconds. I struggled with this a lot before giving up and running with downclocked RAM, and then I have perfect tracking.

Steps tried included updating the motherboard BIOS, chipset drivers and installing an add-on USB 3.0 controller card/ports.

By any miracle, does anyone out there have a suggestion for this problem?

1
Beepboopbob1OP•

Shot in the dark... have you ran a memory test on the ram?

1
KDLGatesVive•

Good suggestion.

Yes, I downloaded a memory test and it passed (no errors on the XMP profile).

1