Design workflow when using a Magento theme?
I'm a graphic designer who has worked on several custom web design projects. I build the responsive breakpoint comps in illustrator and then hand them off to dev. However, I've been tasked with a new project that will consist of picking a Magento theme as the starting point. The issue I'm struggling with is understanding the workflow now that I'll be confined to the parameters and functionality of whatever the theme has to offer. How do other teams mock up what they want the site to look like? How are you supposed to know all of your options when it comes to aesthetic styling, placement, and especially functionality? How do I know if an extension will work with the theme I've chosen? Is it efficient at all to be creating page comps (Illustrator? Photoshop? XD?) or does this whole process require a designer and front end dev to sit together and work through piece by piece?
I'd appreciate ANY insight you have into the creative process of using a theme, I'm really having trouble wrapping my head around it.
Thank you!
Posted Mar 8, 2018, 5:11 PM UTC
First off.
Magento 1 or Magento 2?
They are entirely different platforms.
You need to be versed in Magento. Hiring a designer with no Magento experience to design a Magento site is just asking for loads of scope creep and overhead.
You dont know until you test. Magento isnt a platform you want to just start randomly installing 3rd party extensions on. Every extension you add just builds on another layer of complexity that everyone has to take into consideration when doing anything.
Basically test, test and test again. In your case. You would consult with the dev building the site.
If you have no experience with Magento and your client is aware of that. Yes. You need to be bouncing questions off the developer. Magento is a beast of its own. Even building out a commercial theme is time consuming and complex as shit.
Example. Adding a new block to a header menu with what you think should be a basic function could end up costing many hundreds if not thousands of dollars to implement. Depending on the theme. A simple menu could be built and laid out using multiple files and technologies. The layout is probably, XML, The template is probably calling in multiple php template files, the functionality is probably a wall of JavaScript/jQuery. The simple isnt always simple on Magento. Matter of fact. Nothing is simple at all about Magento.
Get familiar with the theme you are using. Study its layouts, block placements and what it can and can not do out of the box.
Hopefully you have a decent front end dev working with you that you can bounce ideas off of.
Just out of curiosity. What theme are you building on? Also. Be sure to check out r/magento
Thanks for the response, thats super helpful already.
We haven't selected a theme yet because we want to understand how exactly we'd leverage the theme to build the site. We'll be using Magento 2.
I guess the larger question I have is how the creative team is supposed to approach a site build based off an existing theme. Do other shops have their dev team have to hold the hand of the creative team throughout the entire process? Something like, "Okay, you can place a content block here and here, but not over there..." etc. This seems monumentally inefficient to me so I know I'm not understanding the process correctly.
The closest example I can relate to is the Squarespace experience. You begin by picking a template, but from there you have a drag-and-drop experience where you are choosing where content blocks are positioned, sized, etc. — I've seen a few "page builder" features for Magento, but aside from those, how are creative teams showing dev how they'd like the site to be styled?
The other part thats really confusing to me is seeing a theme with several different "demo" sites that use that theme. If those demos are all sourced from the same theme, then all of those different examples of functionality and styling are available to implement, correct? As part of the creative team, how can I 1) know all of the options I have to work with and 2) create a comp to hand over to dev – "recreating the theme" within Photoshop, Illustrator, XD seems counterintuitive if dev won't be directly implementing those designs, and instead just tweaking the existing template framework.
You would normally hire a agency whose creative team has first hand experience with the platform. Firms specializing in Magento usually focus on it.
But ya. The design would be gone over by the devs to get an idea of the scope.
Full mockups.
Yes.
If you stick to the default functionality of Magento and the theme. You shouldn't have any major setbacks. I'd recommend Ultimo. Built a few sites on top of it. Great theme.
I guess you are pretty far along in the process. I'd be damn sure I needed Magento 2 and had a hefty budget before I went forward with building a site on it. The overhead of Magento 2 compared to Magento 1 is off the charts. You need a backend dev to do basically anything. Coupled with the patch after patch and the hours needed to simply install updates. The platform is a major pain in the ass.
For some background, our dev team is extremely familiar with Magento, but primarily for back-end. I'm on the creative team who has little to no true experience working with Magento, other than providing mock ups to dev who then somehow turn it in to a working site. (Ugh, I know how bad that sounds. We're trying to fix workflow communication issues between creative & dev).
Do you have any good examples of ecommerce sites built using Ultimo that I could share with my team? (Our client has about 1700 SKUs if that helps to compare).
Just out of curiosity, what makes Magento 2 so much more expensive than Magento 1?
The workflow, lack of documentation, then tech stack and hosting requirements. Magento 2 is enterprise aimed where medium sized businesses are basically alienated from the platform due to needing a developer to do anything.. A good Mag 2 dev is going to charge you $130+ an hour.
The only reason I'd roll a Magento 2 site is if the client needed to massively scale or needed very custom functionality not provided by other platforms.
Check my website/portfolio or kitchen cabinet kings dot com, very custom site I built over Ultimo. Theres a lot out there. Ultimo is one of the better built more popular themes. I'd link you some but I'm currently on mobile.