"Good Praxis"
archive.is/PCxytPosted Dec 21, 2017, 4:09 PM UTC
Posted Dec 21, 2017, 4:09 PM UTC
Downvote harder, narchos.
Or maybe, just maybe, you shouldn't feel the need to sally forth on the internet to defend fucked up shit like campaigns of terror against the working class.
Who the fuck would even disagree with us on this?
Anarchists
Anarchists are idiots, but i have the slightest bit of hope, that they aren't this horrible...
poisoning drinks will totally show "the living dead"(meaning proles) how bad the system and "consumerism" is. continuing the trend of other "green/eco-anarchists".
What the fuck? That's so messed up.
Dies from HCl "Yeah that'll show em!"
Very insurrectionary...killing members of the working class. Green anarchists are consistently awful.
Killing children in the name of militant veganism is the only true revolutionary action.
It's not authoritarian if the people murder each other instead of the state!
Holy fuck.
And they're supposed to be morally superior here?
Why would anyone think that this is a good idea? This is fucked up beyond belief!
Anarchists
This is so mess up, fuck these people and their shitty ideology.
How to "spread class consciousness", expanding brain edition:
ONLY THROUGH DEATH AND MERGING OF THE SOUL WITH THE GREAT ABOLETH UNDER THE SEA CAN TRUE CLASS CONSCIOUSNESS BE REACHED
Holy fucking shit WHY???.
Just why would you fucking do that!?
"Christmas Poisoning campaign"
Nah m8 were the most moral lads come on we the good guys here.
Holy shit! What the hell are they even trying to get out of this other than killing innocent proles? When are the news of hundreds of kids dying after drinking acid coming?
Insurrectionists worry me so much.
[removed]
Hydrochloric acid isn't a poison, it's an acid. No one will actually be able to consume the substances, and even if they did it wouldn't actually kill anyone. It's as stupid as it is evil.
Don't assume that HCl isn't harmful just because the stomach can handle a 0.5% concentration of HCl.
Hydrochloric acid is a clear, poisonous liquid. It is highly corrosive, which means it immediately causes severe damage, such as burning, on contact.
This article discusses poisoning due to swallowing or breathing in hydrochloric acid.
...
Outlook (Prognosis)
How well a person does depends on the amount of poison swallowed and how quickly treatment was received. The faster a person gets medical help, the better the chance for recovery.
The person may need to stay in the hospital for more treatment. Swallowing poison can have severe effects on many parts of the body. Extensive damage to the mouth, throat, and stomach are possible. Holes (perforations) in the esophagus and stomach may result in serious infections in the chest and abdominal cavities, which may result in death. Surgery may be needed to repair the perforations. Cancer of the esophagus is a high risk in people who live after ingesting hydrochloric acid.
Depending on how loose your definition of poison is, even water can be a poison. Yes, HCl can cause large damage to especially internal organs, but it will not kill you in the same way HCN, HF, Mercury salts, and various heavy metals will. Yes, you can get infections from ruining your stomach by drinking acid, but that could also happen if you were stabbed or ate magnets or whatnot. It can also ruin your throat and cause massive burning, just like boiling water. Drinking boiling water would have a very similar effect but is not, of course, poison. There's a reason HCl is so widely used even in classrooms from high school and up, you need to be exceedingly clumsy to suffer permanent injury, and exceedingly unlucky as well to die from it.
Now, of course, drinking something without you knowing it is dangerous is a whole other beast, granted. However, anyone smelling the milk or Cola or whatnot will instantly recognise it is bad, and even those that were to instantly drink it will quickly spit it out. However, the syringe on the picture looks like a 5mL one. That syringe filled with laboratory grade 10 M HCl, which I think they would struggle to buy, would only really make the cola as acidic as stomach acid, which anyone that has thrown up will know is rather tame, though uncomfortable.
If you were to actually make this as acidic as house cleaners and such, you would need it to be about 10-20% by volume. This would require 90 syringes worth of acid if it was laboratory grade. The 1.5 L bottle would then contain 2 litres. Yes, HCl is dangerous, more so if a person is ingesting it without knowing, but to call it a poison is rather misleading and kinda lazy instead of calling it what it actually is a strong acid. The worst that can happen if someone were to drink that Cola is they would end up in the emergency ward. The most likely thing that could happen if someone were to just dip their hand in, say, HF, a weak acid but also a poison, let alone drink it, would be death a few weeks later. The latter would be poisoned and die, the former would be hurt and injured.
Edit: no school or university would let their students play around with a genuine poison, you would need a bachelor or beyond to really get access to those chemicals, and only then if you were specializing in something like organometallic chemistry or certain forms for organic chemistry. Hydrochloric acid, however, is not regarded as a poison, just dangerous, like boiling water, which is also handed out to students regularly. Also, I didn't assume that HCl isn't dangerous because we have acid in our stomachs, I did because I am currently studying chemistry.
Is there some rigid definition to "poison"? Even water intoxication is sometimes called water poisoning. From what I understand, lethality isn't a requirement--for example certain kinds of poisonous mushrooms won't kill you, but rather just give you a very bad day.
Paracelsus' definition made in the 1500s encompasses literally everything, it's just that the dose is the killer. Such a definition doesn't really help to distinguish between different kinds of harmful substances. I really don't see, however, how calling HCl a poison really accomplishes anything besides being confusing and making actual poisons seem less scary than what they actually are. HCl will just damage you until your body suffers too much damage in one spot. An actual poison will often have a delayed response, make it so a central function of your body ceases to work, and have a set of symptoms that are quite distinct. One would have to call knives, boiling water, nails, and what not poison if we were to use the same definition as is used on HCl, which I find quite silly.
Other definitions try to be more precise and say it's "Any substance dangerous to living organisms that if applied internally or externally, destroy the action of vital functions or prevent the Continuance of life." which makes it so that things like knives don't apply. Still, things like boiling water or even iron ingots would then be classified as poisons since an iron ingot applied externally on the head will certainly destroy some vital functions.
Wikipedia shows a few different definition, but it also specifies that "Absorption of a poison is necessary for systemic poisoning. In contrast, substances that destroy tissue but do not absorb, such as lye, are classified as corrosives rather than poisons.". It would be prudent to stop using poison then, and use a more fitting title, like corrosive or strong acid for HCl. In my opinion, the word poison should not be used as an adjective to make something seem more scary, as it cheapens the word. That's not to say several titles can't be used, things like aqueous HF should be called both corrosive and poisonous.
I just think that the term "poison" has been used way to much to describe way too many things. As it is used now, like in this thread, it serves no purpose.
Jesus fucking Christ what a bunch of psychopaths