A huge pp nerf is incoming for short maps
If a map has fewer than 500 objects, there is a harsher penalty for pp
The percentage change decreases at 250, 500, and 2000 objects.
Maps that have over 500 objects are unchanged with the current plan
Here's a chart of some specific values for what is changing
Note: It will not be implemented in the next few days, give it a few weeks. It may or may not be implemented at all.
https://github.com/ppy/osu-performance/pull/14#issuecomment-371431338
Posted Mar 8, 2018, 10:14 AM UTC · edited
Can we abandon piece wise functions and adapt appropriate logarithmic or best fit functions instead?
the words here sound good so ill upvote
basically "stop setting arbitrary limits and use a formula with smooth output"
like if all maps with <500 objects get nerfed then u just make ur map 501 objects and it doesnt get nerfed. that's not ideal since there's no in-between
I thought piece wise functions meant functions that have discontinuities (i.e. pauses in a graph... like x<5 && x>7 [wherein x=ℝ≠5,6,7]).
...what is school anymore?
they don't necessarily have to have discontinuities, they just need to have different equations for different parts of the domain
so in the case of this pp change, a nerfed formula is used when objects < 500, and the original formula is used when objects >= 500 (disclaimer: i didnt look at the changelog)
Yeah, but it looks like this instead. ______--------''''''""""""""""
Piecewise functions often have discontinuities, but not (necessarily?) places where it's not defined like that.
There's a discontinuity at x=2 because what the function approaches from the left side (and the actual value) is y=10 but from the right side it approaches y=14
It doesn't need to be discontinuous. It will have different derivatives.
I don't like the terminology of "piecewise functions", cause a function is just a map from a domain (in this case it could be a proper subset of R) to R. More appropriate is "piecewise continuous functions", which is what you're familiar with. A continuous function is by definition piecewise continuous (with just one piece). :)
Well it's 3 linear functions with differing gradients.
I think we should be using Krylov-subspace based methods instead. GMRES has excellent performance.
it really doesn't change much. the piece-wise functions are still linear and create a roughly logarithmic curve (but being better tailored to not approach extremes).
I don't understand how a piecewise could me more tailored to extremes than a logarithmic curve (not to be imflammatory, genuinely curious)
sometimes you actually want a linear drop-off?
but why? Maybe for testing but I don't see why you wouldn't try to later find a best fit curve to the piece wise? I guess I'm having trouble finding a purpose other than balancing, which you can just keep the piecewise as an early model then shift to a more appropriate curve once the numbers settle. At this point all this system does is encourage 251 and 501 object maps.
So if the piece wise function has no break (as peppy is suggesting) it can create a decent approximation.
1-15 = 9*x + 31
16-30 = 18*x - 104
31-45 = 36*x - 374
46-60 = 36*x - 779
A function like this with properly corrected y intercepts will approach the previous and next function.
then make more steps. should not be too bad to make 10-20 steps instead of 3
unnecessary IMO. if we notice issues during testing we will consider it.
People will just map maps that are 1 object over the step, making multiple steps will make it more balanced IMO
every combo under 500 -1 pp imo
wtf maths
wtf i hate english now