Choose your own adventure style books

NSFW

I've published a few of these (using Inkle to generate a file for amazon) and they are my all time best sellers. I was wondering if anyone else has written and published any of these and what their experiences are. Also, I suppose if it's something you haven't done and have questions I'd be happy to answer them. I'm not an "expert" but I have published three fairly large ones on Amazon, so I have some experience.

-EDIT-

So I hadn't actually done a conversion to Ebook with Inkle for a while and someone just sent me this link:

https://www.inklestudios.com/inklewriter/kindle-ebooks/

So it looks like they are no longer providing this service which is REALLY sucker. I've sent them an E-mail asking to confirm but my hopes aren't high...

-EDIT-

So looking into things Inkle is definitely no longer compiling Ebook files. In fact the makers have totally abandoned the program and it will be offline within a year. Sad, it was a really cool tool and there really isn't anything else like it out there.

I had been a little despondent at one point but after a lot of trial and error going through other programs I took the advice of a few posters on here and messed around with some of the features I had never touched in Scrivner. You can TOTALLY and actually pretty easily create a word doc with the proper links using Scrivner! So anyone who has that program you can totes make an interactive story.

Posted Jan 14, 2018, 2:11 AM UTC · edited

927
zehnharlock•

I have nothing to add here, just that I've been debating trying one of these out myself for a while and wham...this thread answers pretty much every question I had.

Huge thanks for this!

3
PhiloHunterOPHypno Perve•

Really glad to help! I hope you and anyone else that writes and publishes one shares what their experience was like after it's been out for a while.

1
sultryslurry•

I was just thinking about this, and wishing it was something that could be done for amazon when DUH, I could have just searched and found it.

Did you write it all through Inkle or did you just put it into Inkle to generate the file for amazon?

How do you feel about Inkle's formatting options? Do you think you could link me a book done with it? I'm just curious what the end product looks like, and looking at some choose-your-own-erotica on Amazon I see people's formatting can be all over the place.

2
PhiloHunterOPHypno Perve•

Here's links to the three that are up:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B017EIX9V2

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00ROHWEVU

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B015F1D93S

(for anyone looking at my stuff it's really heavy on the mind control kink and dubcon, so if either of those squick you out best avoid)

I do my outlining and first draft in Scrivner which allows me to organize and link the different sections. I couldn't imagine doing one of these books without Scrivner. I found out early on that copy pasting from scrivner into Inkle loses all your paragraph breaks and bold and italics. For two of those books I was copy pasting each individual paragraph into Inkle (I don't suggest writing a book right into Inkle, the spell check on your web browser isn't good enough to catch typos and grammer mistakes). But eventually I found out that if you copy paste stuff into word and THEN into Inkle it will save the paragraph breaks and bolding/italics. So now what I do is copy past each section into word to do my editing and then copy paste it into inkle.

So yeah, Inkle is pretty much just there to generate the file. I also use it to do beta reading. I have a Patreon and let my Patreon readers have the link to it till its done. But be warned: if you post the link to the work ANYWHERE it will be publicly searchable online. If you want to put the book into KU (which you should, you cna't really upload the file anywhere else and you get a SHIT TON of page reads from these stories. Like hundreds or thousands each read) you have to ask Inkle to change the link and keep it from being public so its then "exclusive" to Amazon.

As far as Inkle's formatting it looks pretty nice on a kindle. It might not be how i would make it work but there is nothing wrong with it and it flows amazingly smoothly and looks professional. The big draw back is you can't really add any end material to the book, like links to all your other books. You can't put any formatting into the book other than bolding and italics, so no web links unless they are types out and even then I don't know if they are clickable.

But Inkle is VERY worth it. Manually formatting one of these books, especially a big or complicated one is a nightmare and takes ages. Inkle does all the work for you.

A couple things though to keep in mind. I already mentioned the work around for copy pasting into it. The other big thing is there are a TON of really awesome tools as part of inkle, some of them ones that you have to kind of dig around to find. You can use Inkle to basically make a complicated text game. But almost all of that won't transfer into the file for amazon, in fact including most things will make it so the file won't even compile.

The first big thing you need to avoid if you use it is NEVER have the possibility of an endless loop. That will make it so the file won't compile (do to how it makes the file, basically it ends up trying to make an infinite amount of pages).

Images are useless, they come out basically as thumb nails.

You CAN use some if/if not logic but you have to keep it limited. Don't use more then maybe 5 or 10 different "ifs". And if you are having them have a numerical value (like say tagging someones horny level. Like if you pass this passage you get +1 horny or -1 Horny) its safest to not let those get higher than 3. Basicly you risk making the compiled file too big for them to complete because of how it compiles. There's no "coding" in the final file so if you have an entry that you could get to and have horny 0,1,2, or three the file will make FOUR copies of that page and then four copies of every page fallowing it and if you get to many you end up with millions of pages and it won't compile.

But if your doing something without any fancy logic, just point a leads to point b and c might lead to b too I haven't found a size limit.

-edit-

One more Inkle thing: the insert new section thing is a great tool. It makes it easy to locate chunks and is where its easiest to link pages to. But the text you type in there is never seen by anyone but you. Reading on line it is invisible and they aren't included in the file for amazon. so don't stress over what they say.

3
sultryslurry•

Awesome, thanks!

Have you tried compiling on Scrivener using their links system? Or have you always been beholden to Inkle?

2
PhiloHunterOPHypno Perve•

So I hadn't actually done a conversion to Ebook with Inkle for a while and someone just sent me this link:

https://www.inklestudios.com/inklewriter/kindle-ebooks/

So it looks like they are no longer providing this service which is REALLY sucker. I've sent them an E-mail asking to confirm but my hopes aren't high...

2
sultryslurry•

Oh dang, and there’s no other way to convert out in suitable format? I wonder why they discontinued it.

2
PhiloHunterOPHypno Perve•

Honestly I didn't even know A driver could do that. I probably only use like 5% of its functionality. I try to keep my process as simple as possible so projects don't end up overwhelming me.

Also glad the info helped!

1
IcemanConch•

Damn, that’s a SUPER useful post!

I played around with using the CHYOA erotica website and doing a really short, unfinished story with it. I’ve been wanting to circle back to that and potentially do an eBook version. But it’s one of those things where I haven’t know where to start. So this is VERY helpful, thank you! :)

2
PhiloHunterOPHypno Perve•

Your welcome. Inkle is a really cool took it just takes some getting used to. For me the hardest thing when I'm working on an ebook is not using all those extra tools that can't translate into an ebook file.

1
PhiloHunterOPHypno Perve•

So I hadn't actually done a conversion to Ebook with Inkle for a while and someone just sent me this link:

https://www.inklestudios.com/inklewriter/kindle-ebooks/

So it looks like they are no longer providing this service which is REALLY sucker. I've sent them an E-mail asking to confirm but my hopes aren't high...

1
IcemanConch•

Damn! Boo. :(

1

I've got one out there and about 50% of the way through book #2. I actually do a flowchart on paper for each step / branch and then write the whole thing in google docs using Bookmarks and Links inside it. The google Link to an internal bookmark is pretty easy and works flawlessly. In the end I just export it to word format and import it to kindle create. Nice and easy and free.

And yeah as others have said stay far far far away from 'choose your own XXX' phrases.

2
IcemanConch•

Oh cool! I was wondering if Google Docs bookmarks/links would work in it.

I didn't get far in the one I started a while ago. But for the structure of it, I used a mind-mapping website called Coggle.

1
hotdogtopus•

I've done one, but it's more fantasy than erotica. It has low sales every month, but it has had a long tail. I've seen a few books like this with anime covers rise through the charts.

2
[deleted]•

This sounds super interesting - I loved choose your own adventure books as a teen, and I think it might be quite fun to try out. How many words are your stories on average? And I'd assume the plot can't be too massive, otherwise it gets a bit too complicated to plan out all the different endings? I'm also assuming that the choose your own option bits are not actually during the sex-scenes, but during the plot the surrounding it?

I wonder if those japanese dating simulator/graphic novels could be good inspirations...

2
PhiloHunterOPHypno Perve•

I think the books i've finished or got near to finishing were anywhere from 20,000 words on up to 60,000.

The two superheroine ones I have don't really tell one linear story your trying to get through. Each story starts with the heroine deciding where to patrol for the day and then the story branches out into tons of different stories (all ending in her defeat). They were meant to be highly rereadalke with little cross over through passages you read previously. Sometimes I had choices in sex scenes, but mostly yeah it was the stuff leading up to it. It kind if reads like 50 short stories all in one. And those ones only have bad endings, something I probably won't do as most people expressed that they wanted to be able to get to good endings.

The odd book out i have published, a post apocalyptic one, is totally different. It tells a linear story and you are trying to reach the end if it where the one "good" ending is. All the other endings expressicly say they aren't the real ending. For that one it wasn't to hard to keep it from getting complicated. If you graphed out the choices it would mostly look like a series of straight lines with little explosions of choices that all meet up at the next straight line. I have a sequel about half done that's way longer and more complex, but obviously there's a reason that one isn't finished.

I'm actually working on one right now (another suoerheroine one) that's different from the other ones I've done. There's a lot of passages that can be led into from many different directions and a good mix of good and bad endings. The thing I did to keep the narrative from being to divergent was make all the events set in one day. So lots of choices for what she does with her day but just 24 hours ensures that the different story arches don't get to far from each other.

And yeah, like I said above I don't usually have choices during a sex scene. A lot of the times the choices outside of sex scenes are a little ambiguas as to what they will lead to, not really telling you whether the choice will be good for the main character or not. But once it comes to sex scenes I try to make it pretty clear what your walking into. My stuff uses a ton of different kinks so I want to make sure people can avoid stuff that's bores or squicks them out. If there's going to be a lactation breast growth scene I make that clear.

2
Johntrenchard•

I published a few early in my career. If they're your bestsellers, it may be time to move to another niche as the ceiling for them is not high especially because they take so much longer to write than standard stories. Unless you're doing for fun rather than money!

I had a cease and desist email from scary lawyers after a month or two and then got those books blocked for the titles being "Choose your own erotic journey" and similar as "Choose your own adventure" is copyrighted and using "Choose your own" was enough to get a lawyer email. I pointed out in response that there were lots of books with "Choose your own," in the title asking why mine was singled out and their response was they were working through them all. I protested they'd been up for a while but Amazon just sided with them and blocked the titles. Be careful what title you choose!

I had to republish and make sure I didn't have "Choose your own" in the title though it was fine when I used it in the blurb. That was three years ago and according to Book Report they've each earned about $50 between publishing and now.

2
PhiloHunterOPHypno Perve•

Yeah, I write mostly out of love not to make loads of cash. I write what I would want to read, which is super weird genre stuff which isn't the road to riches.

Part if the reasons they are my best sellers is that they are in KU and most of the rest of my stuff isn't (I like smashwords and need to be able to post stories to my patreon feed). I make usually close to 50$ on each of my cyoa books each month, so I guess my mileage has been better than yours.

And yeah, the guy who owns the copy right (or is it trademark?) to "choose your own adveture" keeps a tight lid on that phrase. He wrote the original books and then lost control of them for a looooong time and had to fight really hard to get the rights back to them. He went and rewrote all the orinigal books, they newest editions are pretty cool and have web addresses hidden in for interactive games that young kids love.

I have all my published stories labels as "Choose Her Peril" since my main characters are always female and Peril is a specific dog whistle key word for the superheroine genre.

If I ever had a male protag I'd probably use "interactive story" as a descriptor.

2
Johntrenchard•

You did better than me to get those kind of figures. There was one by a big publisher called Fulfil Your Fantasy, not sure if that's still out there somewhere to do a bit of research but if memory serves, it was pretty mainstream.

1
PhiloHunterOPHypno Perve•

Maybe that's the difference. My stuff isn't main stream in any way. Mainstream readers tend to want to read one specific kink at a time. The people i write for like a ton if stuff: mind control, breast growth, bimbofication, humiliation, impregnation, tons if different sexual acts. If you can use 50 different kinks in different combinations in a cyoa story you can write a bigger more diverse story.

1
IcemanConch•

If you can use 50 different kinks in different combinations in a cyoa story you can write a bigger more diverse story.

Oh, interesting! I don't know if I would've thought of that.

2