DID MARX WANT TO ABOLISH MONEY?

Hi guys, i know it says to search the sub before posting and i did, but couldn't find anything. I tried to read Capital once but out was to hard, so i think I'll just stick to reddit comments. My question is, did Marx want to abolish money? I know he was a big proponent of democracy and workers rights, but what if the proletariat democratically decide to keep money after the leftist revolution? Also, what if they decide to implement anarcho-communism instead of Marxism? Thanks a lot for answering. I've been reading the wikipedia page on Rosa Luxemburg and it seems like her theories are good, I know she was a famous leftcom so pretty soon I might be switching over my tendency.

Posted Jan 20, 2018, 4:58 AM UTC

10129
Babeuf58•

Obviously Marx wanted to keep money. He loved money! In the C-M-C relationship, it is only capital that Marx hates. Eliminate that C and what is left? Answer: Money! For Everyone! So in conclusion, Marx's Kapital supports a universal basic income and legal pot.

63
AlienElationOP/r/LeftistHotTakes•

I love money too, but i think it's unfairly distributed to the elites. I think it's because of a lack of workplace democracy like Marx spoke of. If only the capital were more evenly distributed between workers and owners (co-ops for example) it would be easier to establish socialism later since that would raise class consciousness.

51
bobloblawrmsSocialism with Ikean Characteristics•

I'm pretty sure I've seen this exact comment on r/soc.

36
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
stillmclovinitrevolutionary nihilism babie•

this isnt even fake at this point

4
wingnut5k•

Well duh. How are you supposed to by things if you dont have money?

6
AlienElationOP/r/LeftistHotTakes•

"Abolishing commodity production"? DOES THAT MEAN YOU DON'T WANT ANYTHING TO BE MADE

14

“But people in the Middle Ages had commodities!”

1
[deleted]•

Well, (checks brainyquote.com) Lenin once said "The best way to destroy the capitalist system is to debauch the currency.". So what this means is that Marx wanted us to make counterfeit dollars to build socialism.

56
slamDuncan52Please Fucking Read•

Is your username from the leading light WordPress bullet point manifesto?

20
[deleted]•

It's actually a satirical reference to a shitty bourgeois book we had to read for a group in high school by a Chinese anti-communist about the sad, sad tale of an upper-class Chinese family facing stigmatization from the working class and literally listening to Voice of America in secret. The book in turn was satirically titled after a Mao quote.

28
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
TrotskylvaniaThe International Razor•

2018

Not a post-ironic Posadist-Hoxhaist

14
BigfluffyltailL'émergeance de l'État détermine l'apparition des Clastres•

Marx was a fan of card games and wished for money to be replaced by a children's card game.

The yugioh manga, card game and anime were largely based on this idea. It was socialist. I think it's one of the main reasons millennials are socialist now (plus pokémon games that advocated free healthcare and a worldwide government!). The times in the anime where you see money are either errors or actually cards that are green because they supported green cards for Japanese immigrants. Also Star Wars is secretly socialist.

This is why in the anime the "dueling world" balances out the (worker owned, since Kaiba is a hard worker) "business world" and "political world", completing Marx's dialectic. And since they're in communism they can do whatever they want like play cards all day and attend card school. The anime also has the pharaoh (the "feudal socialism" of the manifesto) within Yugi because it's passing the torch from one socialism to another. It's symbolic.

Marx criticized the trading card games of capitalism (even though he was a great fan of the XIXth century version of Magic the Gathering) as "commodity fetishism" (see the fourth and last chapter of his magnum opus Capitalism in the XIXth century) but replacing money by cards makes them different from commodities. Also unlike money they have use value whereas money only has exchange value. This means that cards are the currency of communism, while money is the currency of capitalism.

44
OTIS_is_king•

How do you people do this

2
cityraidercasino communist•

If we want to be good socialists we have to let these new collectives have the right to self-determination, that way they can find the best type of socialism for them. Some will decide they don’t want money, but some will choose to keep it based on their particular material conditions. We can’t go straight to communism overnight, so not everybody can abolish money all at once. A more realistic goal is to fight for workplace democracy, where we can democratically choose to raise the minimum wage to $20 an hour like in Denmark. After winning the hearts and minds of my local commune, we will probably decide to adopt libertarian socialism and therefore keep money for a little while (since I’ll know the most theory, I can run the state bank). Keep reading though, comradely comrade. May I suggest the Conquest of Bread?

36
amkier•

Too real

7
GilbertLebroncheEsoteric Humanist•

Little known historical fact: Marx was a rare currency collector, so of course he wanted to keep money.

29
Babeuf58•

Marx's numismatism was the only reason why he ever hung out with Engels. Sad but true.

21
diezeitenI need a fucking drink•

Marx was a rare currency collector,

Is actually true or completely bullshit?

12
GilbertLebroncheEsoteric Humanist•

i dont know i never read marx

22

“Hey bro, check out these sick currencies I got” -Marx. This quote is from the Grundrisse

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dasaten•
0
Carlos_Marquez•

Free him

1
_metamythical•

OP, everyone in this thread is being sarcastic. Suggest you try elsewhere.

-5
BigfluffyltailL'émergeance de l'État détermine l'apparition des Clastres•

I personally suggest meme subs as a good source on these things. It's the highest form of socialist education because it's basically the final form of détournement.

45
melemStand with the bourgeoisie against proletarian imperialism•

Richard Dawkins coined the term "meme".

Richard Dawkins is a science man.

Steven Hawking is a science man and his last name kinda sounds like dawkins.

Steven Hawking is a super genius space science physics man.

Albert Einstein was a super genius space science physics man.

Albert Einstein kinda looks like a beardless Marx.

Memes are therefore Marxist.

21
AlienElationOP/r/LeftistHotTakes•

Why would they be sarcastic? It's a sub called "ultra left" so their ideology must be super leftist, right?

44
[deleted]•

Left communism is when you use Bordiga memes to move the Overton Window

35
QuintonGavinsonInternationalist Communist Party (Battaglia Catgirlista)•

How on earth did you not realise this post was sarcastic?

16
doeslikecheesecakeThe person reading this is stupid•

Lol I thought they were joking too until I saw their post history

9