VERY different SR gains in the same games?

Question

My brother and me recently (~2 seasons ago) started playing competitive and I seem to always get more SR for wins and lose less for losses.

We're usually very close in terms of skill in fps (which I know overwatch isn't technically) but no matter how well he does/how poor I do, in 10 games I get like 100 SR more. It seems odd that he doesn't seem to be favored by the SR system even if he pops off and that the SR gap increases while we play the exact same games.

I've seen him play and I really doubt I'm that much better, especially consistently.

If anyone has an explanation for this I'd be happy to hear it. We're at ~1650 (me) and ~1550 (him) if that helps.

Posted Mar 12, 2018, 6:00 AM UTC

111
Probroheim•

I heard mmr is used to dictate your gains and losses. So even though you have similar SR your mmr ratings might be different resulting in those differences. Me and a friend, me at 1740 and my friend at 2110. We gain and lose about the same for each game. With a difference of about 5 - 10 on average.

3
msx92OP•

But shouldn't he get more mmr and me less mmr for the same games? Let's say you and your friend play vs a 1850 team and your mmr roughly matches your SR. The system expects your friend to be able to beat these players so he gains less/loses more sr/mmr. You play vs players the system thinks are better than you so it's vice versa.

That should mean if you play the same games you should always get pushed closer in terms of rating, no? Unless skill based really has that much of an impact, which seems odd in our situation...

0
wowaka•

mmr =/= your rank compared to team avg rank. it's true that you generally gain less sr for beating an "underdog" team and vice versa, but his hidden mmr is still in play and it seems like the system has determined that he should be a higher rank and is pushing him in that direction by awarding more sr. since personal performance sr gains is still in play at your rank, it's probably focusing on his stats (likely higher than other players at his level) and using those to bump up said hidden mmr.

some of this is definitely still speculation, since no one has a complete grasp of the mmr/sr algorithm besides the programmers, but we do know these two factors have a significant impact on sr gains.

3
Probroheim•

Well let's be real here, none of us truly know what blizzard is doing with their rating system. This theory is based on things I've read and my own experiences. My friend played a lot longer than I have, when I started out I used to gain quite a bit more than my friend. He was high silver and I haven't been placed yet (was put in mid bronze). But the better I got the gains/losses started equalizing. But again, we can only assume what blizzard dictates as good or bad gameplay. I've noticed when I play Zen and I am a bit lacking with healing but I got a good kill count I won't gain as much Sr as I usually would.

2
DarkPenfold•

The main thing that's probably to blame is your hidden MMR (matchmaking rating). SR and MMR are separate - SR is affected by every game, but MMR is slower to adjust based on how 'certain' the algorithm is of where you belong. If you're playing lots of games and are performing within the norms of your expected skill level, it'll get more 'certain' of your skill level and will be slower to react to (for example) win or loss streaks; conversely, if you don't play Competitive for a long time - e.g. a couple of seasons' break - your MMR becomes less certain and will react more dramatically. (It's possible to gain considerable amounts of SR for a win if the game isn't certina of your MMR; for example, I took a 4-season break from Competitive until S8 and my first post-placements match netted me a gain of 77SR.)

At any tier below Diamond, you're also going to be subject to the vagaries of 'personal performance'. What this means is that key stats for your chosen hero(es) that match are compared to the stats of other players at around your current MMR who used those heroes on that map. If they're above the average for your MMR, you'll gain slightly more SR per win, or lose slightly less in the event of a loss. If they're below average, you'll lose slightly more / gain less SR.

On paper, performance-based SR adjustments are problematic for a couple of reasons. First of all, the concept disincentivises changing heroes - stats are based on your performance per 10mins, so it's detrimental to flex to several different heroes during a match because your short bursts on each character are being compared to the 10min averages of all the players who 'main' those heroes. You'll gain less SR for a win if you play 4-5 different heroes in order to exploit the weak points in the enemy team's defense than you would if you stuck with a single hero and tried to brute-force your way through suboptimal match-ups.

Secondly, a lot of elements that contribute to a win can't realistically be measured by stats alone. A Tracer who's harassing the enemy supports by their spawn, preventing them from reinforcing their team, will be getting less damage and Ults per 10mins than if they'd been shooting enemy tanks on the frontline, and so will gain less SR for a win - but the damage they're doing to both the supports and the enemy team's morale can absolutely swing the match in their team's favour. Similarly, a Reinhardt player who blocks tons of damage for their team but doesn't contribute towards a lot of elims will gain less SR than someone who blocks an average amount of damage for that hero, but who also spends more time charging into a weakened enemy team and going ham.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
GalerionTheMystic•

stats are based on your performance per 10mins, so it's detrimental to flex to several different heroes during a match because your short bursts on each character are being compared to the 10min averages of all the players who 'main' those heroes.

Wow, is this still true? I thought they changed it; weren't there some people saying that one-tricks get lesser SR now?

If this is still true then Blizzard is dumber than I thought.

1
yumyumtinklebottom•

sr gain/loss is performance based so if im on an account that is bronze sr but i play liek a masters players ill gain 30-40 sr on wins and lose 10-15 on a loss

3
YouWonADildo•

Do you and your brother play different characters? One thing it's doing is comparing how you played your character to how other players perform on the same character. For example, if you're a little better at healing than the average mercy at your rank then you get extra points. On the other hand you can get the gold medal for healing in that game, but still be pretty average compared to the wider community, so no bonus points.

2
x_LordOfGlory_x•

It depends on what role you play, usually DPS players get more SR than Support or Tank players.

1
Jaskre•

I was duo queueing with a friend last night, he is 800 less SR than me for each win I was recieving around 15 SR he was getting 25-30. When we got a loss I would lose 25-30 and he would lose around 15-20.

It's because when you group up it gives you a new group at rating so say your 2000 and a friend is 1400 your group rating will be around 1700. So your gains/loses will be based off the fact your against a team below your sr whereas your friend is against a team higher than him.

1
burr-sir•

Do you play the same roles, or different ones? Do you have similar hero pools? Does one of you play off-meta heroes and the other doesn’t? Performance-based SR sometimes has trouble measuring the performance of certain roles (particularly tanks) and heroes who are rarely played on a given map or objective.

Has he been playing much longer than you, or does he play a lot more than you? If your account has fewer games than his, the system may be less certain of your rank and more willing to believe you’re a smurf.

Or maybe you’re just better than him!

1