Questions: Value and Exploitation

Ok can we talk about value and price and shit again? I'm trying to wrap my head around the mechanics of profit re. proudhon and how they integrate with classical LTV.

So, (an) LTV = cost exerts the greatest influence on long term price because it's the point at which suppliers will enter/leave the market. Cost is reduceable to "disutility to labour", ie. the price at which it is necessary to pay labour to get it to labour.

Proudhon exploitation thing = 100 workers working for an hour produce more than 1 worker working for 100 hours, but they're all paid according to their individual contribution and the value of their collective force is appropriated by capital.

My question is: if long run price is determined by labour's willingness to labour, wouldn't price be driven to the same point in both cases (1 labourer vs 100 labourers)? If so, how is this an explanation for profit? The extra productivity of labour because of collective force shouldn't actually result in a higher price (the difference being appropriated by capital), right?

I may be fundamentally misinterpreting either of these ideas tbh. Thanks for anyone who wants to help.

Posted Jan 11, 2018, 2:56 PM UTC

22
humanispherian•

Wages are determined by a combination of factors, some of which have nothing to do with the value actually created by the labor-power purchased. And the same factors that make it possible for capitalists to appropriate the fruits of collective force influence the price of labor. Because, within a capitalist system, large-scale capital is controlled by a relatively small portion of the population, labor is often limited in its opportunities to even enter the market by a shortage of "jobs." As long as the opportunities to labor are not sufficient for full employment, there are forces at least potentially driving the price of labor below the level of simple disutility. On top of that, many workers occupy positions where there is little or no prospect of wage increases and where increased productivity and availability demands [are common] (often accompanied by precarity with regard to actual hours of employment, etc.), so that even calculating disutility and wages/hours needed for subsistence is nearly impossible. Assuming that there were no such thing as collective force, a soft labor market and weak legal protections for workers mean that wages can be driven down and productivity driven up at the same time, giving us a much simpler sort of exploitation. And the exploitation that is attributable to the appropriation of collective force is actually quite constant, with workers' inability to resist increased demands often acting as an additional multiplier.

5
Robert_Jarman•

I believe that an employee should be given whatever amount of money he or she has caused the cooperative to earn, minus expenses of running the cooperative (and with the option to participate in cooperative provided programs like health insurance or vouchers to pay for the education of children who can't learn on their own). A consumer should at the end of a regular period, usually 6 months to a year, be able to get any amount of difference between the purchase price and the cost in the end (for cooperatives already using the sell at cost principle, this is likely to be relatively limited in scope anyway). Cooperatives likely will adopt the at cost principle if others are doing it, but many members don't know about the at cost principle, so they need education. It also allows more members to participate.

1