Should I cash savings bonds early? How much potential interest will I lose?
Hi PF,
I understand the basic concept of how savings bonds work but trying to figure them out still confuses me. I have 9 of them, here's where they're at right now, copied from the Treasury's calculator. (If images aren't allowed here I'll remove it and edit this post with the info.)
I've had a rough patch over the past 6 months and cashing ALL of them in now would really help me dig out of a hole and relieve a lot of anxiety. At the same time, I'm hesitating because all the advice I've read seems to scream against doing so because you're leaving money on the table, etc. It feels like a dumb question as I'm writing it, but am I better off cashing them in now or sitting on them for the next few years? Pay debt now seems like a smarter option than sitting and waiting for a few more dollars in the future, but I guess I'm afraid of making another bad/misinformed decision.
The one that matured yesterday is getting cashed on Monday. It only earned $2.02 since August, so I assume the $50 ones due in April will do the same and the $100 one will get around $4. I can certainly eat $8 in interest to get an extra $500 immediately. Can anyone help me figure out the interest I'd be losing out on if I cashed out the other ones?
(Side question, is cashing them in as easy as going to the bank and saying I want to do so? Bank of America is the only physical bank I have an account with [I know, I know] and when I called to ask what the process was, the only thing the girl would say to me was "Well ma'am, you'll have to step inside a financial center for that." I assumed it was complicated because the smaller local bank I used to work at wouldn't cash savings bonds.)
Thanks y'all!
edit: words are dumb.
Posted Feb 3, 2018, 12:17 AM UTC
I think you're overcomplicating the analysis. If you can get a better return than 4% (except for the first one that's already matured, and the last one at 1.56% of course) by cashing in the bonds now, then cash them. If you've gone into debt recently, consider that paying off that debt early is equivalent to getting an immediate, risk-free return equal to the interest rate.
As for cashing them, since you have an immediate need to cash the bonds, I would go through with trying to get it cashed at BoA. Many institutions restrict EE bond cashing to members, while others will restrict bond cashing for non-members to $1000/day. I'm guessing that bond cashing is not something BoA tellers are trained on anymore, so they'd need you to wait for someone who knows how to do it. Either that, or they want to try and hook you into a sales pitch for investing through them.
If you had a bit more time, or if you didn't need to cash them all out, you could consider converting the bonds to electronic bonds. There's an overview for how to do it in the wiki entry on savings bonds. Once you convert them, you can cash them at any time by logging onto the Treasury website, and they'll electronically transfer the proceeds into your checking or savings account.
Don't forget when you file your tax return for 2018 next year that you owe income tax on the accrued interest (though it's exempt from state and local taxes).
I swear I checked the wiki before posting and didn't see that entry at all. Thanks for the link; sorry for being dumb.
You're right, I'm making it way too complicated. I'll take them all to BoA on Monday, pay down some debt, and wash my hands of it. (Til next year, anyway.) Thanks so much for the help!