Per_LevyOP•

while this movement has a huge popular base and we should support it, it is nowhere near revolutionary and is being driven by the same kind of reactionary burgeoisie that rules Spain, they just have a different flag.

they are reactionary, they are the same as the other just under another flag but we must support them anyway

Podemos has completely abandoned it's responsibility to campain for socialism.

a social democratic party doesnt care about socialims who would've thunk

We all knew this would happen. We also all know that Puigdemont cannot lead Catalonia to independence. While worker, farmers, and even the Catalan police resisted the Guardia Civil and the Francoist crackdown, Puigdemont and the bourgeois leadership refused to take a firm stance on independence.

ah trots and their leadership fetish "this nationalistic stupidity can only be achieved with us in power"

"What is the relevance to socialism of this vote?" good question, lets see the see the leftist response:

Respecting democracy seems relevant to socialism.

does that imply respecting the trump gouverment? the tory gouverment?

The communist manifesto calls for communists and socialists to support revolutionary movements against the establishment anywhere and everywhere. Thus a move toward self-determination represents a tearing down of the old order and should be supported by marxists. Of course people may disagree. Thats just Marx's take.

"thats just marx take" they say, meaning "this is my opinion but i want to make that opinion sound authorative" of course nowhere in the manifesto is there a section where workers should support a bourgeoisie that wants to be independent to pay less taxes. also nothing about the independence movement in catalonia is revolutionary.

The issue is that JuntsxCat (formerly PDeCat, formerly CDC, formerly CiU) proposes an independence program that appeals to the middle class, which allows the ERC-CatSí and CUP-CC to take working class votes from the PSC-PSOE and JuntsxCat to take middle class votes from Ciudadanos and the PP. So even though the neoliberal JuntsxCat may be just as corrupt as the unionist parties, I think it’s an important alliance to keep alive until independence is achieved. Post-independence, I think that the ERC-CatSí and CUP can campaign hard for radical change and that Catalonia will hopefully respond correctly.

translation: "the workers have to subordinate their struggle so the allience for another bourgeois republic can stay alive, the left(as usual) is to help in that aspect. after the independence they can ask for stuff any maybe some nice reforms will be made but whatever independence is more important then class struggle anyway"

going step by step is better than not doing anything.

playing the bourgeois game, on bourgeois terrain, will surly end in socialist catalonia, of course that has never worked ever in the history but this time it will be different, promised...

By "ignoring" you mean claiming self-determination right? Its a basis of socialism...

self-determination of non-proles = basis of socialism....

Good news: The conservative and social democratic pro-independence parties need the CUP (the anti-capialist, pro-independence party) for their majority. Hopefully we can see a bit of a leftist shift in Catalonia

or as it usually the case, the left will abandon everything to not break the coalition.

39
NotADinnerParty•

This post made me love this subreddit

1
MirandaTS•

Podemos has completely abandoned it's responsibility to campain for socialism.

Damn, I can't understand why these social democrats keep betraying us! Another $27 down the drain.

26
Dashiznik•

600+ upvotes

God bless r/succ, the whole mass appeal approach of the sub to 'raise consciousness' is really doing wonders for the quality of posts. Gotta pull every idiot into orbit who feels the need to slap labels on themselves which are becoming increasingly meaningless.

So much for class struggle.

22
mattjmjmjm•

r/supportbourgeoisiemovements

16