With “The Last Jedi,” “Star Wars” has chosen a side in the class war.
theintercept.com/2017/12/24/star-wars-last-je...Posted Dec 27, 2017, 6:20 PM UTC
Posted Dec 27, 2017, 6:20 PM UTC
Reasons why leftists like The Last Jedi:
Great man theory: It’s everywhere, and has been since the beginning of Star Wars. The protagonists exist in a world incapable of change without their direct intervention. Without Luke and Co., the galaxy far, far away would’ve been in complete stasis. This is addressed somewhat in the new movie, and seemingly rejected on a ideological level, but is reinforced by the story just as much as ever.
Idealism: In Star Wars, the dream of a New Republic fuels all revolution. It’s implicit in the original trilogy, and explicit in The Last Jedi. Someone, I believe Leia, makes the statement that ‘if the Old Republic is forgotten, so is the resistance.’ Not to mention the child-jockey looking down at the rebel signet ring before finding the courage to flee his tormentor at the end of the movie. Even on the level of the individual, ideas are everything. And not just any ideas, but reactionary ideas; the goal of the Resistance is to roll back the clock to an idealized vision of the past.
The fact that the Empire grew from the processes of the Old Republic seems lost on the rebels. I’m reminded of the 18th Brumaire here, ‘first as tragedy, then as farce.’ Much like the leftists, the Rebellion clearly is in need of Marx.
Moralism: Throughout eight movies in the primary story and multiple additional films set in the Star Wars universe, the primary motivation to resist the Empire is that it is evil. In what way? It’s not clear. On all the worlds of the Empire, life seems to go on now as it did under the Republic in the prequel trilogy. Materially, nothing seems to be terribly different. There were morally repugnant people of power under the Old Republic as there are under the Empire. What has changed, however, is that the supreme leader of the Empire (and now the New Order) is, himself, outwardly evil and that he rejects democracy. But does this matter to the average prole desert planet junker? I can’t see why it would.
Simply put, the revolution in Star Wars is both bourgeois and reactionary. It’s characters fall for the same traps as the leftists though, so of course they see class struggle in it.
In my opinion, Yoda was probably the most revolutionary character in the film. He destroyed the Jedi teachings and force tree to sort of signify that the age of Sith and Jedi is over.
The only thing I could think of watching that part of the movie is thinking "if the rebels win nothing will change, just the flag", which the thief dude confirms by showing the arms dealers deal with both sides. They'll be fine by the end of the war and those kids will still be slaves. As a side note that entire subplot destroyed the pacing of what I believe is the longest Star Wars movie. Didn't help that I needed to pee through half of it.
Star Wars, the galactic adventures of the antifascist front! Class collaboration on every planet in the name of "hope"! No interplanetary positions here. Shit Bordiga predicted the prequel plot of democracy giving away to fascism. Something apparently only Luke is aware of. And the Rebels are fools who think only of restoring democracy.
Let's take this to even more overanalysed levels: Luke is ripped away from his farm, becoming a proletarian who symbolizes "a new hope". No but seriously Star Wars movies are just a commodities they have no hidden anti-capitalist message whatsoever.
That was already shown in TFA. Nothing is more clear than the fact that in canon, the Rebellion's final victory over the Empire occurred in the battle of Jakku, yet look at the conditions we find Rey in at the beginning of TFA. I mean that's when the Star Destroyer she scavenges from crashed onto the planet. The Rebellion was a failure and bourgeois movement that ultimately accomplished nothing.
But the way the film is written (and its viewers) don't really view it as such because the sequel trilogy is a poorly written, disjointed mess that doesn't really understand its own implications. Also it is a cash grab and a commodity that everyone wants to attach their pet ideology to for some reason.
meh, early George Lucas was at the very least a weird socdem “socialist” who had a weird appreciation for the Soviet film industry
Something apparently only Luke is aware of.
Can you elaborate?
I don't care to see the movie but I keep seeing references to some solid story arches concerning Luke.
Luke wants the Jedi Order to end with him and mentions that the Jedi Order had demonstrated its failure when, at the peak of its power, it could not stop the Empire from emerging. As such, he sees no use in restoring it (edit: his main reason is his failure with Kylo Ren but Luke does flat out say the Jedis failed and Yoda agrees so it's not just about Kylo). He ends up destroying what's left of the Jedi but at the same time unsurprisingly helps the Rebels towards the end. This begs the question, why does he not apply the same logic he used for the Jedis to the Republic/Rebels?
BEFORE TOUCHING DOWN on the planet of Canto Bight, Rose looks down forebodingly to tell us that it’s full of the (((“worst people in the galaxy.”))) Cut to champagne glasses clinking and a casino full of galactic (((1-percenters))).
It's quite telling that article ignored one of the better parts of the scene, where DJ cynically points out that they're selling weapons to whoever is buying, including the Resistance.
YES i really hope they expand on that more in ep 9
I doubt it honestly. Ep 9 is probably going to give TLJ the full 1984 treatment and pretend it never existed.
Explain why this is shit leftists say material? (Not because I disagree but because I'm curious your insight)
leftists think that star wars is '' a subversive piece of media'' while in fact it is just another cashgrab that the movie industry is known for.
Haha yes. This one is so obvious it went over my head lol
i mean it is subversive but only in the sense that it subverts expectations as they relate to the canon and Star Wars story, most definitely isnt subversive in the social or economic or any other sense.
Star Wars was really just George Lucas taking Joseph Campbell's A Hero with a Thousand Faces and running with it. It was never meant to be anything more than a modern recreation of ancient mythological tales.
[removed]
A 'goody army' verses a 'bady army' has literally no relation to a class war fermenting into a social revolution, transforming everyone's way of life. In fact it's the cliche Liberal trope of having virtuous and morally superior people in charge. No wonder r/succ users love it so much.
yeah sorry, im lately not that there if you get my drift. anyway, the rebellion(which in the new movies makes no sense anyway but whatev) in star wars was always milktoast liberalism, some lefty "journalists" reading a super deep, woke message into that crap of a movie that isnt there just tells you everything about "leftist movie analysis".
also what u/MarxismHannibalism said.
[deleted]
What does that mean
[deleted]
where does authoritarianism have anything to do with being left or right?
If that's truly the case, then this should be shitlibertarianssay instead
edit: apparently i get banned for saying antiauthoritarianism is libertarianism, and that's a different axiom and independent of left and right wing politics.
it is quite fun when people get confused about this sub.
Weird, the amount I loved this movie is directly proportional to how inaufferable the "discourse" around it is.
When you mix up George Lucas and György Lukács.
Guilty as charged. Same name anyway.
Wait, they're separate people?
The stupid shit leftists say is mostly reading waaaaaaaay too much into a campy sci-fi movie about space wizards with laser swords. It also happens to be stupid shit rightists say.
Shrek is probably the most marxist movie in history if you over analyse it enough
I really enjoyed The Last Jedi and I felt there were some decent moments of reflection and critique that were sprinkled into the film. But obviously a fucking STAR WARS film is not going to be some epic call for proletarian revolution. The industry and influence behind it are pretty insurmountable limitations on that front. I can enjoy the film as a piece of entertainment and appreciate some of its brief forays into introspection and critique, but a propaganda piece it is not.
[deleted]
lol
fucking kill me
MarxismHannibalism? Should be Markism-Hamillism!