Was Muhammad really poisoned?

(Question/Discussion)

It is related that Abu Hurayra said, “When Khaybar was conquered, a poisoned sheep was presented to the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace.” ​[Bukhari]

And it is related that ‘A’isha said, “The Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, used to say in his illness from which he died, ‘O ‘A’isha, I still feel the pain of the food which I ate at Khaybar and now I feel as if my aorta is being severed by that poison.'”​

As you can see the Hadiths claim that Muhammad was poisoned and subsequently died. Is is true that Muhammad died because of a Jewish woman poisoning him as an act of revenge? Or did he die of old age?

Thanks in advance for your responses!

Posted Jan 24, 2018, 6:34 PM UTC

1022
ibelongintheclosetNew User•

Filthy Jews killed Muhammed. Sure... Why didn't Allah save him like he did before? Anyway who cares?

8
reallyrunningnow•

That was one of the things I never got. My family uses the "Christianity must be false because God couldn't protect his son/himself from being strung up by a bunch of Romans". Which is a fair point, but it can be also applied to Islam.

There were so many times Muhammad was "warned of some sort of assassination attempt" or given a convenient revelation. Why didn't he get some sort of warning about the poison?

5
Artan42Never-Moose atheist•

because God couldn't protect his son/himself from being strung up by a bunch of Romans

It's not really a fair point as his intention was to die for himself.

3
Tsegen•

No. That's the intention Christians said he always had after he died.

0
Artan42Never-Moose atheist•

Well yeah. They wouldn't say that if he hadn't have died. That would defeat the point.

2
UltrashitpostSince 2012•

That was actually the main motivation for poisoning Mo. The Jewish girl figured that if he were a prophet, then God would save him from being poisoned.

5
ibelongintheclosetNew User•

And what do muslims say about that?

1
UltrashitpostSince 2012•

You'll have to ask them. I didn't find out about that hadith until after my apostasy.

3
houndimus_prime"مرتد سعودي والعياذ بالله" since 2005•

Since our only sources about his death are from Islamic sources, we'll probably never know for sure.

8
jackfruit098Since 2005•

Correct. And Muslim just white washed Muhammad like Eddie Murphy in that SNL skit.

1
Sokrates1981New User•

So it is recorded, and I think we can assume it as true, I see no reason why one would fabricate this story. Muhammad died at the age of about 60, so he was not exactly young anymore. As he seemed to have suffered some permanent damage from the poison, it could have at least contributed to his death by progressively weakening his body. My guess would be that is probably was something with arsenic.

Interestingly, this makes Muhammad a false Prophet even by quranic standards:

Q69.44-46

Sahih international translation: And if Muhammad had made up about Us some [false] sayings, We would have seized him by the right hand; Then We would have cut from him the aorta.

Ahmad Ali translation: Had he attributed falsely any words to Us, We would have seized him by his right hand, Then cut off his aorta,

Ali Qarai translation: Had he faked any sayings in Our name, We would have surely seized him by his right hand, and then cut off his aorta,

Hilali & Khan translation: And if he (Muhammad SAW) had forged a false saying concerning Us (Allah), We surely should have seized him by his right hand (or with power and might), And then certainly should have cut off his life artery (Aorta),

Muhammad Shakir translation: And if he had fabricated against Us some of the sayings, We would certainly have seized him by the right hand, Then we would certainly have cut off his aorta.

Other translations use terms like "life-vein" (Arberry, Daryabadi, Wahihuddin-Khan), "life-artery" (Pickthall), "main artery" (Muhammad Sarvar) "heart's artery" (Ahmad Khan), "artery of his heart" (Yusuf Ali).

According to tafsir Ibn al-Kathir: (And then We certainly would have cut off Al-Watin from him,) Ibn Abbas said, "It (Al-Watin) refers to the artery of the heart, and it is the vein that is attached to the heart.'' This has also been said by Ikrimah, Sa'id bin Jubayr, Al-Hakim, Qatadah, Ad-Dahhak, Muslim Al-Batin and Abu Sakhr Humayd bin Ziyad. Muhammad bin Ka`b said, "It (Al-Watin) is the heart, its blood, and whatever is near it.''

Just think of it. Allah could have killed him with a heart attack, a stroke, let him die the glorious death on battlefield, or snatched him directly up to heaven... but no! A jewess poisons him and he complains for the rest of his life about feeling his aorta being cut. https://www.sunnah.com/bukhari/64/450 https://www.sunnah.com/abudawud/41/20 https://www.sunnah.com/abudawud/41/19

7
jackfruit098Since 2005•

Fake news! Out of context! Mistranslation!

1
i_lurk_here_a_lot•

OFF with his HEAD!!

1
cleverpanda1New User•

Id poison him with piss.

4
ibelongintheclosetNew User•

Be careful that it is not camel piss. You might heal him.

9
ByzantiumI grow tomatos in my back yard and EAT them.•

It was, I think, three years after the Khaibar sheep that he died. He thought it was the Khaibar poison still affecting him, but I suspect that one of his wives may have been still poisoning him.

3
i_lurk_here_a_lot•

Or he could have been severely weakened by the poison. Apparently it left some kind of mark on his face or mouth.

1
Danish9248Allah Is Gay•

These hoes aint loyal

1
NeoMarxismIsEvilمحمد كذب (Never-Moose)•

Assuming he existed then sure, why not, because we have no other information to contradict it.

1
Danish9248Allah Is Gay•

Muhammad died a shitty death. Should've died through Martyr style whilst killing kaffirs LOL

1