Why is everybody so upset about the CDirk buff?

[Discussion]

I’ve never had a CDirk, so this might be a little biased because I’ve never used the original CDirk, only the buffed one.

Anyway, I was messing around on the testing server, and I found that I was prefer CDirk over Etherite. Why? Because it had longer range, so it was safer to use in godlands, and because sometimes you can only get a few shots in on a boss, so you want to deal soulbound with that, and Etherite dealt less damage than CDirk did with each shot.

Idk tho, maybe CDirk didn’t really change after the buff, but I still preferred it over Etherite.

So, I personally liked the CDirk buff. If you didn’t like it, what’s your reasoning?

Posted Feb 22, 2018, 3:49 AM UTC

449
Rocketboy4221Did I mention Necro = best class?•

The DPS of Cdirk is still lower than Etherite's. The entire point of "Buff Cdirk" was to make it better than etherite because of it's status as a rare event white.

14
LikeClockwork6OPMore like Lord of the Never Drops Ogmur•

Yeah. What I wanted to say (but didn’t for some reason) is that Etherite isn’t always useful, it’s most useful on anemia’s you can get really close to. I agree, for its rarity CDirk should be more powerful, but it is still a really good dagger right now.

2
PurplePC420•

Anemia’s?

1
NekoTheCat12370 | NekoTheCat•

Enemies

3
LikeClockwork6OPMore like Lord of the Never Drops Ogmur•

Oops, autocorrect.

I wrote that on mobile.

1
CNeinSneaky•

But generally good players and most rogues can stay within close range of the grand majority of enemies, why should an incredibly rare white be nothing but a dps drop that makes gameplay less engaging from further range?

1
LikeClockwork6OPMore like Lord of the Never Drops Ogmur•

Yeah, rogue is basically the main reason CDirk is worse than Etherite. I do agree that CDirk probably needs a change, but the issue is that everybody was asking for a buff, so they got a buff not a rework.

1
CNeinSneaky•

I’d called for Cronus to armor pierce before stinger had been created but its hard to think of an interesting form of exclusivity for Cronus now. The only thing that really makes sense to me now is to make something like the D-Blade for dagger classes but, I’d like to see it armor pierce so that it isn’t punished for the sheer amount of projectiles it would emit on max dex classes. Something like a 2 range armor piercing pixie sword I guess. ¯\(ツ)/¯

1
Atomic_heart•

Making etherite just "more dps" will make no sence. It will just screw everyone who doesnt have cdirk and will lead to nothing.

1
Rocketboy4221Did I mention Necro = best class?•

It doesnt neccessarily have to have more dps than etherite, it could have a niche like all the others UTs instead.

1
Atomic_heart•

Ye, i think cdirk should give some interesting mechanics

1
MadmanGMIGN:Studio•

Yeah that’s the point of having a fuckin ultra rare dagger

1
Atomic_heart•

Nah, making any dagger op, especially cdirk will just make dagger classes unplayable without it. Event white is not about stats, its about mechanics.

1
MadmanGMIGN:Studio•

Warrior isn’t unplayable without jugg, Knight isn’t unplayable without ogmur, they just makes the classes a lot better, so I don’t see why cdirk has to be a vanity item

1
EdudremagI make bad posts (usually)•

Etherite is still doing the job of a situational event white better than the actual item... My suggestion would just be to take prod CDirk and switch the fire rate with Etherite

4
CancerPatient1337Card haHAA•

because it isn't unique, the pros and cons make them basically equal with eachother, which shouldn't be the case with a god damn event white

2
LikeClockwork6OPMore like Lord of the Never Drops Ogmur•

Tablet is an event white and is still basically the most useless spell ever

Yeah, I suppose it does lack the unique aspect that most of the other event whites have. I mean, a lot of UTs are unique, but some are really lackluster, and most event whites are unique.

3
NekoTheCat12370 | NekoTheCat•

On the flipside, players who haven't got a cdirk can use a weapon with very similar stats by saving up and trading for one, rather than hoping they get it as a 0.1% chance drop from a realm encounter.

Basically, having Etherite be very similar isn't really a bad thing, so more players have access to a good weapon

0
reeeeeee1818•

It is a bad thing.

2
NekoTheCat12370 | NekoTheCat•

Thank you for your insightful argument

0†
CancerPatient1337Card haHAA•

That makes no fucking sense. Why should a tradeable item be practically the same thing as an event white. That's like saying DECA should make a variation of a jugg into a tradeable ST just to let people have access to a good item

2
NekoTheCat12370 | NekoTheCat•

Or unsoulbound jugg. It's an item that so many people will never be able to use due to its rarity. And, even if you get it, you can lose it so quickly because permadeath

1
Glass_MarbleZquidx•

The belief that CDirk should have more damage AND more range than Etherite breaks the fundamental principle of risk vs. reward and will never happen.

2
Therdlol•

No. Cdirk is an event white. Etherites are sold in the nexus.

2
Glass_MarbleZquidx•

It is not a matter of "justice", but of game design. In endgame, where balancing matters the most, an item simply should not be strictly better than another in every situation.

1
Therdlol•

T5 is strictly better than t6. Just like a white bag should strictly be better than an item sold in the nexus.

0
ImasquashBees?•

Lmao that was probably the worst example you could possibly use.

1
Glass_MarbleZquidx•

T5 is not endgame. There is intended progression from T5 to T6. There is no natural upgrade progression across categories like Tiered Items, White Bag Items, ST Items, etc.

If you believe that "a white bag should strictly be better than an item sold in the nexus", you should argue for your opinion, not use the opinion as your main argument and expect everyone to understand. You should also reflect on whether your beliefs are consistent.

Should all white bags that are less commonly used than tradeable items be buffed? Should all ST items that are used without the rest of the set be nerfed?

1
turbindzinejsactually retarded•

Etherite fires 19% faster though.

2
BlackMoth27so deca saw my flair hmm.•

as a person using etherite more on testing, the buff feels weak, personally both are better than the t12 dagger, but i personally feel insulted by the weak as buff that doesn't make it better than etherite. like that was the point.

2
LikeClockwork6OPMore like Lord of the Never Drops Ogmur•

Yeah definitely. The only time I used the T12 dagger was on bosses like the Parasite Chambers one, anything you can’t really get close to.

1
BlackMoth27so deca saw my flair hmm.•

well if i had my pet it wouldn't be such a big deal on parasite. pet free it's a real challenge. then again parasites with my pet is me sitting in a corner spamming poison.

1
LikeClockwork6OPMore like Lord of the Never Drops Ogmur•

Yeah, same. Assassin isn’t too great in chambers.

2
israphialMODMod | isranoob•

Flair changed to discussion.

2
ImasquashBees?•

Because they are idiots who don't understand the concept of balance.

1