r/China•
mintaurus

Why did govt censor the eye roll?

Why did the Chinese government censor the reporter's eye roll meme? Is there another reason another than the fact that they don't want to shift the spotlight away from the NPC meeting?

Posted Mar 16, 2018, 7:22 PM UTC

2442
calstyles•

Presumably because people were using it to represent disgust with the constitutional reform in general

35
mintaurusOP•

Do you have any sources for that?

2
ting_bu_dongUnited States•

"Why this thing?"

"Because this, probably."

"Prove it!"

13
mintaurusOP•

I am working on a presentation on this topic and need sources, not because I don't believe the commenter.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
BillyBattsShinebox•

Sources? You're doing a topic on censorship. The entire point of censorship here is to pretend that things never existed in the first place.

7
i_reddit_too_mcuh•

For things like this, you might get speculation at best. As far as I'm aware, no Chinese government body came out with a statement on why Winnie the Pooh was banned and that was a long time ago.

5
Jman-laowai•

The Government just censors things. They don't explain why

2
cuteshooter•

You can google it.

1
calstyles•

Ehm... WeChat groups?

4
mintaurusOP•

I'll look into my wechat groups too, thanks for the tip!

1
calstyles•

You won’t find anything now that the image is banned. But you could try uploading a version of it (deep fry it or scribble over part of it or something so it doesn’t get auto removed) and asking your friends... though if you’re not very close they’re likely to change the topic/feel awkward

2
xiefeilaga•

China Digital Times usually has good coverage of censorship issues. Not sure if they've done a write-up of this yet though.

4
mintaurusOP•

Thank you, I'll look into it :)

1
Dachingk•

The reporter in red is quite notorious for asking very unsophisticated questions that are obviously sucking up to the official narrative

24
mintaurusOP•

I'll look into the reporter too, thank you!

3
hapigood•
9
rockyrainyChina•

Thank you.

2
mr-wienerAustralia•

She used to be a beauty contest contestant( miss Sanya?) ... so not the brightest penny in the fountain.

Edited for pronoun problems.

1
barryhakker•

Participating in a beauty contest automatically makes you dumb? Very open minded of you.

4
mr-wienerAustralia•

Let's just say some girls stay in school , others get by on their looks ... some guys for that matter also.

Sorry to have offended your sensibilities.

1

It went off script.

It broke the illusion that the reporter in red was asking a genuine question, rather than reading prescribed text (which are often over board in praising the questionee).

20
mintaurusOP•

Thank you!

2
ssnistfajenCanada•

Because it is an expression of discontent against this entire show put up by this government, and is being made into a meme to express the same feeling against the government.

Ultimately, anything on the "political scene" that doesn't fall directly in line with the government's narrative is at the risk of censorship. The risk increases exponentially with growing popularity.

11
schuke•

Because it's a truthful unscripted expression, which is banned during the congress sessions.

6
americarthegreat•

Because it's evidence that China is not a united, harmonious nation.

Why did the actor who refused to play his role get fired from the theater troupe?

5
kulio_forever•

Because everything is political, and anyone can be punished for being insufficiently insufficient.

4
DylanLeviKing•

It's not really that it's dangerous but that nobody wants to be seen as allowing it. So, if she gets away with it, and you okayed her credentials and set her up there, your head is going to roll, so you have to punish her; and if you don't send up the alarm that the eye roll is spreading, somebody else will ask why the hell you didn't. It's more about a fear that it could be bad for individuals involved, shit like that being tolerated, the spread of it going unchecked—so people jump to shut it down to cover their own asses. I think you can see that with any government edict that comes out, the efforts people go to to follow through, even if it makes no sense, just to avoid any heat coming down on them.

3
lvreddit1077United States•

I think I am still pretty ignorant to the inner working of China. However, it seems to me that the government puts on these pageants because they believe they have been validated by the public. I mean that is the least cynical viewpoint. Basically, if you want to change things you start from the bottom of the party. If you prove yourself you move up. The people that move to the top have earned it and now can express the people's will. The pageant being put on is an expression of the people's will. So the eye roll cuts through that artifice to say at least one person doesn't buy the premise.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
cuteshooter•

Because the Party is insecure. Why?

Mockery and laughter, that's what they are afraid of most.

Like abused children.

1