Andreas addressing some concerns about bitcoin as a deflationary currency
Posted Feb 6, 2018, 7:14 PM UTC
Posted Feb 6, 2018, 7:14 PM UTC
Am I the only one who feels this is a little bit...narrow?
[deleted]
I dont quite agree with this. Deflation can actually work as "tax" in new productivity. Just an extreme example to convey what I mean. I own all bitcoin except for one. The rest of the world entire economy is trading in that single bitcoin. Now, all new value added to the economy actually grows my wealth. This is cool if you got the bitcoin, but ideally every new bitcoin worth of production should get a corresponding bitcoin added to the total amount of bitcoins. This is in part what our current system attempts.
Why should it? If you're holding bitcoin or any other currency, you essentially have an abstracted general claim on all assets. Bitcoin/currency has no use to anyone in and of itself. No one wants a currency for any other purpose than to trade into a real asset at a later point in time. It holds no true productive value like oil, wood, etc. You can either do one of two things with currency, either hold it or trade it for some other good or service. If I "save" the currency, I essentially am foregoing my claim on assets at that time. That means that I don't reserve, use or exhaust real physical resources (whether food, tractors, labor, etc.), but instead allowing those resources to be allocated to others that will be more productive with those resources. Their production increases the total amount of true wealth of goods and services in society, allowing people to buy more with the same amount of currency (assuming the supply of currency remains constant). Deflation would therefore be the "tax" or, better yet, the "return" that one should receive for not utilizing resources that can be allocated more productively elsewhere in the economy.
If I "save" the currency, I essentially am foregoing my claim on assets at that time.
Exactly, and in this case your claim becomes greater over time.
Not as a percentage of the whole.*
Yes, it's deflationary, but what is the real rate of deflation? Not how much was lost in it's infancy, but what percent in a year, after the presumed mass adoption period is 10-20 years behind us?
The purpose of that question is to get to the next conclusion: "Let's build in inflation that counters the loss over time, so the supply actually stays the same."
This can't be done, because now an inflation schedule precedent is set, which means it can become a political target for change. This thing requires a set, and unrelenting hardcoded supply.
.000001% inflation is negligible.
.000001% deflation is negligible.
If we could guarantee either of those, by some magical universal proof, I wouldn't even care which one it is, I'd take it.
But we can't, so we go with a hard code, and accept that until some point in the future there will be coin loss, which is countered already by coin creation, until that stops on 2140.
Exactly, and in this case your claim becomes greater over time.
By 2140 the amount of deflation from coin loss will be negligible, so I find the tax/"greater claim" argument to be a little too much.
So to reiterate: As percentage of the whole, your claim (as a majority stake holder) will increase when coins are lost, very very marginally, after 2140.
The effect I'm talking about is not due to deflation actually. Lets just say its a static amount of btc in the economy for the sake of argument. Now, if the economy grows, say 10%, and you hold 99% of the coins, your coins can now buy 10% more. This basically means you become richer (you can buy more stuff the for same amount if btc) just by holding on to your btc. The picture in the current system would be that alongside the 10% growth could be accompanied by an equal 10% of the circulating supply of money (distributed via loans to investments etc) to the participants in the market ie. not to you sitting on the sideline with a bunch of cash not participating.
Your hands are an asset. If you choose to sit on them or ‘hodl’ them, should you be rewarded for that? Or should you be rewarded for using them to add value to something?
Based on my previous comment, my answer would clearly be no... it's preferable for finite resources to be allocated to their most productive ends. Holding bitcoin/currency is by definition a deliberate decision abstaining from utilizing resources so they can be put to greater use elsewhere. Not sure the point you're trying to prove. Take a moment and consider what I wrote.
If you have a resource and don’t use it, how can someone else use it? If that’s the case then the resource was never yours.
Resting hands are an opportunity cost (in some cases), not an asset.
In other cases, hands are a burden.
using them to add value to something
Universally, "Work" =/= "Good".
Value is subjective and the purpose of money should be a medium to exchange perceived value between.
I'd like to have 1 hour of my time in my 20's equal to 1 hour of my time in my 40's.
When I'm 90, 1 hour of my time would hold much less value to other people than 1 hour of time in my physical/mental prime years.
Why should those earlier years lose that value of work I put in?
Japan has inflation now but they had to do a massive QE. It's lame because salaries aren't really going higher while we see higher prices :/.
What a load of shite!
Solid well thought out rebuttal there 🙄
Ditto
Love it, always inspiring.