PKK has announced a self-administration in parts of Soran region in Erbil province and Pishdar region in Sulimania that they control because 'KRI experience is a failure'; they are copying Northern Syria 's system in the new self-rule area. Kurdistanprotests PKK
iraq.liveuamap.com/en/2017/25-december-pkk-ha...Posted Dec 25, 2017, 4:13 PM UTC
5814
It will be interesting to see just how much support they have.
Different scales, but it will be interesting to see how Baghdad reacts in comparison with how it reacted to the KRG ref.
In a region like Soran, which has been very far away from most of the fighting, it's much more difficult to make the argument that this move to dramatically restructure local government is as legitimate as it is in Sinjar. Then again, maybe it is the wishes of the population. These things are difficult to ascertain off-the-cuff.
KRG is a mess, but it's still a relatively democratic structure (even if not in practice). Then again, it might work if they set up district councils that feed directly into the KRG. Unless these areas just get re-incorporated into Iraq and function a bit like federal regions. But they're not very populated, so that seems unlikely.
Interesting situation to watch.
[removed]
In northern Syria they most definitely have a lot of support. In the KRG? No, not at all. But saying they don’t have support in the DFNS is just plain wrong.
I don't really see any indicators for that support. Quite literally the only sources which repeatedly propagate how much 'support' KCK and YPG enjoys in Northern Syria are KCK's propaganda outlets and mouthpieces, chiefly ANF, ANHA and Hawar. On the contrary, third party observers that can be deemed natural, credible and reliable often indicate that Arab majority towns YPG took over give them the impression of being under an invasion.
Only places in Northern Syria that KCK might be enjoying some resemblance of popular support are the nominally Kurdish majority towns, as the Kurds might genuinely lend support towards KCK out of a sense of Kurdish nationalism. The core tenet of KCK (going back to the days when it was established as the PKK) has always been Kurdish nationalism, and despite the narratives they propagate for the outsiders to receive support in European and Western public, facts from the ground (such as how every structure KCK establishes is dominated by Kurdish leadership) show us that it remains to be the case.
The only opposition they have is with conscription and some isolated stuff where Ba'thists want to keep their curriculum. Other than that, people vote in the elections without controversy, commerce continues and life goes on without incident. They've provided true security and are not oppressive and mostly stand for the locals' interests, so there does indeed seem to be many indicators for local support.
So a hundred people in Manbij evading conscription and some teachers in Hasakah not wanting to teach Kurdish and Syriac along Arabic is proof that PYD doesn't have popular support?
bro you should actually follow the war instead of making this stuff up. You can hate them however much you like but saying that the PYD has no support among Northern Syrians is just ridiculous.
I guess that is why almost half of the population has left their lands.
Amazing. It’s like there’s a war or something. Which would explain why half of Syria’s population is displaced.
TIL there's no war in Syria
Then nobody is supported. There are 5 million+ people who left Syria.
You are mistaken if you think idealogy has anything to do with Kurdish politics. It’s all about who’s popular and which group has your family members in it.