What's your favourite jumping puzzle?
...and your least favourite?
Posted Dec 23, 2017, 6:20 AM UTC
...and your least favourite?
Posted Dec 23, 2017, 6:20 AM UTC
Most favorite: Hidden Garden. Honorable mention: Abaddon's Ascent.
Least favorite: Not So Secret. Honorable mention: Chalice of Tears.
Oh man, screw Not So Secret. What a horrendously designed jumping puzzle that grasps deep within the cauldrons of the Mist in order to torture and terrorize would-be adventurers. I have so many nightmares of this particular jumping puzzle, I dare not return to it after completing it. If I ever have a mortal enemy, I would force him to continually play this particular one for the rest of his life.
First, getting into the puzzle is a hassle. Before entering the general area of the puzzle, you have to climb through a disguised wall that clips just right so that part of the wall is an invisible wall. This would not be a major problem except for the multitude of deaths involved later, sending you over and over again through this passage. It takes a while to get through the two corridors alone.
Next, the moment you enter the main stage, the chest is right there. Right in front of you to mock you incessantly every time you pop back from the dead to the start of the jumping puzzle. Your increasing failure is presented right in front of its face. It knows you have failed in its domain, and so do you.
Then, you have all these ranged enemies everywhere. These Aetherblade mobs will aggro you into combat mode, effectively reducing your walk speed and screwing up with your jumping routine. Moreover, some of them have the capability to root you in place, so there is a certain spot in the puzzle that could get worse.
In all this, the height of the jumping puzzle does not build on top of itself. As a result, many of the jumps made will be to your demise. If you fail a jump, you die, sending you all the way back to the waypoint outside of the jumping puzzle.
And after all this, the air launchers are not currently in sync. If you went for the Diving goggles, you know that the ones all the way at the top overshoot naturally. As a result, you plummet all the way down, hoping—just hoping—that you land in a puddle that can fit your oversized chromedome Charr/Norn that you proudly flaunt in Wintersday Wonderland. In order to not overshoot, I learned that weapon swapping allows your character to halt soon enough so that you do not get launched to Elona (sorry to all those Ele out there).
On the last note, the Diving Goggles at the end is super bad. Because the platform that contains the goggles intentionally clip through a portion of the mountain, you have to make a blind leap of faith into a small hole containing water to get the achievement. Failure means getting booted all the way back to the waypoint, making sure you face all the aforementioned challenges once more.
oh my god, this is such legit gamer salt. I feel you every step of the way on this one. I only wanted the diving achievement and honestly, if a superhero of a patient mesmer hadn't been willing to rez and teleport me constantly to the top to try again and again (and again... and again) I never would have been able to do it. fuck how this JP is years old and the physics with the launchers at the VERY TOP still haven't been fixed.
thank you for describing exactly what i, a low level noob around the time when it was released, faced
huh
i must really love this game if i stuck around after all that...
I can live with everything you mentioned. But then there’s invariably someone who thinks it’s a great idea to give out AoE swiftness just as I’m setting up for a jump...
I absolutely agree with that. Hidden garden is beautiful and has both jumping and puzzles in it. Not so secret is straight up cancer.
Just going to say it: Not so Secret is my favorite.
...but its a lonely opinion. :(
Favourite: The Silverwastes JP and Abaddon's Ascent. I really love jumping puzzles that are like, actual puzzles where it's less about platforming and more about figuring out where to go and how to get up there. Exploring the top of the Silverwastes while below me the meta came and went and the vinewrath groups succeeded and failed was one of my favourite experiences in GW2.
Least favourite: Mad King's Clock Tower and Wintersday. Yeah, I hate platforming.
I forgot about the Silverwastes JP. That would actually be a contender for my least favorite (no offense). There are just too many long, dead ends that you can't even tell are dead ends. For something with more of a "puzzle" aspect, I liked Searing Ascent (Draconis Mons) much more, though there were still a couple of decisions I didn't like.
Yeah, it was quite time consuming so I don't blame you if you didn't like it. That was what I loved about it though, sometimes the trail would disappear and I've have no idea if I was still on the right track. And then I'd pick up on it again much later, or I'd have to decide that I went wrong somewhere and backtrack. It was a little like being lost in the woods, in a good way.
I actually haven't done Searing Ascent yet so I'll have to give it a try! Thanks for the suggestion.
Yeah 100% the silverwastes one for me also. Its HUGE, takes you across half of the map, its really nicely themed, and challenging but not in a cheesy way (like scraping pixel ledges and invisible walls).
Except for that ending. That is cheap.
Yes! There was a sense of wonder and exploration to it that felt really natural.
The most favorite is the one in which the Mesmer participates.
The old Lion's Arch jumping puzzle where it had a troll at the end!
I remember finding the entrance by dropping down into that chimney into the water, that was cool.
chimney
krytan royalty are spinning in their graves
i hate it when chimneys drop me down into water
but ye, it was a good jp
Man, the new LA is cool, but I have awesome memories from old LA. Blew my mind when I saw it in the first BWE 2012. People were finding a fountain and they went up the staira to drop in and they found a jumping puzzle. Another JP they discovered in LA where the entrance looked like a mouth with teeht that you could slide down. Fuckin awesome
That thing was a nightmare in terms of camera control though.
Was a great memory because of the camera in the cave. I took my norn through the jp thinking it'd be no problem..
I really miss that one
Oh yeah! That was great, is that really not possible to do anymore? Like does it feature in the old story instances or anything?
It was replaced by Troll’s Revenge.
An old guildmate used to make up a story every time we did that JP, so it has a special place in my memory. It was fun to look for shortcuts in that one, although it was a real nightmare if you had a tall/large character.
My two favorties are Obsidian Sanctum and Mad Kings Clock Tower. Not sure about my least favorite...I like all of them.
Something so silly such as the one in Fireheart rise. I can't even say why, but i love it. I also like Spekks's Laboratory in Caledon Forrest. And last Goemm's Lab in Metrica Province. I think that is the one jp i had the most fun doing the first time. We were a bunch of friends jumping it and i did not even have the time to be frustrated it was just giggle all the way.
JP i will never jump on my own again, Not So Secret, Chalice of Tears and the one in Obsidian Sanctum. They are all great jumping puzzles, but i will never run them ever again. It is a huge risk that i toss my pc out the window or get a heart attack of raging.
Honorable mention: The Clock tower. And not so much that it is hard to jump it, but the fact that when i learn to jump a puzzle i do jump, fall, jump, fall, jump, fall and so on until i get the flow and manage. In clocktower it is jump, fall, wait for 10 min before i can jump again, which drives me nuts and there is no way i will get the flow on that jp as long as it is gated. So i just ignore it. I would love to manage it at some point, but this year i did not even make at least one try. So probably will never happen.
Everything with "Lab" in the title is pretty good
My favorite JP is whichever one happens to be the daily. Thank you from the bottom of my heart, ye dedicated Mesmers.
I just plain suck at jumping puzzles. Under New Management, Urmag, and Weyandt are pretty much the extent of my skill level.
My favourites has got to be either:
Scavenger's Chasm - it's daunting at first, but once learned, I really appreciate how it's different and the fact it's not one giant linear path, but more of a jumping scavenger hunt - and with water beneath most of it, it's not as frustrating if you miss you a jump as it is in other ones.
Silverwastes one - the one that takes above and below most of the Silverwastses, for its length without being too annoying or feeling cheap. This one was just really enjoyable to do.
Those are two great puzzles and my favorites as well. I really dislike Chaos Crystal Cavern (even though I can do it, I dislike the jerkiness of being size changed...) and of course Not So Secret can die in a fire - it's my last diving achievement, cannot find any help on it, tried it myself, got up there, face planted on a steel beam. Gave up.
I dont heve it,hate them :p
favorite : halloween clock tower
least favorite : not so secret aka aetherblade jp by far, chalice doesnt even come close
honorable mention : sab tribulation mode, it is the best thing ever :D
Favourite: Wintersday JP. I find it really relaxing to do!
Least favourite: Chalice of Tears. I never finished it the legit way because none of the checkpoints would trigger for me, although they did for my friends. And I really, really hated the guesswork that went into completing it.
I loove the Silverwastes jumping puzzle! Its not so much about jumping as it is about figuring out where to go + it is beautifully done aesthetics wise. Going from cave to cave, to the outside, above where players are fighting. The final cave and the lighting is amazing + it has a whimsical story. :) The one in Siren's Landing is fun as well as the one in Draconis Mons. Though the one in Draconis Mons can be incredibly frustrating at the end haha. Can't count how many times I hit the ceiling and got bounced back down...
Least favorite is probably Chalice of Tears.
SW JP was great until there was gliding. Don't know why they never disabled it.
Might be because of the size of the jumping puzzle. I figure it'd be incredibly tedious to disable gliding specifically within the jumping puzzle but enable it within the rest of the sw, especially how close the two are at times.
I don't think they even could. I'm pretty sure "gliding disabled" is a border that extends the full height and depth of the area within the border. So you'd have a huge percentage of SW riddled with borders where people get thrown off their gliders. Doesn't sound fun.
Yeah. It definitely made it a lot easier. Though tbh it didn't change all that much except in the final ascent as falling revived you anyway.
i never attempted that one on my own without a guide until i had mounts
I love all JPs honestly, but Not So Secret became quite annoying because I was trying to get to the goggles. Can pretty much do it in my sleep now since I've spent so much time there. I do like all of the Wintersday routes, platforming is fun to me :D
Favourite is still probably clocktower, although winter wonderland maybe for the 30g+ easy gold and hour doing something i enjoy.
Least favourite. Probably demon grub pits
My favorite one is the asura lab in the sky in Metrica. It's the first one i discovered when i started gw2.
The one i like the least must be chalice of tears in ember bay because it doesn't really feel like a jumping puzzle. Too much gliding and weird paths to find.
Favourite... I've got some fond memories of Not So Secret from when I was new. Breachwall Blitz is pretty solid, and I liked Drydock Scratch as well, though I can't see myself repeating it. Maybe SAB World 1 Tribulation Mode, if that counts.
Least favourite, easily Skip Up the Volcano. That's not a jumping puzzle, it's an exercise in blindly throwing yourself off of various rocks until you happen to stumble on the way forward, only to do it all again from that point.
Yes! A fellow Not so Secret fan!
favorite: either the one in Silverwastes or the one in Siren's Landing
least favorite: Chalice of Tears. i'm fine with difficulty, but it's just difficult for the sake of being difficult, and that difficulty only really comes from lack of information, like "can i land there, or will i slip off?"
I will always have a special place in my heart for Morgan's Spiral. It was the first one I stumbled across with my baby sylvari, and it's just as beautifully infused with the Sylvari aesthetic as everything else in Caledon Forest. Figuring out that we had to beat the dynamic event to make the flower spiral open, and then work your way up, with the magical floating rocks... there was just a real sense of wonder and discovery. (And then, yes, a lot of cursing with the discovery that most JPs have at least a few jumps that are pretty fiendish). So I have a lot of nostalgia for that one.
Favorite: Abbadon's Ascent because it was one of the new, giant puzzles that was actually solvable in a reasonable way by a single person as they do the puzzle. It became a bit too easy with mounts, though.
Least Favorite: Chalice of Tears, for the opposite reason of the above. Too many blind glides and glitchy geometry humping to be any fun.
I found Abbadon’s Ascent by accident, and was like “I bet I could get to the top!” Never even realized it was a JP until I hit the first checkpoint, but definitely needed a guide for that blind glide near the top.
Chalice of Tears is the one in Ember Bay, right?
Because... was this designed this way intentionally? It doesn't feel it. It feels like they discovered level geometry you could walk on, placed some chests, and called it a jumping puzzle. There's barely any telegraphing on where to even go which is a massive contrast from any other JP I've done so far... I see why this is a least favourite so frequently. It honestly feels worse than badly designed, it feels like it wasn't even designed to be a JP especially with the way the geometry looks and the way you have to play Slope Roulette, where good luck is not sliding off and bad luck is sliding off, and... I don't think that should be happening in a JP of all places.