NCAA is investigating MSU for its role in the case of Larry Nassar
Posted Jan 24, 2018, 2:53 AM UTC
Posted Jan 24, 2018, 2:53 AM UTC
If we're being honest, a football program sheltered a pedophile and covered up decades worth of child abuse and basically nothing happened. Nothing will come of this NCAA wise
Exactly, consistency is fundamental here at the NCAA.
If we're being honest, a university set up fake classes so that its athletes could be academically eligible and literally nothing happened to them.
On the other side a program was hit hard because a individual athlete decided to sell his memorabilia for a tattoo. Really anything is possible.
NCAA isn’t going to do shit. MSU will sue them as soon as they try.
Exhibit A: PSU
Exhibit B: Being too scared to touch Baylor
Counterpoint: neither of those cases involved student-athletes being the victims of abuse. They were either uninvolved (PSU) or the perpetrators (Baylor). I think the NCAA might be far more willing to go after programs which abuse the athletes themselves.
Not to mention that since this involves non-revenue sports there's not nearly the same level of community involvement and tradition. Shutting down women's cross-country and shutting down football are two different beasts.
neither of thise cases involved student-athletes being victims of abuse
Baylor student athletes were allegedly raped( soccer, equestrian) by other student athletes(football).
Hm, didn't realize that. That does weaken my point somewhat, although the second part still stands.
Says the guy who watched BOKU NO HERO ACADEMIA LOLOLOL
Wait, 4-1,3-5
[deleted]
We were prepared to sue.
...we didn't sue anybody.
Wrong
He’s a disgusting piece of shit, but we shouldn’t just let the NCAA reach outside of their jurisdiction. So they’re doing this more to be like look! We’re good guys!
When sadly hiring a shit head isn’t an NCAA violation
I can't ignore your flair in this argument...
What about his flair, that Carolina fans might be even less kindly inclined than others towards the NCAA trying to expand its jurisdiction?
[deleted]
Just for accuracy's sake, Penn State didn't sue the NCAA.
PA Senator Jake Corman filed the suit against the NCAA, of which Penn State was technically a defendant as a party to the NCAA.
Exhibit C: UNC
I wish that I had enough faith in the NCAA to believe the motive for this was truly to find (and potentially help) other possible victims rather than try and spin this as positive PR.
Motives aside, I’m hoping that either Nassar’s terrible actions didn’t extend beyond those already identified at MSU or newly discovered victims can be helped to heal some old wounds.
This sucks, but MSU needs to face up to the full brunt of it. Simon probably needs to go. I think she was intentionally keeping herself in the dark. MSU will probably be made an example, and that might not be a bad thing in the long run. Sigh.
Higher ups need to go either way. Either they knew, and did nothing or actively hid it and should be sacked. Or they didn't know, and that demonstrates a lack of control and ability to maintain a quality staff, and should be sacked.
You'd honestly think they would. Fuck Nassar.
Also fuck every single person at MSU who knew exactly what kind of a fucking monster he was and chose to enable him
Same for the USAG and USOC.
MSU faculty is also prepping for an official vote of no confidence against President Simon. Hopefully this is her kiss of death.
I'm sure the BOT is keeping her on as a buffer bc they know the heat is on them as soon as she is ousted. I hope every one of them is gone within the year. What a perfect opportunity to break up the good old boys network like Joel Ferguson that just won't get their claws out of MSU.
Is the board not elected? I know our (and WSU's) regents are elected and assumed that's how all Michigan schools do it.
They are elected, but two have already announced they won't be seeking reelection since this scandal broke, including the Chairman Brian Breslin (yes that Breslin). The others may be pressured to step down or announce that they will serve out their term. Especially Ferguson and Perles who a lot at MSU have been ready to move on from for ages. I don't know a lot about the election process but it seems pretty resistant to getting entrenched incumbents out of there who have the support of the cabal.
The election of trustees largely goes with whatever the political wave of the year is. Since they are partisan offices most just vote D or R.
Hollis has to be fired for this too right?
apparently nassar was part of the college of orthopedics, not the athletics department. I mean if he knew something he should be gone but it can be technically said it is less his job to know than it was lou anna K's.
that is to say he wouldn't necessarily be made aware of a Title IX complaint because Nassar wasn't part of the Athletics department on paper
Gotcha, did not know that.
I’ve seen it floated around that it has to do with their insurer. If MSU admits fault, then they might be on the line to pay out all of the civil suits and such. Firing Simon could be interpreted as a admittance of guilt and MSU might be on the line for $1 billion in legal fees and payouts instead of their insurer.
I still can’t believe this isn’t a bigger story here or the CFB. Talk about systemic negligence. This is on par with Penn State and Sandusky
I think the reason it isn't being discussed is because it doesn't relate directly to cfb or cbb. It has general implications on title IX work at MSU and potential changes at the administrative level, but nothing has said either the football or basketball program is connected.
So for fans on these subs it's interesting to follow, but not likely to result in any direct news.
I think after the joke of a punishment that PSU got (still makes me sick that they're this good again this quickly), people just throw their hands up in the air and don't care enough to debate from a football or basketball program perspective what the consequences could be.
It is a little different. This is a doctor who was within the university who was known as one of the best in the world for treating sports related injuries. He was investigated under a title IX and the other doctors found nothing. They failed in their do diligence because they liked and respected the man. He was not employed by the athletic department. He was not a coach. The man had nothing to do with the Basketball team or Football team.
I stated this before in a comment on another thread, but it sounds like there was a bit more to it than just professional respect. These conclusions are easy to come to looking at this in hindsight. But you can't torpedo a physicians reputation without due process, and it sounds like because of the gymnastics coach, MSU couldn't grasp the full scope of the situation without the story breaking from the USAG side of things. MSU investigated per protocol, and had his practiced supervised for a time. But obviously, he's going to perform his procedures normally while he's being supervised. So what else can really be done? During this point of the investigation, MSU was looking into a single isolated violation [accusation] against a highly regarded physician. This physician also had a reasonable defense to the complaint. Due to HIPAA and other confidentiality laws, I imagine MSU was very limited in their capacity to conduct a full investigation, and there wasn't enough evidence to go to the medical licensing board or conduct a professional investigation, until more victims and complaints began to surface. Until that point I don't think anyone really imagined the depth and depravity of the actual situation.
Probably because it involved neither the basketball nor football programs, just as a guess.
[deleted]
This shit is terrible- but I don't really see how this is college basketball related at all.
Pretty ridiculous that the NCAA is even getting involved like this anyway. This is a legal matter and I really hope that in some way to "save face" the NCAA doesn't just ban every sports team on campus.
Hope everyone involved gets jailed and properly punished though-- hope everyone with absolutely no connection with this at all doesn't get wrongfully punished for the misdeeds of some terrible people.
Not sure there's any bylaw that was broken. This is more of a title ix issue and an institution issue. Sorta like with Penn State, the NCAA seems to be stepping outside their authority. I'd rather see the feds go after MSU
For what? MSU had a Title IX investigation and passed the complaints to both local authorities and the FBI.
All three cleared Nassar after other doctors said there was legitimacy to the “medical procedure” being performed. Obviously hindsight makes that look terrible.
I get calling for the President or BoT to resign, but I don’t understand a federal investigation into MSU. Maybe USA Gymnastics after the whole NDA settlement thing.
MSU had a Title IX investigation and passed the complaints to both local authorities and the FBI.
MSU also cleared Nassar during that title IX investigation, which has been described as poorly done. The FBI claims they didn't connect Nassar with MSU until 2016.
I'm confused, when did the FBI ever clear Nassar? When did the local authorities ever clear Nassar?
I'm for a federal investigation into what each of them have known on Nassar. Because they've all claimed they knew nothing and when they found out, they took the appropriate steps. So I'm for an investigation into those claims, and whether any of that was true.
I'm all for the same thing on USA Gym and USOC.
My fault on the FBI part, I got that backwards. The FBI didn’t advise MSU that they were investigating Nassar until after MSU fired him. MSU police investigated parallel to the Title IX investigation in 2014 and passed along the case to the DA who declined to seek charges for the same reason the Title IX investigation cleared him. Sort of what I meant by that.
The problem isn’t people saying they didn’t know, it’s that they deferred to doctors who gave Nassar’s medical procedure defense credibility. How do you attack a leading expert in the field when others in the same field give him that credibility?
Regarding people at MSU who didn’t do enough, I think the list is Klages, the softball coach who’s name I don’t remember, and Strampel. There was never some grand cover up, but the first two on the list can be argued as mandatory reporters and should have done more.
Strampel just blows my mind. Dude still has a job at MSU (he’s no longer Dean of COM) despite being the only person who had action items from the 2014 investigation, and then not following through on implementing the new policies.
Can you elaborate on that? I was not aware Strampel sat on anything. This was my perspective on events as I understand them, but I'm still putting pieces together myself. I stated this before in response to another comment, but it summarizes my understanding/perspective. "These conclusions are easy to come to looking at this in hindsight. But you can't torpedo a physicians reputation without due process, and it sounds like because of the gymnastics coach, MSU couldn't grasp the full scope of the situation without the story breaking from the USAG side of things. MSU investigated per protocol, and had his practiced supervised for a time. But obviously, he's going to perform his procedures normally while he's being supervised. So what else can really be done? During this point of the investigation, MSU was looking into a single isolated violation [accusation] against a highly regarded physician. This physician also had a reasonable defense to the complaint. Due to HIPAA and other confidentiality laws, I imagine MSU was very limited in their capacity to conduct a full investigation, and there wasn't enough evidence to go to the medical licensing board or conduct a professional investigation, until more victims and complaints began to surface. Until that point I don't think anyone really imagined the depth and depravity of the actual situation."
I have read he was involved with softball, cross country, and gymnastics yet I hear people calling for a university wide death penalty (including basketball, soccer, football, baseball to name a few). What are people's thoughts?
Lol people say lots of things. Of course sports that Nassar wasnt involved with will not be punished. I imagine at the harshest the NCAA will heavily punish the gymnastics program and any others related to Nassar who had officials who acted imprudently.
People are dumb
People who are calling for that are ridiculous. I want every single person who knew about Nassar gone and behind bars for enabling his monstrous behavior. But to punish people who did nothing wrong? Why? I feel like people saying that are people who do not like the MSU football and basketball teams.
If Penn States systematic cover up of child molestation lead to essentially nothing, then the a few members of the gymnastics program not reporting things should lead to nothing.
This has been an embarrassment to my alma mater and people need to be punished hard but that may be the stupidest thing I've ever heard.
Trust me it is but that is what some people have said.
what happened to the FBI investigation?
Just posted this in r/cfb as well.... if someone could help me out.
Hi, without being mercilessly attacked, can anyone please let me know what anybody in the MSU administration did wrong prior to the PR disasters of the last two weeks? I believe as soon as MSU the institution was aware of Nassar he was fired and we already had a full title IX investigation. What exactly did anyone besides those in the COM/Gymnastics program do wrong and why isn't USA Gymnastics the center of this because they knew well before MSU was made aware and didn't tell anyone else he was associated with?
Simon is going to have to go as a symbolic thing, but honestly she hasn't done anything wrong.
MSU first received a report from a victim sometime around 1998 and a few others throughout the years. Not a lot of people knew what was occurring but a few did and that is too many. I love MSU as much as anyone but we are not innocent here. A culture of looking the other way allowed this to occur for far too long. Simon is a bit of a scape goat here but heads absolutely have to roll.
USA gymnastics also needs to be shredded as well.
Who at MSU first received a report though? I thought the report stopped with the Gymnastics program each time? If I missed something please help me find it.
It did, that seemed to be the main roadblock. Once it got passed them, a Title IX investigation was launched that I believe involved MSU Orthopedics and the College of Osteopathic Medicine. Nassar defended that the girl in the complaint didn't understand a medical procedure vs sexual assault. After a period of supervision and a character reference from MSUCOM, he was able to return to practice. It wasn't until after the story broke on the USAG Olympics side a year later, that it was revisited.
The only true negligent act seems to rest with the gymnastics coach. This was a predator with unique a position, when the University, Medical college, and orthopedic department investigated- obviously the pedophile is not going to say he's a pedophile. And at this point in time, he's still a highly regarded physician, and from MSU's perspective they are investigating a single complaint. So they didn't really didn't have a choice except to clear him, especially without knowing the gravity of the situation. Also, people really seem to be forgetting about HIPAA and patient privacy laws, which I suspect made this really difficult to investigate until other victims started voluntarily coming forward.
[deleted]
Just read about this guy. Wow! What a scumbag. Glad he's going to root in jail.
I think this case follows the “repugnant” precedent established against Louisville
oh thank god. if you can't trust the NCAA to properly handle adults and authority figures exploiting young adults who CAN you trust? /s
[deleted]
I'd be willing to bet that the MSU AD and Simon are gone.
As it relates to basketball, it's hard to think Izzo would have known unless he knows eeeeeverything the athletic department does. Unless the NCAA punishes the entire athletics dept, don't figure Izzo and MSU hoops will be affected.
It's kind of in the job description for the AD to try and keep things like this from happening.
Given that, I'd be rather surprised if the AD survives this. It sure sounds like the President at MSU is already on her way out.
Though not strictly college ball related, this could have implications for our athletics program as a whole. Despite that, I'm absolutely rooting for everyone who either knew or ignored the signs to be sacked.
Yuck. Good luck with this, Sparty.
Some really bad looks from the university on this issue that is no fault of the student-athletes.
Thanks for well wishes. It's good to hear.
There are some UM fans on the ol' Facebook feed that are using this whole thing as fuel for their rivalry posting and it makes me sick. Shit like "always knew MSU was shit, go blue!" and the like.
Like holy fuck, who cares about sports. This shit is actually affecting people's lives. And one person employed by the university secretly being a monster piece of trash has nothing to do with the students or 99% of the staff.
Yeah, this goes beyond sports. I mean, I hope the hammer falls on anyone there who ignored or abetted the issue, but it had zero to do with the rivalry or athletes or sports in general.
You should probably remind them that Nassar is a UM grad.
I’m behind anything the NCAA does outside of killing the program just because MSU sports mean so much to me on a personal level. But if that was a decision they made, who would blame them. This is behind awful and everyone who even had something mentioned to them deserved to lose their job and a criminal enquiry.
I'd be against that considering the athletic department as a whole had no idea. Kill the gymnastics program, for sure, but if Penn State still gets to have a football team after systematic cover up of child molestation, MSU certainly shouldn't lose anything more than the gymnastics program for something only members of that program were aware of.
Absolutely. Also, more people need to be aware of how Kathie Klages, the former MSU gymnastics coach who ignored reports from her own athletes and shielded Nassar for years, was allowed to retire rather than be held accountable by our administration.
Kathie Klages seems to be the real main person at fault here.