r/Buddhism•
humanbug

Slate Article: "Prescribing Mindfulness Allows Doctors to Ignore Legitimate Female Pain"

Question

Hello everyone. I wanted to ask your advice about the problem this article presents, which I've seen elsewhere too. Briefly, from this piece:

"But I think it goes even deeper than this very practical and perhaps even somewhat understandable reason. Mindfulness also happens to fit into a rhetoric of personal responsibility that has long infused American health care. Although ostensibly mindfulness originates in Eastern practices, Kabat-Zinn successfully reframed an Eastern practice in Western terms when he transformed meditation to mindfulness. Mindfulness fits in quite successfully with bootstrapping American values—through self-management, self-control, the right attitude, and daily practice, you can take control of your own life and illness. Of course the flip side of that logic is that if your pain is still debilitating, it’s your fault for failing to follow the protocol correctly."

I personally came to meditation through secular "mindfulness," as part of treatment for an anxiety disorder, and it's been enormously beneficial to me. But there is much cultural pressure for mindfulness to be part of a way to "achieve your best self" and "be productive and successful," a pressure that makes it more difficult for me to practice personally, and, according to this article, exacerbates pain in many patients.

Does anyone had advice about how to address or understand this cultural pressure, both in private practice and in conversations with others?

Thanks in advance.

Posted Feb 11, 2018, 5:18 PM UTC

59
ZFree2013mahayana•

This is nothing new. Having written my dissertation and studied further into mindfulness since, you'll find many accounts of people that have negative effects with meditation and mindfulness upon it's removal from the underpinnings of the Dharma.

One of the biggest problems has been a blindness to accepting any negative side effects. It's application today can be found in sports (running), science, healthcare and peak performance, and specifically in the proliferation of the 'self' in the economic system. Any negativity is met with criticism by the many for whom it has presented positive effects. And of course, since mindfulness is by definition a personal and therefore relatively abstract (from a philosophical premise anyway) experience - it's easy to say someone is 'doing it wrong', rather than to investigate deeper. For those undergoing mindfulness therapy for medical reasons as an example - this can be very distressing.

From the Western point of view we have suggestions that mindfulness can cause pronunciation of depression/anxiety, can implement false memories, escapism, depersonalization, psychosis, delusions, hallucinations, and particularly adverse effects to those suffering from PTSD.

Of course Eastern religion already knew of this.

Makyo - is a figurative reference to the kind of self-delusion that results from clinging to an experience and making a conceptual “nest” out of it for oneself. Makyō is essentially synonymous with illusion, but especially in reference to experiences that can occur within meditation practice. More info

Zen school's have particularly taken note of this experience. I have experienced similar, and can understand where the sense of depersonalisation in particular comes into play.

And in Zen we have something called 'Zen sickness' Which, whilst difficult to universally pin down from experience to experience - is the premise of depersonalisation, or rather a disconnect/imbalance. Looking up the term will give you a greater breadth of information on the topic. Therevadha explores similar themes but would classify theirs as 'restlessness in the path' AFAIK.

The core issue for me is that when you remove mindfulness from the Dharma's guidance you do not have the underpinning to deal with nor understand the effects of the direct experience. Mindfulness on it's own is an intrinsic human practice of awareness that does not belong to anyone - but that does not mean it is by nature perfected. Like any natural occurrence, it has good and bad uses.

Mindfulness is not supposed to 'make' you happy, nor compete faster or push a peanut up mount Fuji with your nose - these are personal superimposements. Mindfulness for applicaton in the Dharma is about self-perception and awareness, from that the Dharma guides the practitioner towards the stages of enlightenment. The Dharma has answers for depersonalisation, attachment, ego, and spontaneous living - the secular delivery however can often fall down in this department, especially if the teacher is not particularly fond of understanding the concept in greater depth than the exploration of it's practicality in application.

That said it can be highly effective in the mangment of pain, especially those with chronic conditions and it's use is definetely warranted - the question is finding balance imo. Using it as a tool for getting you a leg up in Samsara is fine, but there has to be an understanding of the cultural effects.

4
AjeevakShakyaputtanon-affiliated•

Why is the only female pain being ignored?

3
Rks1157Theravāda•

I read this article last week. It paints a sorry picture of the health care providers involved but perhaps not a complete picture of the patients, their presenting conditions and their history.

3
Kedasien•

I spent some time in a rehabilitation clinic where I met quite a few people with chronic pain. Some found meditation helpful others not so much. Meditation can be frustrating and make people even more aware of pain in their body especially when they are just starting meditation.

Treating pain is difficult, especially when no biological origin can be found. Prescription medicine may not provide enough relief and has serious downsides. Mindfulness is an relatively safe and evidence based way of managing pain. It is not perfect in any way shape or form as a treatment for pain but generally it is helpful. Maybe in the future there will be more effective ways of dealing with chronic pain, in the meantime I think we should help those suffering in any way we can including meditation.

As for the cultural pressure you experience in relation with meditation I will say this. Some people use mindfulness and mediation to become better off financially, or be more successful. Others do it to be more healthy and happy. Some do it to reach enlightenment for the benefit of all beings. And some other people meditate for its own sake. All of them are valid reasons for practice, and all practitioners will gain something from it.

You will have to decide for yourself what your reason for meditation will be. Seems to me that your goal is to live with less anxiety and to learn to live according to your own definition of “successful” instead of societies definition. Mindfulness and meditation helped me with this, and I am sure it can help you too. If somebody else want to meditate because they want to be more financially successful or achieve some ideal version self, just let them do it. But don’t let them dictate your practice. You decide what you want to do with your life and your reasons for practicing.

I hope my blabbering has helped you in some way.

3
humanbugOP•

Thanks very much, your thoughts were extremely helpful!

2
Uqbaritibetan•

Future article idea: "Which is more beneficial, mindfulness or marijuana?"

2
hurfery•

How is this a gender issue?

2
colourfulsoul369•

Prolonged meditation has excacerbated ptsd for me.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-6