Parliament Act 2016 Repeal Implementation - Results
The results of the vote are as follows:
#1st Round
Nominated Peers and the legislative system from the consultation: 11
A different system: 3
Don’t repeal the Parliament Act: 6
Abstain: 1
Therefore, the repeal of the Parliament Act 2016 shall be implemented as discussed. This will take effect tomorrow (08/01/18 at 00:00 GMT), so all Lords bills submitted after this point and all Commons bills sent to MHoL after this point shall not be subject to the Parliament Act 2016.
There were additionally a number of comments on the poll, which I’m grateful for:
Abolish the Lords x3: Clearly there was a rump of support for if not this, at least not giving Lords more power. However, not enough to warrant a change of direction, but I note that not everyone is happy, and if more people become dissatisfied with simulating both Houses there will be more discussion.
Nominated Peerages should have an expirary date to prevent bloating of the the Lords: This is a very valid concern. I’ll be monitoring the situation of course, and if problems I think are due to bloating arise, I’ll probably impose this expiry date. The Working Peerages system suggests we don’t need to be too worried about it though.
Bring back Party Peerages: While a better system if your aim is proportionality, I think this system only works when demand for positions exceeds the supply of them. Having Party Peers when parties are struggling to even fill their Commons seats however creates more stress for party leaders, much more churn in the Lords, and much less engaged and interested Lords. This is only more the case now than when Party Peerages were abolished, and I don’t think there’s any appetite for bringing them back amongst party leaders.
Move to the RL System?: There're some things we simply can simulate in the crossover from physical legislating all happening in the same place at the same time, to online over the course of several days. However the original implementation of MHoL was as close to the RL system as we can manage, and many of us found that in the end to be frustrating, off-putting, confusing and dull. I don't think it's something that translates to reddit well, and I therefore think it'd be the wrong course for MHoL.
no: Ok.
If you want any more clarification or discussion, feel free to comment below. Thanks everyone!
Posted Jan 7, 2018, 5:24 PM UTC · edited
Thank you for listing the comments given and discussing them, this speakership's attitude towards transparency is greatly appreciated.
My pleasure :)