r/AskDocs•
muscleups

Required information so your post doesn't get removed - mandatory!

Pinned

Dear r/askdocs users,

The last few weeks, more and more posts are being made without including the required information found in our rules. Though this information may seem redundant or useless to some, it can provide important context to a doctor reading your question, and help tremendously with an accurate and speedy answer. The required info can be found here: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskDocs/about/rules/

We ask you provide at minimum your age, approximate height & weight, gender, medications you take, smoking status, previous and current medical issues, duration and location of complaint, and a photo (if it's a skin issue).

We have been getting a number of messages from users who think their post doesn't require them to post demographic information and they should have their post approved. 100% of the time, upon reviewing their post, demographic information would benefit users trying to assist them.

No, your post is not an exception. If your question really doesn't require your demographic information, your question can most likely simply be Googled.

If you are concerned about giving your information out online, create a throwaway account. Regardless, this information is not of enough significance to result in somebody doxxing you or identifying you. There are most likely thousands of people that share your exact demographic.

If your post gets removed by AutoModerator, don't message us saying that your post doesn't need any information about you. Only message us if you included information in your post but it was still removed. Your question will always be best answered if you include as many details about yourself as possible.

Thank you and we hope to continue to see more great questions trickle in!

Muscleups and the Mod team

Posted Feb 22, 2018, 4:58 AM UTC · edited

9527
l-Agonist-lNursing Graduate, RPN•

Thank you.

5
gothicapples•

I’m guilty of this but I promise I will be better

4
LinuxthekidArmy Healthcare Specialist•

thank you

4
chuby007Physician•

can you add weight and height so we can get a BMI... thanks !

3
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

sure

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
chankeypathakThis user has not yet been verified.•

Are NSFW pics allowed?

2
theGreatBrainiacThis user has not yet been verified.•

yes

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
jmglee87threeThis user has not yet been verified.•

Great post, thank you.

2
zeuoos•

Good to know. Very informative!

2
Doc_TobiasPhysician•

Glad this was addressed

2
sankdafidePhysician•

Amen amen amen

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
HojoExperiment•

Can we include these rules on the right sidebar to increase visibility?

2
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

The rules are already displayed to everyone in the textbox they write their post in (right where they type). Which is the most visible place possible.

2
MitchRNNursing Student•

What about science and learning related questions. Like “if when myocardial tissue dies it’s replaced by non contractile tissue, then how does cardio exercise make the heart stronger, considering muscle gets stronger through tearing and repairing?”

Are these types of questions not welcome?

If they are allowed, I guess one would just have to invent fake numbers so the automod doesn’t remove.

1
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

Are these types of questions not welcome?

Perhaps "Not welcome" is a bit of a negative term. Although we welcome all participation, I would call these types of questions simply "not the right kind" for this sub. This sub is designed for clinical, symptom-based questions. Since we get a large volume of those every hour , 24/7, to dilute these questions with academic-type curiosity questions would make the sub difficult to browse, contribute to, and moderate.

There are hundreds of subs I can think of that love science and learning related questions like the ones you mentioned. r/science, r/medicine, r/medicalschool, r/anatomy I could go on....

3
Taskuhecate•

I've been trying to find a sub where I can ask a medical question, but it's research for a fictional story. r/medicine is very strict, no ask type questions by laypeople... Any suggestions?

1
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

we are also pretty strict. that kind of question is not allowed. try r/askdoctorsmeeee

1
LemonBomb•

Could you tell me what would be an appropriate sub to ask about doctor's office procedures/being prescribed the wrong drug type questions? I don't have anyone to ask about whether my experience with my doctor/doctor's office is normal and whether I should switch doctors. Sorry if this is the wrong place and thank you for your time.

1
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

this is an appropriate sub for this kind of question. Feel free to make a new post and give us a few details to work with

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

I guess one would just have to invent fake numbers so the automod doesn’t remove.

Oh trust me....I do more removing than automod most days through manual review ;) so that won't work

2
MitchRNNursing Student•

Good to see we have an active moderator again. Mod messages werent getting answered for nearly a year before you came by. Thanks. Just curious, what age range are you? I feel like new doctors would be more likely to discuss things on, or even know about the existance of reddit but then I could be totally wrong.

3
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

you'd be correct. And thanks

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
PollyObscurumThis user has not yet been verified.•

Do people have to write the same details (age, height, weight, gender, medications, smoking status, and the other necessary demographic details) in every post, or only in the first post in this subreddit? Because I wrote those details in my first post in this subreddit.

1

Not to mention we aren’t necessarily going to remember you from one post to the next.

7
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

Just this very one time ;)

2
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

Every post. Your age changes over time, some people even change genders! More importantly, things like medications, doses, and weight can change significantly even in the span of a few days.

3
hellogawgous•

New to Reddit. How do I make a post with an image and text?

1
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

link from imgur.com

1
hellogawgous•

Thanks

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
kittens_mittens93•

Would this subreddit be appropriate to ask if there are any risks to receiving a tetanus vaccine twice in one month because of confusion on immunization records?

1
muscleupsOPSurgeon | Moderator•

Yes but you should provide the info above (age, meds, weight,, etc) if you dont want it to be removed

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1