r/osugame•
Xinnoh

A huge pp nerf is incoming for short maps

News

tldr of the proposal


If a map has fewer than 500 objects, there is a harsher penalty for pp

The percentage change decreases at 250, 500, and 2000 objects.

Maps that have over 500 objects are unchanged with the current plan


Here's a chart of some specific values for what is changing

Note: It will not be implemented in the next few days, give it a few weeks. It may or may not be implemented at all.

https://github.com/ppy/osu-performance/pull/14#issuecomment-371431338

Posted Mar 8, 2018, 10:14 AM UTC · edited

707289
gdq0•

Can we abandon piece wise functions and adapt appropriate logarithmic or best fit functions instead?

494
Wieran•

the words here sound good so ill upvote

277
nanobuilderhttp://osu.ppy.sh/u/426638•

basically "stop setting arbitrary limits and use a formula with smooth output"

like if all maps with <500 objects get nerfed then u just make ur map 501 objects and it doesnt get nerfed. that's not ideal since there's no in-between

148
sentimentalmicrowavehttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/9646988•

I thought piece wise functions meant functions that have discontinuities (i.e. pauses in a graph... like x<5 && x>7 [wherein  x=ℝ≠5,6,7]).

...what is school anymore?

9
nanobuilderhttp://osu.ppy.sh/u/426638•

they don't necessarily have to have discontinuities, they just need to have different equations for different parts of the domain

so in the case of this pp change, a nerfed formula is used when objects < 500, and the original formula is used when objects >= 500 (disclaimer: i didnt look at the changelog)

37
GobbyBoss•

Yeah, but it looks like this instead. ______--------''''''""""""""""

5
Transflux•

Piecewise functions often have discontinuities, but not (necessarily?) places where it's not defined like that.

y = { 5x; x <= 2
    { 7x; x > 2

There's a discontinuity at x=2 because what the function approaches from the left side (and the actual value) is y=10 but from the right side it approaches y=14

5
-transcendent-•

It doesn't need to be discontinuous. It will have different derivatives.

3
Potla1995Potla•

I don't like the terminology of "piecewise functions", cause a function is just a map from a domain (in this case it could be a proper subset of R) to R. More appropriate is "piecewise continuous functions", which is what you're familiar with. A continuous function is by definition piecewise continuous (with just one piece). :)

1
Forgetmepls•

Well it's 3 linear functions with differing gradients.

1
crvcx86•

I think we should be using Krylov-subspace based methods instead. GMRES has excellent performance.

1
pepppppypeppy•

it really doesn't change much. the piece-wise functions are still linear and create a roughly logarithmic curve (but being better tailored to not approach extremes).

43
Duderm3n•

I don't understand how a piecewise could me more tailored to extremes than a logarithmic curve (not to be imflammatory, genuinely curious)

6
pepppppypeppy•

sometimes you actually want a linear drop-off?

23
Duderm3n•

but why? Maybe for testing but I don't see why you wouldn't try to later find a best fit curve to the piece wise? I guess I'm having trouble finding a purpose other than balancing, which you can just keep the piecewise as an early model then shift to a more appropriate curve once the numbers settle. At this point all this system does is encourage 251 and 501 object maps.

7
gdq0•

So if the piece wise function has no break (as peppy is suggesting) it can create a decent approximation.

1-15 = 9*x + 31

16-30 = 18*x - 104

31-45 = 36*x - 374

46-60 = 36*x - 779

60 = 45*x - 1319

A function like this with properly corrected y intercepts will approach the previous and next function.

1
c2cgosu•

then make more steps. should not be too bad to make 10-20 steps instead of 3

2
pepppppypeppy•

unnecessary IMO. if we notice issues during testing we will consider it.

10
DdeathK•

People will just map maps that are 1 object over the step, making multiple steps will make it more balanced IMO

3†
ShazWowhttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/RS1•

every combo under 500 -1 pp imo

1
oamleya•

wtf maths

18
dat_swag_doe•

wtf i hate english now

17
Conspo•

Press F to pay respects to Granat and Harumachi Clover

414
hksy46•

good riddance

130
gollum8it•

501 note version coming soon yes?

78
solonggaybowsah•

All songs will now be exactly 501 notes so just more slow parts same amount of pp jumps

51
Lrd_Herobrine•

Those are my top plays rip

Edit: /s jeesh

19
Mayushii_x3https://osu.ppy.sh/u/9058925•

Not impressive at all. Deserved nerf.

EDIT: Joke confirmed. Nevermind me.

6†
Lrd_Herobrine•

It was a joke.

5
xenoniusosu&gt;///&lt;•

cbcc and kibo refrain lol

15
anoymaly2152•

F

9
krotoxx•

dont forget about CCBC. Thank fuck

8
mamizop•

cookie choco butter cookie

11
jsebeanJSE•

Never know. Could be choco cookie butter cookie.

1
robeeelis•

God still exists it seems, and his name is peppy!

1
OnACloud•

HaiTai?!

7
hsephelahttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/4742068•

now sotarks will just make maps with 501 objects

346
Gawley4•

sotarks big brain

73
akylers•

IQ 727 MODE

24
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
wa_o_did_kolain•

WILCHQ TOP 10 CANT WAIT

202
Brimstail•

Can't wait for digidrake rank 5 🤤

22
likesleague•

OSKARRITOS HYPE TRAIN

2
XinnohOPSinnoh•

hey that means pp compilation is worth even more xdxd

184
nansnsKooKyZ•

save me 700pp lol

56
anoymaly2152•

wait what? no one said that long maps will get a bigger boost

63
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
anoymaly2152•

oh god no, now I'll be even MORE overranked :((

12
hsephelahttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/4742068•

that may have just meant that longer maps are worth more in proportion to shorter maps

4
nansnsKooKyZ•

Yes ur right I just realized I got stupid

1
sp1d3rp0130ntwitch.com/mindforrest•

I got the gay

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
m4ttm4ndokidokilolixx•

why fix the pp system when u can just nerf every short map in existence

osu goes 2000iq mode pt.209837927432772394714

98
MTD4207k player•

you seem to be 9000000000 iq yourself, there is no way to "fix" the pp system... mappers will always find a way to abuse it so you cant really find a perfect fix... you can just nerf things that are a bit over-kill and this is exactly what the staff is doing

23
m4ttm4ndokidokilolixx•

when u nerf ALL short maps REGARDLESS for actual difficulty

this isnt a overkill change now???????????????????????????

35
LawL4Everhttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/3556856•

Since the pp system is based on retrying to get the best possible score, short maps have a huge advantage in that regard. Nerfing them is entirely sensible (really just look at bill nye, haitai, cbcc to see how stupid it gets when it's less than tv size. Yes, I know traumatic and other underrrated short maps exist, but being worth nothing or almost nothing doesn't really make a difference, if you care about pp you farm, if you don't you don't give a shit).

25
m4ttm4ndokidokilolixx•

I understand that most ''pp'' maps are mostly short, but firstly keep in mind that long maps can be retarded in terms of pp aswell (4* with 7* jumps)

Secondly, if this nerf creates another bunch of underrated maps, did it really solve the problems with the system? even if there's new problems with it?

Its like cutting your entire arm off because you have a infected finger.

It's good to see peppy start taking action though.

21
Yaahh•

Than the Problem lies in the rules. QAT 's and Nominators should check for what the pp system cant. If they feel that a song is mapped more towards providing pp rather than following the song than just dont rank it.

0
Mayushii_x3https://osu.ppy.sh/u/9058925•

There is a fix. Scorev2

-3
lolisamuraiFranc[e]sco•

while this helps taking the bias off short maps, it doesn't help certain patterns being under/over weighted and there's just as much long pp maps that exploit high object count and diff spikes with easy patterns as there are tv size ones

89
JoleKKBiggest FGSky fan alive•

its a good start

70
SeungHyunLee•

Nah it's really just a useless change

15
KQouyHCFWill Stetson•

Found the granat farmer

68
BeautifulTaeng•

hey das me, no shame in it

18
MEKhahayeah rock on •

great so now pp farmers will have to sit through 2 minutes of 1/2 filler thats 1 star under the end of the map instead of 1

84
SaftigMo•

Not really. The change for most TV sized extra maps will only be 1-3%, or about 2-8 pp or something.

5
runescapeN3rd•

I like the idea but shouldn't it be a gradual change instead of 250 and 500 thresholds? Seems expoitable

39
Kartonrealista•

There is. The post was updated recently

17
Blueishhhuehostile•

They aren't really thresholds like that just steepness of the dropoff. A 240 combo map would still be weighted similar to a 260 combo map.

5
runescapeN3rd•

Yeah I understand that now, at first I thought that making a 501 object map would exploit this system but I understand now that that is obviously not the case

1
number1matrixhater•

i knew the day would come yet i still farmed short shit

25
LG34-Nao•

literally touchscreen 'fix' v2 lol ''yeah let's not bother reworking pp and make stupid counterproductive changes instead''

25
pepppppypeppy•

thanks for your productive contribution of less than nothing.

75
Klockgaming•
18
sneakpeekbot•

Here's a sneak peek of r/peppyRoastedHimGood using the top posts of all time!

#1: Peppy has equal rights | 0 comments
#2: Peppy on paid ban removals | 2 comments
#3: [even at 8 o'clock in the morning he's in roasting mood (x-post r/osugame)](https://i.redd.it/dpuwdi0qolgz.png) | 0 comments


^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^Contact ^^me ^^| ^^Info ^^| ^^Opt-out

3
LG34-Nao•

no problem

11
Noswiper•

Just wanted to say, even with all the hate, whether this is positive or not, thank you for atleast trying something. I don't have an opinion on how this will affect the rankings yet, but I'm glad atleast SOMETHING is done. Thanks peppy :D

1
shavitush•

this is what happens when the only knowledgeable programmer in this topic from the osu team (overlord tom94) isn't as active

9
neverlink_•

this is the same person who fucking added doubletapping into the game

-1†
LawL4Everhttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/3556856•

Except it was always there if you had the right keyboard. The reason he added it to work is because otherwise it was possible on a laptop keyboard but not on a normal keyboard (probably bc laptop kbs generally don't send the inputs at the actual same time or sth), so you'd just give an arbitrary cheese method for certain hardware.

15
jesse1412jesse1412•

Is this true? Why would osu! Treat laptop kbs differently? If you mean that some laptop keyboards allow multiple keys to be pressed while some keyboards don't then that's honestly a none issue imo. I think most modern keyboards are starting to support nkro, especially mech keyboards. Either way, the fix should've been disabling double tapping for all rather than enabling it, it's a cheap method for streaming. The only reason I'm not completely triggered by them enabling double tapping is because it's neat for 2b maps.

1
LawL4Everhttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/3556856•

It's what he said when he tweeted about it when he changed it. He used to play on a laptop and doubletapping worked fine, then when he changed to a different kb it stopped working, so he made it work regardless of hardware. It's not an issue with nkro (otherwise the game wouldn't register the input of both keys regardless of what the code says), it has to be something else though I have no idea what, probably related to how the game receives the timing of the keystrokes. My theory is that on his laptop kb the keystrokes weren't registered as exactly at the same time, and the game treated two keystrokes at the exact same time as only one keystroke, so it wouldn't hit two notes if they were stacked.

1
vertotaco•

Although I cannot really agree with this, we desperately need changes so it is a step forward.

24
frendle•

I'm glad there is finally SOME change. Why not experiment and see what works instead of throwing out ideas and never actually trying anything?

4
vertotaco•

Read the second part of the sentence.

1
Forgetmepls•

He's agreeing with you

7
vertotaco•

Oh...

My bad ;_;

2
OneWStreethttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/4565624•

Congratz to Rohulk

17
PHCRohrhttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/9316279•

And Wilchq

8
sublimity_osu•

Just so you all know, Its not being absolutely implemented.

right now in the dev server they are setting up test data etc.

https://i.imgur.com/x9fP4TQ.png

15
Raubhen•

Imma kms if i lose my 2 207 pp scores

12
robeeelis•

cool

1
dtatiyamahttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/tatiyama•

Jesus, I'll be a 6 digit again... rip.

12
Paco-ta•

and freedomdiver's haitai is going to worth even less lol

12
fiscottehttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/4218862•

Please make the incrementation less linear, it's gonna frustrate a lot of people otherwise

11
blader0607•

wow this is BIG gay

10
blader0607•

Sure nerf maps with difficult jumps lets not nerf 5 min farm maps with no hard patterns at all. RIP people whomst'dve hands sweat, and grips that fall apart in a few minutes.

10
cmyui•

bro why u getting wet looking at anime girls??

3
GiftedOsu•

My hands do that but I just reset whenever there are slow sliders so I still manage to fc long maps

2
blader0607•

resetting grip and pausing fast as fuk is now a skill calculated towards pp. fml lmaooo. every time i've adjusted grip in a 3+ min map I almost always shitmiss because the grip I've adjusted to felt wrong and I had no more opportunities do so.

6
amadesu•

change grip :)

3
GiftedOsu•

Eh I guess I just adjust correctly at the right time

1
osuisfun6969•

I full combod waldschrein without pausing once who’s upset

1