[help] our dogs have started fighting now that our younger dog is an adult
long post ahead! nacho (pitbull mix, 1.3 years) and his brother taco (lab mix, 6.5 years) have been getting into scuffles lately. sadly, I just got back from the vet because of a scuffle they had this afternoon. we believe that taco has been having a hard time with nacho becoming an adult and getting bigger (10lb more than taco). now that taco is getting older and nacho is getting stronger, it seems like their hierarchy is getting disturbed.
the good news is that since nacho and I got home from the vet, they've both been extremely calm and have literally been licking each others' wounds.
recall and "leave it" fall on deaf ears during these fights. I have also tried making very loud sounds and even spraying the hose at them to snap them out of it, but they stay very focused on the fight. I know that dogs communicate with one another and sort these things out better than we do, so I only try to step in once I can see it's getting very serious. at this point, we physically have to pull them apart (pulling the dogs from the hind legs, avoiding their mouths).
ideally, I want to prevent these situations from even starting. however, we are having a hard time identifying exactly what is triggering these aggressive fights. they still play together often, but we don't know why sometimes the play escalates into a fight.
we went through this article, and I think the most applicable point is that taco now feels challenged by nacho's adulthood: "One scenario that can result in social aggression is when an older, previously bold, confident, and assertive dog, is challenged by a younger, more ambitious dog. This may happen as the older dog ages, or as the younger dog reaches behavioral maturity at 12 to 36 months. This may be an attempt to alter the existing hierarchy." https://vcahospitals.com/know-your-pet/dog-behavior-problems-aggression-sibling-rivalry-diagnosis
- today's scuffle started during playtime with a buddy they've been hanging out with weekly for the past nine months. taco and nacho were playing together and things just seemed to escalate until it got too far. their buddy stayed out of it. nacho had to visit the vet :(
- one night, the boys were playing with their respective toys. nacho got a little too close to taco (as he has done before), and taco told nacho to back off. since it was never really an issue for nacho to be close by, nacho didn't move. this set off taco and it resulted in a fight. because of this, we have avoided giving high-value resources unless directly monitored.
- another night, nacho started poking at taco (i.e. "play! play!"). taco was not in the mood and he told nacho to back off. when nacho was smaller, it was never too much of an issue when he was annoying. this time, it seemed to really bother taco and it also resulted in a fight.
- we avoid punishing either dog after a fight occurs.
- we have not gone through any major changes in household.
- we do not currently crate, but I think it would be best to start crating immediately. do you recommend both dogs to be crated, or to crate one and not the other?
more about taco:
-
we rescued taco when he was 4yo. he came into our family with a very quiet, but also very dominant personality (very territorial, lots of mounting). he used to do a lot of resource guarding and would also bully others for their toys or food. we've been able to guide him to socialize more politely.
-
taco is also a very anxious dog. he came to us with severe separation anxiety and still gets set off from certain triggers. we avoid coddling him when he is triggered and have done a lot of work on desensitization. he has improved greatly, but his anxiety can still come back depending on how significant the trigger is.
-
we went through training with taco and he is quite obedient, but we were not satisfied with the methods of the service we used. we much prefer methods that focus on positive reinforcement
thanks for taking the time to read - any advice you might have will be greatly appreciated!
Posted Mar 1, 2018, 6:14 AM UTC
This will be quick as I'm going to work but when you leave don't leave toys or high value items around. I wouldn't be crating at this point honestly.
It sounds like this can be managed in house by yourselves; you've always been present and could have interjected before a fight escalated. This needs you as owners to step in and separate when either dog shows that they are not comfortable. Playing too rough? Call one away or separate before it gets out of hand. One dog growls because it's not comfortable with the other in their space at that time? Call one away and separate before it gets out of hand. I've managed a major fight in my household over resources, it hasn't occured again with easy management tips.
Also get their bloods checked at the vets to test thyroid levels etc., it could be one is not well and therefore more likely to behave aggressively.
The more slip ups that happen without you stopping before things escalate the more likely things will be serious in the future and the outcomes less positive; nip it in the bud early and you have the best chance of success. Luckily they're both males, the prognosis is often worse if it's two females that begin to fight. Your Pibble mix is likely to be bolshy and is now an adolescent so going to push his luck, it's up to you to show him what is and isn't appropriate and as he grows older and he begins to calm (lol, pibble calming) he will learn to back off. At this point in his life he's pushing boundaries, don't let him.
Thank you for taking the time to respond! We do not leave high-value resources laying around the house :)
Yes, your points make sense. However, signals that the dogs gave to each other in the past just seem to be randomly ignored now. I guess the tricky part for me is understanding why sometimes the dogs agree to back off and why other times, it results in a fight.
I think you are suggesting that moving forward, I should simply not leave it to chance. I think I had stepped back from intervening because I really felt like after living together for more than a year, they knew how to communicate with one another - especially because this was never an issue in the past. But you are right! Now that nacho is matured, he is definitely pushing his luck. I will help him understand the boundaries.
Also, (for example) if my older one growls, does it make more sense to call over my younger one or older one?
Thank you again for your advice!
The difference now is your younger dog has lost his puppy license and your older dog is now being less tolerant about behaviours which are given leniency in puppyhood. The problem with bullies (I have a large bully mix at the moment) is that they will often push and push and push and when another dog says back off they will be tenacious about carrying on and ignore signals which can cause aggression to take place. My own dog wants everything her own way play wise and the second another dog growls or gives a warning they have had enough she snaps and attacks, some of it is nature and respecting that hence play is very limited for her and I step in whenever she is getting close to over excited or not respecting another dog and being unsociable.
The younger one. The dog growling is trying to communicate effectively, likely they have given more subtle hints that a dog with good social skills would understand and have already backed off. If the dog has had to resort to growling the other dog should immediately give calming signals and back off. Again, with bullies they are tenacious and some do not heed warnings and push their luck instead. The only reason my bully now respects my (much larger) male dog is because he snapped back once and she got wounded in the ensuing fight; now she's learned she's not the one who can push him around constantly.
The quicker you step in, the quicker your dog will come to realise what the correct step is to take. Some old school people would advocate 'leave them to sort it out between themselves' or other such nonsense, better to prevent than have to react to a much worse scenario. As your younger dog matures, with your guidance I would imagine that with good management things will settle down once more and you'll have a peaceful home. As I said initially though the more something happens the worse the outcome so good management to see him through adolescence and all should be well. :)