An Unpopular Opinion

Football

I think we should roll with Hundley as the backup this year.

Now hear me out, I know he's not good. But if our goal this year is actually to make a superbowl run our focus should be on keeping Rodgers on the field, not on upgrading his backup. Everyone talks about signing a veteran backup QB or drafting another QB. I would much rather spend those resources on upgrading our Oline. We could likely get 2 veteran Guards for the cost of getting a veteran backup QB. With a 3rd round pick we could possibly get a decent backup RT, possibly even a future starter.

Unless you're willing to bet our Oline is gonna stay healthy this season.

Posted Feb 7, 2018, 4:24 PM UTC

052
JerginMagergin•

A veteran guard and veteran qb both cost roughly 3m. I agree that we shouldn't be drafting a qb before round 5, but I do think we should sign one.

18
vanweOP•

Even so, I'd rather have a guard.

2
JerginMagergin•

I'm not sure how big of a need guard is. We've always been able to find lesser known guys and turn them into decent guards. The big concern is RT. If Murphy/Spriggs aren't the answer then we will need to a dress that somewhat early in the draft. I'm not concerned about RG because I think Patrick, McCray, Evans(FA), or Spriggs can move inside and have a good season.

3
vanweOP•

RT is certainly the bigger issue and I agree, it should be addressed in the draft. However a veteran guard would also likely have experience at either tackle or center, and could serve as a backup for those as well. With as many injuries as we have had at every position on our OL, a serviceable and healthy backup OL would be more valuable to me than a backup QB.

1
JerginMagergin•

I think QB is a more important position than OG. Clearly you disagree so I guess that we can agree to disagree.

1
thepwnyclub•

In what world does a veteran qb cost 3m?

2

I looked through the backups on this a while back thinking a good backup cost about $5m, really Foles was the only non-bridge (McCown/Glennon) backup over $4m with most in the $2m-$3m range (Keenum, Hoyer @$1.6m, Cassel, Anderson, McCoy).

These guys can be gotten for pretty cheap.

4
JerginMagergin•

For the most part there are five different types of QBs, there are superstars, average starters, veteran bridge qbs, backups, and there are young qbs.

Guys like Foles, McCown, and Hoyer(2017) are bridge qbs. Bridge qbs are veterans that are good enough to start, but you are always going to be looking for a younger QB to come in and take over. Usually bridge qbs are paired with 1st/2nd round picks and will end up starting a year while the rookie qb is still developing. Bridge qbs cost around 6m per year.

Backup qbs are usually paired with a veteran qb and they are paid 3m or less per year. Some examples of backup qbs are Hoyer(2018), Fitzpatrick, Keenum(2017), Geno Smith, Matt Moore, and Chase Daniel.

2
ill_be_bakhtiari•

We have 11 draft picks. That's more than enough to draft OL and a new backup QB.

9
vanweOP•

I don't have much of a problem with drafting a project QB in the later rounds, just don't expect him to be an upgrade from Hundley in his first year. There are too many needs on this team to be spending an earlier round pick on a player you're hoping doesn't ever see the field.

2
StockmanBaxter•

I think the Eagles proved it's important to have a good backup.

Anything can happen at any time. I don't want a concussion to Rodgers that takes him out for game and a half to give us 2 losses.

7
vanweOP•

I think the Eagles proved that if the rest of your team is very good, an elite QB is not necessary. Unless our defense takes a surprisingly large step forward in the first year under a new Defensive Coordinator, no backup in the league would be enough. Foles would not have taken us to the superbowl last year.

7
StockmanBaxter•

Nobody said we need an elite backup qp. Just that Hundley has cost us games when our defense kept the score low.

3
vanweOP•

He certainly did, but as I said in my original post this is "if our goal this year is actually to make a superbowl run". A better backup is not going to accomplish that. If your goal is only to make the playoffs again, then yes an upgrade from Hundley would be a viable option.

2
the_0rly_factor•

Foles is not considered an elite QB but he was very good, particularly in the post season.

In 3 games: 77/106, 971 yards, 6 TDs, 1 Int

72.6% completion rate in 3 postseason games is pretty damn good.

The Eagles have a lot of talent but you gotta give Foles some credit for those numbers.

2
vanweOP•

I did not intend to imply that Foles was bad or deserved no credit if that was your takeaway here. But you have to admit that the rest of his team deserves a good amount of the credit for those numbers as well. Even if they were entirely due to Foles, that would not have been enough to win if their defense had not also held the Falcons to 10 points. Our defense gave up 34 points to them.

1
Tiki-Tiger•

What the Eagles did has never happened before, AFAIK. And they are in a different situation as they have not had to pay Carson Wentz yet, so can have a very good roster by playing other players.

It is very simple--if Rodgers goes down, the season is fucked. Cut Brett Hundley but only if you get someone for less or not have to waste a draft pick on a promising player at a position we need. There are a lot of holes to fill right now.

2
stagman35•

But last time that happened we won the SB

0
failingtolurk•

We got the wildcard and a severe disadvantage.

If we can win a few with a back up we can hold steady. With Hundley we let at least 2 games go that just a tad better QB could have won.

2
stagman35•

I shouldve used the /s

-3
stuckinacubicle•

You owe someone a pizza

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Siddhendrix•

Pay the man his pizza.

1
the_0rly_factor•

Why are these things mutually exclusive? Of course they will do whatever they can to help Rodgers. That's a given. That doesn't mean you ignore the backup situation and hope nothing happens to Rodgers.

6
vanweOP•

Of course if we can do both that would be better, but we had 44 total games played by offensive lineman on 1 year deals last season. Add onto this the best of those, who started 14 games, is rumored to be retiring.

2
F_D_Romanowski•

Hundley needs to go even if our backup next year is a 3rd round rookie.

5
thepwnyclub•

Hundley is still on his cheap rookie contract, why would we bother cutting him? Also this was basically his roomie year. Almost all rookie qbs look bad their first year.

2
F_D_Romanowski•

3 years he's been here. Coaching staffs don't have the luxury of investing time, money, and a roster spot on a QB wishing and hoping something clicks for him eventually. The overwhelming majority of QB's who have tried to make a career in the NFL have failed. Hundley has shown nothing that says he can make it as a backup.

1
vanweOP•

There's no way I would spend a 3rd round pick on a QB with this team. I would much rather have a 3rd round OL. I would be hesitant to spend even a 4th round pick on a QB.

1
F_D_Romanowski•

How do you know what we will draft in the 3rd round before the coaching staff ? The combine is still a month away for God's sake. When all the picks fall into place there may not be an O-lineman available they think is worth a 3rd round pick compared to another player at another position. Regardless of where we draft a QB or sign one from free agency, Hundley should not be our backup QB.

3
amccune•

It's very possible that one of our first two picks could be a O-Line.

3
Gawdlytroll•

And if you bet on our O-line being healthy then you haven’t watched the Packers the last 5 years. The Pack is doing exactly what the Saints are doing. Wasting top tier talent at the most valuable position.

1†
law_student3340•

I don't disagree with you, but if a good offer comes up for Hundley (unlikely but possible) then we have more than enough picks to grab another QB. I don't think we should forsake Hundley yet, but we also shouldn't pass up an opportunity if it arises.

1
vanweOP•

This is the one circumstance I would change my opinion on. I just don't think a decent offer on Hundley is realistic.

2
zZChicagoZz•

Signing two veteran guards doesn't guarantee Rodgers stays healthy...

1
vanweOP•

Neither does replacing Hudley, but at least my option improves the chances of keeping Rodgers healthy.

1
zZChicagoZz•

Replacing Hundley could improve our season if Rodgers DOES go down.

See: Eagles season.

1
vanweOP•

As I said in my original post "if our goal this year is actually to make a superbowl run". Foles would not have taken our team to the superbowl, no backup QB in the league would have. Heck, most starting QBs in the league would not have. If you just want to make the playoffs again, then upgrading from hundley is a good option.

0
zZChicagoZz•

How about we just roll with aaron rodgers, and just cut hundley/callahan by your logic? Like if Rodgers isnt starting then fuck it all, and send all the players home amirite?

1
Firefox247•

The problem with that is in the NFL you have to assume that your back-up QB will see the field at some point.

1
milhouse234•

So if Rodgers gets hurt again, you basically want us to have no realistic shot at winning again. Because we know what hundleys ceiling is. Hes just flat out bad. A veteran backup would cost but a few million, and a mid/late draft pick wouldn't hurt us at all. We have other needs, but to say we should completely forget about trying to get qb depth and run with someone we already know won't do us any good is pretty ridiculous

1
vanweOP•

I am saying that if Rodgers misses significant playing time like he did last year, we don't have a realistic shot of making a superbowl run. I would like to believe we could do so with an upgraded backup QB, but I don't.

1
milhouse234•

If Rodgers gets hurt again it pushes my point. Why stick with something we already know won't work. Take a chance on someone else because if we stick with hundley the only wins we'll get are from bottom of the barrel teams. We aren't competitive with him behind center

1