chicagojoewalcottSanda, MMA, Boxing•

Hey, that's the author of one of my main sources for Historic American Folkstyle.

This is from the New York Athletic Club, the head coach is Hugh Leonard, the guy in the white tights.

William "Billy" Muldoon was a wrestler who had a long and varied career, including as a strength and conditioning coach and, notably, the head of the New York Athletic Comission. Muldoon, during the lat 1880's, worked as a trainer for John L. Sullivan in preparation for his bareknuckle boxing match against Kilrain. The best part of this camp took place in Belfast, New York which is where Muldoon is said to have first met Hugh Leonard.

Leonard, among other local children, would loiter around the Sullivan camp during their free time; some of them, Leonard included, would end up doing odd jobs as was more common during the 19th Century.

Leonard's wrestling career began at 16, when Muldoon began "promoting" challenge matches for purses of up to $100. He would enter the pro-wrestling circuit of the time and develop a solid record; ultimately though, he would enter coaching at a young age.

His first recorded coaching position was at the Buffalo Athletic Club (New York) in 1893. By the next year he would be appointed coach at the Manhattan Athletic Club, and ultimately to the, still standing, New York Athletic Club. He would remain coach at the NYAC until his death.

The NYAC (athletic club not athletic commission) had published rules for Collar-and-Elbow dating back at least to 1870 and probably before, but Hugh Leonard is the first recorded Catch-as-Catch-Can/Folkstyle/Freestyle (American Folkstyle was not a term often used until much later) coach at the NYAC.

His program was, from the numbers reported by the Club itself, extremely popular, accumulating hundreds of students at its peak. It was also competitively successful, though single matches during this period are difficult to reliably source, the NYAC was well represented among AAU Catch-as-Catch-Can champions in multiple weight classes (the championship in question existed from 1888 until 1921).

14
chicagojoewalcottSanda, MMA, Boxing•

Self-Reply to divide up this wall of text

This position was, apparently, quite stressful, as Leonard had to go on sabbatical after experiencing a sharp downturn in his health that was characterized by a rapid loss of weight, down to 140 lbs. This was attributed to overwork. After his recovery the wrestling program would no longer be year round, one of the first instances of wrestling as a formally seasonal sport.

Frank Herrick, an assistant coach, would step down from his position due to overwork as well. Herrick would go on to coach at Brown until 1932 and also worked as a physique model. The arm on the Arm-and-Hammer logo is actually his. According to the Encylopedia Brunonia a Harvard physician said that Herrick had the best physique of 10,000 men. This highlights the apparent rigours of coaching at the NYAC, as assistant coaching duties were described as "...too much of a strain on his constitution" in the NYAC's monthly newsletter.

In 1897, Hugh Leonard published his Handbook of Wrestling which would become something of a standard in the field and was the most popular such book of its time. According to Grehndal's I rose Like a Rocket President Theodore Roosevelt personally wrote to Leonard with praise about the book . If I had to identify any single book as my primary focus, it would the Handbook.

Leonard would also notably be featured in a Cosmopolitan article along with K. Higashi, a Judo ambassador. Leonard had previously commented that he had not seen anything in JuJitsu "not known to western wrestling," Higashi was meant to challenge that claim. Though Leonard conceded that he was un-familiar with the Juji-Gatame type armlock, Higashi ultimately said that he could not show his "serious tricks" presumably because they were secret.

Leonard and his assistant coaches, Herrick as previously mentioned, and the notable George Bothner, would form the first generation of collegiate wrestling coaches. Leonard coached at Columbia among others. Bothner would coach at Princeton whereat he defeated the previously mentioned Higashi in a challenge match.

Hugh Leonard would hold his position as wrestling coach at the NYAC until his death by lightning strike in 1914 while overseeing a training camp. The NYAC continues to have a wrestling program to this day.

Miscellaneous Facts

  • Hugh Leonard didn't believe in breakfast or lunch. Instead, he consumed five "hard crackers" and a quart of milk every three hours.

  • He only ate chicken and vegetables for dinner.

  • He didn't smoke, drink, or chew tobacco. (In contrast to his early influences Sullivan and Muldoon).

  • He either slept from nine-to-eight or from 12-to-ten depending on when he had to get up; he believed that at least 10 hours of sleep was necessary.

  • He was sometimes known as "Hughey" in the gym.

  • He was responsible for the first, as far as I can find, time limits in American folkstyle competition; if this was exceeded there would be another bout, if the limit of that bout was reached the referee would determine the winner based on activity.

  • He would have four daughters with his wife, Rose; Rose would die a little less than ten years after her husband, leaving their youngest daughter, Marjorie, in the care of the eldest three children.

  • His daughter, Marjorie (mentioned above), would marry William J. Brennan Jr. who would serve on the Supreme court from 1956 until 1990; one of their children would be named Hugh.

An image of Leonard with his team

12
ColonelKickOP•

Top tier comment. We need to give you like some special sub flair for going above and beyond the call of duty

u/TopTomCat Can we start giving out "Redditor of the month" awards for people that make quality comments like this?

5
chicagojoewalcottSanda, MMA, Boxing•

Aw, shucks.

Honestly this isn't exactly a topic that comes up in conversation, so having an opportunity to deploy my wall of text is nice.

5
ColonelKickOP•

Well, I appreciate it. I learned some neat history.

What are your reading sources for this kind of stuff? Anything to recommend?

2
Toptomcat•

After the failure of the Technique of the Month expiriment, I'm not sure enough people would participate to make it worthwhile. Still, make a post about it and I'll implement it if enough people seem excited about it.

3
ColonelKickOP•

Alright. I'll make a post and see how it goes. Should I slap a "Meta" tag on it?

1
eheisse87Judo TKD Muay Thai•

The NYAC (athletic club not athletic commission) had published rules for Collar-and-Elbow dating back at least to 1870 and probably before,

As a judoka, it was interesting when I learned about this style that seems so similar (even more similar to shuai jiao-chinese wrestling) and that it used to be so popular in America. Apparently, George Washington was a collar-and-elbow wrestler! Could be a big reason Japanese judokas didn't have as much success in challenge matches in America as they did in Europe. Do you have any idea why this style completely died out?

1
chicagojoewalcottSanda, MMA, Boxing•

Sorry it took a while to get to this.

Anyway, I wouldn't necessarily say that it's dead; it's essentially dead in the Americas but there are other branches of the Celtic jacket wrestling family that are still very much alive. For example Gouren in Brittany and Cornwall/Devon Wrestling in England.

I would attribute its loss of popularity in America to a move away from "artificiality" or things that were viewed as gimmicks. Greco-Roman (such as it was at the time), collar-and-elbow, side-hold, Cumberland/backhold, and Catch existed pretty much simultaneously at one point. With this came specialists or exponents in all of these styles. High-profile wrestling matches, as a consequence were often "mixed matches" for fairness. Ultimately, standardizing Catch became pretty common because it allowed pretty much everything from the other styles and was therefore the best middle-ground.

There was also a significant move towards "natural" athletics or viewing the value of a sport based on how close it was to the basic state of man as it was viewed. Catch was seen as the closest as it had the fewest rules and required no special garments.

1