r/rpg•
midgardmc

Tips and experiences running Hot Springs Island?

Hey fellow GMs,

I will run HSI friday to Sunday the first weekend of April and as it has been out I while I was interested in the experiences you had with it.

I have read and prepared the "Dark of HSI" and the Field Guide. I printed that one out for my players.

The map is in Din A3, so pretty large.

I found links to an DnD 5e and an OSR bestiary here on reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/dndnext/comments/7hfjz8/i_created_5e_stats_for_all_of_the_monsters_in_the/

I also read about Zak Sabbath running it in his houseruled DnD 5e version. here is his system: https://www.reddit.com/r/rpg/comments/6o68zz/best_system_for_maze_of_the_blue_medusa/dkf84b3/ I will run it using Swords and Wizadry.

I have found many reviews, but I have found little else from people who have actually run it.

So any tips? Regarding starting location? (System used?) Problems encountered?

Would be glad for any help!

Thank you!

Update:Links from the thread/helpful resources:

an automated dice/encounter roller for all the dungeons/areas/... can be found here: https://chartopia.d12dev.com/en/collection/14/

Tips from the creator for starting a campaign: http://www.swordfishislands.com/2017/11/not-sure-how-to-begin-campaign.html

a list of resources collected by the creator of HSI: https://plus.google.com/u/0/+JacobHurst/posts/VM61Ep1PQjf

Many thanks to MilkyLeanDonnor for his awesome writeup below, please read it if you want to run HSI. I found it very helpful!

Posted Mar 7, 2018, 5:19 PM UTC · edited

5636
MilkyLeanDonnor•

I'm 4 sessions in, playing with Shadow of the Demon Lord (I would have preferred an OSR system but my players love character building with plenty of options, and SotDL was a good middle ground).

I had them start in Swordfish Bay (RR-02 on Rand's Retreat, the island south of Hot Springs Island). They signed a contract with Rand's guild : the guild brings them here, provides them with a roof to sleep under, and let them keep 30% of everything they bring back from their expeditions. The contract lasts 1 year or until they have paid 10,000 GP in taxes to the guild.

Zilbee set them up in a shack, loaned them a few bucks to buy equipment, and booked them a trip to HSI on a fisherman's boat for the next day. They met Matthias, who offered to pay them for any detailed report on the flora and fauna found on HSI (this quest is only interesting because I didn't give them the Guide to begin with: since most of my players struggle with English, that would have been a pain for everyone).

I gave them the unkeyed HSI map and they decided to disembark in Crab Mouth Lagon (HS-14-01). They started exploring and writing lengthy reports on the plants and animals. They took part in a sumo wrestling competition between fire imps in front of the Lapis Observatory (HS-15-02) before delving inside.

We are now in the middle of their second expedition: they were promised a big bonus if they were to bring back the lost party of Geoffrey Splitheart. We ended the fourth session with them getting chummy with Svarku and the fuegonauts, eagerly awaiting the New Moon Party.

There has been only two PC death so far.

18
midgardmcOP•

Thank you for your long and helpful answer. I like how you used the guild and the map to set it up and the tasks they got seem really well-suited.

How did running the Lapis Observatory go for you? I'm a bit afraid of all the dice-rolling for every room/encounter/... and getting a good dungeon going.

It is a cool idea to have them looking for the lost expedition! I will probably use that as well!

Thank you!

5
MilkyLeanDonnor•

Rolling every encounter is a chore, I use an automated roller: https://chartopia.d12dev.com/en/collection/14/ .

I give myself a lot of room for interpretation on the rolled encounters, and if I can think of something more interesting, I use that instead. I would advise you to read up on he NPC adventurers, to be ready to use them whenever they pop up on a roll, they make for great interactions.

Running the Observatory was especially interesting because one of the PC was an ancient golem that had worked at the Hotel Lapis a thousand years ago. I had given him an approximate map of the first few floors, and having him try to match that knowledge with the ruins they were exploring was a nice gameplay moment. In particular, this allowed the group to find the secret passage near the entrance.

So, first thing first, they had a hard time climbing up to the Observatory, which I was calling the Blue Tower to avoid giving away its true purpose (well, that was the idea, I slipped anyway). On top of the outcropping, they met a fire imp prepping the area for a tournament that evening. They learned a bit about elementals, then entered the building and got tangled in an astral spider web. The spiders themselves dealt no damage, but could ensnare a limb on a successful attack, or call for support by sending vibrations up the web. Fortunately, the only two PC that became completely entangled and sent to the astral were not made of flesh (a golem and an automaton), so the host was not able to feed on them. A PC asked the fire imp outside for help and, seeing that the fight was imbalanced due to the sheer amount of spiders, this one stepped in and burnt everything, saving the group. The two prisoners came back from the astral by following the silver threads.

The imp was lamenting his intervention in a fight that was not his own and offered front rows to the sumo tournament as an apology. The group met more fire imps, some betting steam imps, as well as a combustarino and two salamanders, who got thrown out of the tournament after cheating in a match. A PC took part in a few matches in order to win a bet with a steam imp, who lost and had to follow with them into the Observatory.

Delving inside once again, they assaulted some orange sludges, then freed the Nereid from the painting at the reception. She was thankful and offered to help them next time they came by the sea. She left to find her sisters.

The golem PC remembered about the secret passage near the entrance, and the group went down to the basement. Their steam imp friend got rid of the silver webs down there for them, then left, having met his end of the bargain. They found some treasure, a pair of Sensitivity Gloves, and Vinlay’s Catalogue. They met the Herald, did not remove his shorts, and accidentally woke up all the other golems, who decided to start cleaning the tower. Some golems were possessed by orange sludges, so the group elected to promptly leave the basement.

They fought a Muttering Serpent in the gift shop, then found some drug paraphernalia, a few gold coins and a Codpiece of Sustenance that nobody dared to wear.

On the first floor, they encountered Wild Eye (NPC adventurer) in the restaurant, screaming at the Crystal Column. The Herald was necessary to translate what she was saying, and he ended up insulting her, so she left angrily. While investigating the column, the adventurers got their clothes replaced by skimpy costumes (the obtained magic loincloth could protect as well as an armor, it was in the end quite an interesting item to have). They found the secret kitchen, fought a chef-sludge inside, that rusted most of their weapons to uselessness. They freed the water imp, who felt thankful and accepted to help them.

The second floor was more challenging to run, with the 12 rooms to improvise. I took a lot of notes to remember to put tie-ins to those rooms in Hot Springs City. If you don't feel confident about improvising everything, don't hesitate to prepare a few in advance. The group found 6 gold statues in a room that seemed to be some king of dance floor. They could not carry them out, but had the water imp use a focused water stream to cut a golden toe.

The next floor is a pain to describe because all the complex scenery is visible from the get-go I added two chimes near the pods, that could open the vivarium and raise the statue. The PC took a gold leaf on the aspens, but felt remorse when the tree started to bleed, and couldn't bring themselves to pick any more. Moving between the roots proved quite challenging, and most of the mysteries of this room were left unsolved. The group managed to save an unconscious pod person, and then set the salt vine ablaze to see what would happen. The closed level quickly became a blazing inferno, which only worsened when the ember coral started squirting scalding magma left and right. The adventurers quickly jumped through the portal to the last floor.

There, they managed to activate the planetarium, but did not take the time to discover all its secrets, as the floor was getting hotter by the minute. They rappelled down the outer wall to the first floor's balcony, started fighting orange sludges left and right, ended up against an alabaster guardian that killed a PC and maimed two others before being tricked into going through the portal to the second floor.

The group quickly left the observatory to catch their boat back home, but met a rampaging giant boar on the beach, and were forced to retreat to the jungle to spend the night… where they faced a second giant boar, wounded this time. They hid as well as they could, but the smell of their fallen comrade's blood brought some vyderacs during the night and they had to dispose of the body.

So, as far as advices go: roll the whole dungeon at once, to know what is happening and what encounters could interact, ignore he results you don't like. Read up on the elven treasures and NPC adventurers to be ready to use them. Think a bit about the metaphysics of your world to know what to describe in the planetarium (AD&D's Manual of Planes is a good start). Estimate the strength each monster should have, keeping in mind that making frequent encounters like orange sludges or boltforagers a bit too strong can make the whole dungeon way more lethal than intended, sprinkle to taste.

9
midgardmcOP•

Ok, WOW! Thank you so much for taking so much time to answer my questions! This is an amazing help and awesome to read in itself. Thank you for all the tips! I have read your text four times by now :D it is really really helpful and just makes me even more excited to run the island! THANK YOU!

3
MilkyLeanDonnor•

Here are a few other resources I made for my game that you might find useful :

Other than that, don't hesitate to dig into Jacob's blog, it contains numerous useful design notes: http://www.swordfishislands.com/ . In particular, check out the Swordfish Bay relationship board, the annotated Swordfish Islands map and the bath house's plans.

7
pandesmosSwordfish Islands•

way more lethal than intended

^ this is impossible. This is also one of the most amazing things I've ever read. Thanks for running my game. It sounds like it was phenomenal.

2
J00ls•

Great post. How did you portray the elementals? I find them a bit weird and inhuman and how did the players learn about them?

2
MilkyLeanDonnor•

They leaned about elementals when they met them.

The first was a water elemental fighting a golem that was trying to fill its pond with rubbles. They tried to reason with it, and the elemental got so annoyed with the chitchat that it simply left to do other things.

Pure elementals are generally less interesting to use than imps, maybe with the exception of steam elementals. I rolled them as a random encounter last Sunday, at the bottom of the steam falls. The appearance of those "fog angels" in the middle of the night doing strange rituals left a lasting impression on the players.

Another memorable elemental encounter was with an ooze elemental in the blasted tower, it agreed to share its knowledge with the PCs if they helped it produce more mud. They redirected a small stream to flood the surroundings, and the elemental told them about the magic responsible for the tower's destruction.

Imps, on the other hand, are really fun and handy to use. They each have simple minds and traits. I play them all as friendly unless angered. They make nice NPCs to encounter every now and then.

2
valzi•

Thanks for all of that.

Where /when do you convert treasure to xp?

1
MilkyLeanDonnor•

When they come back to Swordfish Bay and sell the treasure to Rand's guild. The adventurers get a week off between expeditions to level up, carouse and work on lengthy projects like identifying magic items or learning a new language.

1
ludifexQuesting Beast, Maze Rats, Phoenix AZ•

Here's an app that automatically does all the rolling for you. https://chartopia.d12dev.com/en/collection/14/

8
midgardmcOP•

Thank you!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Jalor218•

I'm 4 sessions in, playing with Shadow of the Demon Lord (I would have preferred an OSR system but my players love character building with plenty of options, and SotDL was a good middle ground).

SotDL is like the secret formula to get Pathfinder people to play OSR style games. There are tons of character options but none of them give abilities that invalidate old-school challenges (or no more than what spellcasters in B/X could do), and there's no "search" or "insight" skill that bypasses interacting with NPCs or environments.

3
kenku_sommelier•

This helped me understand what I am looking at when I open this book.

3
badash56•

I am interested in using SOTDL for this as well, how has it gone so far? Did you run it rules as written or make any changes? Tough converting monsters?

2
MilkyLeanDonnor•

The main issue I've run into so far is that the pace of the adventures on the island is too frantic to leave time for the players to level up. Levelling up mid-adventure feels weird because the PCs suddenly gain mastery of new abilities and languages without having taken the time to learn them. SotDL seems to be designed for long breaks between expeditions, which is not really compatible with the explosive situation on HSI.

I play mostly by the book. I added some carousing rules for time-off when they get back to swordfish bay. I don't use grid combat, my players and I prefer theatre of the mind, with the help of a hastily drawn plan when things get too confusing.

Monsters are not especially tough to convert, but the process of doing so is a bit longer than what I'm used to with simpler games. I do it on the fly while the players are thinking about their battle strategy. I used the horned ogre stats for the Albinos Ogre in the slave quarters, it ended up being a bit much for the three level 2 PCs, but it made for a great scene of rescuing fallen comrades.

1
pandesmosSwordfish Islands•

Sooooooooo cool!

1
Gourgeistguy•

It's one of the best sandboxes I've ever laid my hands in, it can be run with prettty much ANY system you can imagine. It is an indispensable supplement in any Game Master library and I really, really hope the creator keeps blessing us with more sandboxes like this.

In fact this is the best organized sandbox I've seen in my entire GMing career and anyone could learn from the way he deals with exploration time, random encounters and organic world building without cracking people's heads open.

5
midgardmcOP•

Have you run it or just read it?

2
Gourgeistguy•

Both. It's a dream to run and read. You rarely need to cross reference stuff like many other Sandbox games make you do.

2
pandesmosSwordfish Islands•

Creator here.... thank you everyone! This is so awesome to read.

Here's the way I personally like to start it (with a shipwreck and some blackbagging: http://www.swordfishislands.com/2017/11/not-sure-how-to-begin-campaign.html), but of course there's no right way to do it.

I've got an (incomplete) list of resources related to Hot Springs Island over on G+ (https://plus.google.com/u/0/+JacobHurst/posts/VM61Ep1PQjf).

My co-creators tend to start the game differently every time, and yet also the same: Usually with a fetch quest. The fetch quest is pretty insignifigant, but it leads to exploration which generates the "game". We've started with shipwrecks, Martel company boats anchored off the shore, and even a couple airship and airship crashes. The island is leaky with extraplanar portals, so there's plenty of routes in from the real far away elsewheres. Old elven magic is always available as an excuse for pulling players in, and if you really want to push the envelope you could use the steam imps.

Steam Imps have taken notice of these adventurers, so they pulled them over for their own amusement and to facilitate many many bets.

5
midgardmcOP•

Thank you for chiming in! The idea with the fetch quest is a really good one! I will probably shipwreck them, but we will see ...

1
LaramieWallHackmaster•

Wait! You have a G+ community? (Joins)

1
valzi•

Use this instead of rolling dice to generate encounters: https://chartopia.d12dev.com/en/collection/14/

Go through and roll several encounters for each hex type. Then copy and paste them to a document and print it out. Do the same for any dungeon you're currently running. Now you have an idea of what's coming up AND don't need to roll dice. You can plan things out now if you like, though you don't need to.

4
midgardmcOP•

Thank you! This is also very, very helpful!

1
LaramieWallHackmaster•

Sorry man, I'm planning on this being my next campaign, and while I've bought it, have barely cracked the covers. I'll be running it in HackMaster.

3
midgardmcOP•

I found it looked really easy to prepare, but somehow I now find the idea of running it a bit daunting. We will see how it goes. It is a good group and I know most people for 20+ years, so no worries, but a bit anxious. I have never met anyone playing Hackmaster. Do you feel it that is especially suited or is it your "go-to" system and you use most of time anyway.

3
LaramieWallHackmaster•

Go to system. As I mentioned, I have barely cracked the books, I just really like the system (non-round based combat, lower magic [not low magic, just that people aren't tripping on +2 daggers], active defense, etc).

1
midgardmcOP•

I will give Hackmaster a look sooner or later. We played with active defense systems for years, but are now really happy about what at least feels like faster combat. Non-round based combat sounds very interesting, even if I do not run it I will read up on it

2
LaramieWallHackmaster•

HackMaster, for all my love of it, is NOT a fast combat system. Non-round is a pretty simple concept, as you can imagine. The HM system of it- every action has a speed, the whole system is just simply "seconds". It takes 10 seconds to attack with a long sword (not to swing one, just to get a good swing that's not a parry, or feight, etc). It takes a few seconds to cast a spell. And if you change your mind, you can stop and change actions, you aren't locked in ("Well, I'm 2 seconds into this attack, and the orc I was bashing just fell over. Next target!").

1
derkriegerI GM a lot•

Also havent had a chance to run it but I am envious and wish to know how your groups escapades go.

3
midgardmcOP•

Thank you! I will get back to you!

3
CriminalDM•

My books just arrived. They look amazing. The production value is beyond my initial expectations and the flora and fauna section has captured my attention.

I want to find a way to railroad my campaign to the island.

3
midgardmcOP•

I totally understand you! I also enjoyed just reading through a lot!

2
valzi•

I don't have much here yet, but I'm collecting things: https://plus.google.com/collection/MAg-XE

1
midgardmcOP•

Awesome! Thank you!

1
Illumi__Zoldyck•

Hi guys,

I just got the books yesterday (to Sweden) after a long wait. And WOW. They are far beyond my expectations. I will sleep with these books in my arms.

I can't even tell you how hyped I am to get started. I think I will use 5e rules with XP for money and possibly some variants of exhaustion and encumbrance.

Anyway! I did this (in my opinion) slightly more flavorful map to hand out to my PCs, and thought I'd share it with you: https://imgur.com/a/DsMZtzZ

Again, thanks a lot Jacob & Co for making this superb hex. I am impressed and delighted.

1
Illumi__Zoldyck•

Hi guys, I deleted my old comment. But, I still have some questions and thoughts! :)

So, I finally got the books to Europe after a long wait... And WOW! They are far beyond my expectations. I most definitely recommend getting the hard copies. I will sleep with these books in my arms <3

I can't even tell you how hyped I am to get started though it will be my first time DM:ing (wish me luck)..

I think I will use 5e rules, but with "XP for Money" to make players understand they don't have to try and slaughter everything they see, and give them a reason to occacionally rendevouz with the Martel Company for leveling up. I may also employ some variants of exhaustion or encumbrance to make it feel a bit like a island survival game. Have anyone else tried that? Maybe it is more annoying than fun?

Moreover! I modified the island map (gave it a worn look) to hand it out to my PCs, and thought I'd share it here with you: https://imgur.com/a/DsMZtzZ

Does anyone have an idea of what parts of the field guide to make print copies of to hand out? I will give them the whole book eventually, but my players and I are not fond of spoilers so I don't want them to know about all factions and creatures before they encounter them or hear NPCs talk about them. How has other people handled this? Should I just give them the guide right off the bat anyway?

Again, many thanks to Jacob & Co for creating this superb setting. I am as impressed and as delighted!

1