r/ps2•
massReduced

Memory card reliability - your experiences?

I need to get new memory cards for both PS2/PS1, as mine seem to end up corrupt or full too quickly. The corruption appears to happen mostly on unofficial cards. Problem is, unofficial cards often have more space available and are the majority you will find for sale.

So what cards have you used, and how reliable have they been?

Posted Jan 25, 2018, 3:25 AM UTC

217
brandokid25•

OEM cards seem to always do fine for me. I dug out my memory card from my childhood days and still had a ton of save files from the early 2000s still on there. Hasn't failed yet, nothing corrupted at all.

I did buy a new OEM memory card on eBay for my PS2 to put all my new game saves on while I use my old one to preserve the old saves. Overall, the official memory cards I've used seem to still hold up very well.

I wouldn't trust unofficial cards if the reliability is questionable, I'd play it safe and stick with OEM cards. But, that's just me.

6
OrcSupremacist•

I’ve never had a single issue with memory cards messing up save files. All of my cards are official cards that I’ve had since the early 2000’s and they’ve never failed on me. I’ve never used an unofficial card so I don’t have any experience with those.

I do end up having to go delete old saves to make room for new ones pretty often, but it’s not that big of a deal to me unless it’s a game like RE4 where I’ve put in multiple playthroughs and hours to get every unlockable item. I just keep those saves and delete the ones from games that don’t have any unlockable content or big reason to keep that particular file.

5
bungiefan_AK•

Why not just use codebreaker or fmcb with UlaunchELF to store your old saves on the hdd, USB drive, or shared network folder on pc? Then you don't have to delete anything.

4
OrcSupremacist•

Because I have no idea what any of that means, lol.

I’m fine with deleting saves, it’s no big deal. I really don’t need to keep six year old saves that was made ten minutes into a game.

2
massReducedOP•

Free McBoot is a a hacked memory card firmware that lets you do some crazy stuff with your PS2. You can copy saves to and from memory cards (both ps1 and ps2) and launch backup discs etc. There's other stuff as well but that's all I've really used it for.

2
bungiefan_AK•

Codebreaker and some other ps2 cheat devices had functions to copy saves to USB drive, so you could download them from the internet or back them up, so you didn't need a ton of expensive memory cards that cost as much as a 128 MB flash drive did back then.

Fmcb is in the sidebar. It is free memory card boot, which lets you boot from a memory card to access homebrew applications. UlaunchELF is a file manager and application launcher that can manage files on optical disc, memory card, hard drive, USB drive, and network share, so you can copy saves to and from those devices to keep your files without buying additional cards. With that and a 4 GB flash drive, I never run out of space with just 2 memory cards.

1
benryves•

I've generally used the official 8MB cards and haven't lost any data yet. I do also have an unofficial 64MB card but I've never really used it as it didn't work at all in any of the games I tested it with, only the main system browser (where I have been able to use it to temporarily back up files if I needed to clear some space from my main card). I guess some games support the larger cards but as far as I can see most need an 8MB one and that's plenty of space so I don't see the need to go any larger for general day-to-day saving needs.

5
garasensei•

I haven't lost a save yet on official cards. I stayed away from third party after having such bad experiences on the multi page cards. Stick to official.

3
davidbrit2•

Over the years, I've never had a single problem with these cards:

  • Official PS1 memory cards
  • MadCatz silver multi-page memory cards (with the little red rocker button)
  • Official PS2 memory cards
  • Multi-page officially licensed PS2 memory cards (in 2 and 4 page varieties, can't remember the brand, but they're black, and have little 1-4 LEDs and a button on the front)

I have had those shitty old PS1 multi-page cards that used compression lose entire pages of saves before. Those things were always garbage. The silver MadCatz ones work fine, as they don't do any compression hijinks. You're probably just manually bank switching the flash chip by toggling the high-order address lines. The little LCD on them that shows what page you're on tends to get flaky, but the 32-page card I've been using for many years has never had any problems with the actual data.

2
Oloneise•

Mine still work fine with saves from the early 2000s on them. The only time I've ever heard people running into issues with cards is when they were sketchy third party ones, but they were problem cards when they were new as well.

2
MorbidTorture•

Official PS2 cards can be had on eBay for just a few dollars. I actually just bought 2 official cards for $8 & free shipping. Just search for them :)

2
xCROOKEDx•

For PS1, I've never had an issue with Mad Catz 1MB cards - the current set I have still have saves from over 7 years ago.

As for PS2, I was wondering the same thing.

2
PM_EVANGELION_LOLI•

I still have my original memory card from like 2001 and it still works fine, it's one of those yellow and black Nyko brand I think.

2
massReducedOP•

This one?, i think i had one of those back in the day, such nostalgia.

1
PM_EVANGELION_LOLI•

YES! lol that's exactly it

1
Santi76•

I have always used official and I've never had any file go corrupt. I'd always just sick to official cards, they're so cheap anyways that it doesn't make sense to go with a generic brand.

1
Eddy_0205•

Original PS2 card: lost for like 2 years. Works fine. Fake PS2 card: it was my backup card. It's dead for a stupid reason. There's NOT ENOUGHT METAL on the contacts, so it keeps disconnecting. Cheap copies are bad copies :(

1