Paragon and the Card System
So last night I was a little bored, wanted to change it up some so i decided to try out the new season of League of Legends. (Side bar: I never want to hear people bit**ing about solo que on paragon, it was terrible I played 5 games once I went against an all Melee team, once was all AD, and 4 out of the 5 my team decided that a 2 ADC comp was viable so yeah it's pretty bad no matter what game you play) The bizarre team comps did bring a couple of things to my attention that I believe we all know but I would like to try to articulate.
First: Cards seem incredibly confused when it comes to tanks. Mid range cards are great. Better than great, they are amazing, you have Numbing Rogue, Vital Waters, Yomi Guardian, Arcane Dancer, Wicked Reposte, Thorned Yomi. (Although I would probably say that the last 4 are still a little confused, why do they give power?? But I think that horse has been beaten enough. Wicked Reposte is the one exception in that list that probably could use the power) But as soon as you go into late game cards it gets silly.
Let's start with Chaos: Nukeblood Mutant- Attack and move speed steroid on ability use, 19 power.
Unstable Cyborg- Damage Return-ish, 14 Power
Compensator Rig- Basic Damage Steroid, 20 Power.
Ok to be fair this is Chaos, anything they do should probably beef up some power, but why is Compensator Rig the only one that provides any life?
On to Death: Withering Shadow- Damage Aura, 20 Power Sorvukk Initiate- Damage Link, perfect tank stats! We found a tank card with tank stats! Too bad the active is 100% offensive.
On to Growth: Unbroken Spirit - Regen on CC, 10 power Perfect tank card, gives defense, health, a low amount of power and a tank passive. Other than the fact that it's a CC meta there is a reason this is the most common tank card (because its the only TRUE tank card).
Next is Intellect: Black Ice Routine - Area Damage and Slow, 17 Power Offensive ability too much power
and finally Order: Godmother Vigilant - Bonus Life, 15 power Defensive ability, no armor at all.
Why do we go from amazing mid range cards like Numbing Rogue that give area AS debuff and 36 Armor or Vital Waters with bonus healing, Life, and health regen. To strictly go out do damage? Is this how epic artificially forces low match times? All late game cards do damage, damage, and more damage. If you want to stay tanky, freeze the game at 13 minutes and no one is allowed to spend points or buy cards. It's very silly to me.
The reason this came to my attention was against the all AD team comp I played against last night in league. I was able to punish this by building heavy life and TONS of Basic Armor. 2 items and Ninja Tabi and I was able to run all the way across the map with 3-4 of their team beating on me and still get away or to my team. The key here is that in any Moba, bad decisions should be punishable right now they aren't. Only Death has multiple mid game tank cards and both of their late game cards do damage to yourself! Some of the tankiest characters are building Sacred Alchemy/Vampire Blade to stay alive, this makes them highly susceptible to CC. All of this is why we have a CC meta right now. What if Black Ice Routine was given a Tank Passive, something like Black Ice Armor, when CC'd gain 60 Basic and Ability Armor. Sorvukk's Link stole life (at a much lower rate than it does now) regardless of whether your CC'ed the only way to break the link is to get out of range giving you some more survivability or forcing the carry to back out of range.
BUT with all these changes WAH WAH tank meta WAH! Well, what happens if we got a little crazy and didn't just throw attack speed at every offensive item! WHAT?!?! Heresy you say!?!? Wouldn't it be crazy if Deathcrawler gave you Armor Penetration rather than Basic Defense? Why are there no cards other than a 4 point and 5 point death card that has any Armor Pen. Grinning Specter, Shatter Golem, Mallenk Gnasher, all great late game cards to throw penetration on. But instead of doing it like we did the tank meta where is was something ridiculous like 2.2 points of pen for every 1 point armor your make it 1:1. However much armor late game tank cards give that's how much late game offensive cards give.
So I know I said I had a couple of ideas, well the first one took way too long to articulate so I will make a second post for the second idea.
TL;DR - Late game tank cards need tank actives, passives, and stats. While late game offensive cards need to include penetration so we don't get forced back into the tank meta.
Edit - Formatting
Posted Jan 12, 2018, 3:26 PM UTC · edited
I will never understand why GMV has no armor. It’s a mid game health spike card but there are stats wasted on power...? Why would i want tons of health with literally 0 mitigation. Rip to anyone running this card against a Carry with pressure hunter. Makes no sense.
I know exactly what you mean, honestly why do any of these cards build power. I tried to stay away from that side of it just because of how much it has been stated but I think it is an insane concept. I don't understand why the tank cards can't just give ton's of tank stats and tanky abilities. Do you think the CC meta would be as prevalent when you don't just get to stun lock the tank and blow him up? Or when it takes so many stuns for you to keep the tank down that you have nothing left for the damage dealers?
I think it also would open up solo lane. Right now typically (only speaking for my games) its a tank/basic damage dealer in solo, ability mid, basic in jungle and duo lane. But if you could stack 2 or even 3 forms of Basic Armor and health now you have negated an entire team. It may force a caster into solo, you would see a lot more of Kwang/Sev since he can do ability damage.