Let's have a serious discussion about the problems our LE face dealing with illegal immigrants.

Read my post history for proof/details.

So I work in LE, and have been doing some soul searching this evening. I was in a hit & run today, as a private citizen, by an illegal immigrant, and was on the receiving end of the justice system.

Long story short, nothing was really done to an illegal who was driving without a license, had no documentation, fled the scene of an accident, and had no insurance. I've been left to fucking pay to fix my car out of pocket.

So I started doing some thinking tonight. At first I was really upset with the town PD in the way they handled the situation. But I had to ask myself a really honest question - do I really handle situations with illegals any different than the town PD? Can I really fault them for their actions?

And I've got some observations/answers.

First is the language barrier. I speak a little bit of spanish, not much, but enough to get a few words across. Another centipede pointed out in my earlier thread that I should not be forced to speak spanish in order to exchange information in an accident -which I largely agree with.

Then I think about my day-to-day job, which I'll get to later below - and I realize language has a big part to do with how I handle interactions with immigrants.

Second, there's the "great unknown" in terms of what's legal/not legal with interacting with them. Unless you're specifically trained with how to handle illegal immigrants, you really don't know a lot about what you can or cannot do or say, and most LEOs probably get nervous about this as well.

So with my job, I enforce a certain section of laws on the state level. This enforcement generally just results in a summons, but can include an arrest in some cases. I am by no means a traffic enforcement officer, nor do I deal with the daily "regular" LE work, but I can say at least from my job, and what I have observed with local and county guys/gals, we are largely not equipped/trained to deal with immigration. None of us really know what to do with illegals, and when you can't even talk to them, because of the language barrier, it makes it difficult.

So sitting and reflecting on my career, I have had to honestly ask myself if I have been in a situation like the local guys were today, and I can say that I have been.

And pedes, I don't think I've handled that situation any better.

The times I've dealt with illegals, they've mostly been migrant crews that work on farms. My job also doesn't allow me any real backup, I'm on my own to cover several counties.

When I've had issues where I've had to go talk to someone for violating some law that I enforce, I usually go and try to explain the law, issue a summons for the charges, and then release them on cognizance. Worst case, I have someone getting mouthy or violent, and I simply shut down the conversation and take them to county, so they can await a judge the next morning, who will decide what will be done.

But there's a few cases where I've had a "minor" infraction, something where I probably wouldn't make an arrest, but would have issued a summons to appear, but they can't speak english, and then they come out of the woodwork and overwhelm me, all bombarding me with spanish for what I'm assuming is, "I didn't do anything".

In those cases, I've been by myself and did not feel comfortable trying to get someone to submit to a summons by gestures alone, because really - if I can't get them to sign a summons, I should then be making an arrest.

They can't understand what I'm saying (or at least they claim that's the case), and claim that I'm not speaking spanish correctly (although I'm pretty sure I'm getting enough across to make sense), so they always act like they don't understand and then if you try and make an arrest, you're going to be by yourself against 12-15 guys, in the middle of nowhere.

The department policy is to go out to a main road and wait for backup in those cases. Which we can get, but it just takes an hour or longer. And by that time, Pedro and his buddies have already loaded up in a UTV and have disappeared.

Also, most of the time these are, again, minor infractions that are normally just a summons where you appear in court, we let the judge decide your fine, and you go about your day - maybe you get a year or two of probation, but nothing that is serious enough that I feel like I should be risking my life to bring them in.

So you catch yourself in these situations thinking about going home to your family, and then you think about pedro and his younger cousins that have face tatts and illegal weapons shoved down their pants.

You have to sit and think about if it's worth trying to enforce the law equally and fairly on these people, the way you do normal everyday citizens.

And honestly the answer usually ends up being "it's not worth it" after they've circled around you, with 15 people all running their mouths off in a language you aren't fluent in, and you feel threatened. You can go get that "backup", sure, but by the time they get there they're long gone, as mentioned above. Or you can play your cards and hope that you can get dude to peacefully come into your car to go to county, and you're hoping his cousins don't decide that you're target practice.

It's a fucked up situation.

I don't really know where I'm going with this, other than trying to start a conversation.

Those of us on the local, county, and state level are mostly not equipped to deal with them, and those of us like myself who work for agencies that are underfunded and do not have the people to support you, end up with situations where you enforce the law on citizens, but when it comes to these enclaves of non-citizens, you have to decide if you're job is worth your life.

And that shit is fucked up.

Thoughts? Conversation?

I just feel like I need to talk about this.

Spez: maybe some other LEOpedes can chime in, especially if you've got experience with illegals. In my job, only about 10% of my cases involve them, but they do pop up, and the questions remain.... Especially after having this bad taste in my mouth today due to the way that hit and run was handled by local guys.

Posted Feb 17, 2018, 12:35 AM UTC · edited

125
just_leave_me_alone_FF•

Gonna need a TLDR for this one, pede

2
anharmonicaOPMemeWarrior•

TL;DR - how to enforce laws on illegals, as a small department, when they hoard up in enclaves of their buddies and cousins, likely have weapons, language barrier exists, and you've got little to no backup, and you find yourself in positions where you have to wonder if you're going to be killed to keep miguel out of jail.

And then if that's fair to regular citizens (it's not), and how to reconcile that.

Like the last few sentences show in the post, it's fucked up and I don't have answers. Just trying to open some discussion on solutions.

1
littleirishmaidUSA•

Will your insurance cover the accident against an uninsured driver that fled the scene?

2
anharmonicaOPMemeWarrior•

They will cover it, but I'm going to have to pay a $500 deductible, and they were very sketchy about my rate going up.

1
littleirishmaidUSA•

Sorry to hear this. In my state you don’t have to have insurance I’d you own your car outright. I’ve been in your situation. I don’t recall it going up. You can always change companies if it does. No harm shopping.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1