3 - 1 with GR Belcher at FNM Tournament

Hello everyone!

This is the first time I've written a tournament report, but I thought my experience was curious enough that it's worth to post it.

So first the list: Gruul Belcher


Yes, you heard it right. I've built a Modern Belcher list based on this Primer and took it to a third place finish at a 22 people FNM modern tournament. I was lucky enough to not face the most competitive decks since my deck can run into serious issues against Death's Shadow, Tron, Bogles and Burn.

Round 1 vs. Jeskai Draw-Go

I take a Mulligan down to 6 and keep a hand with 3 lands, [[Birds of Paradise]], [[Wall of Roots]] and [[Lay of the Land]]. Normally, I can't keep something like this, but I was really afraid of going down to 5 and start my evening off with a bad game. So I kept the Hand, played my Birds & Wall in the first turns. Soon enough, my opponent tapped his lands to play [[Search for Azcanta]] and then had only one mana open. I used that opportunity to cast a [[Wurmcoil Engine]], which was promptly hit by a [[Path to Exile]]. We then passed turns back and forth, and I finally crept up to seven lands. I cast 2 [[Chancellor of the Tangle]] which were met by Cryptic and Snap Cryptic. In the final turn, I had 10 mana available while he had only six. I led with a [[Blood Moon]] which had to be countered or it was over. So he did cast [[Cryptic Command]] to counter draw. But then I followed it up with a [[Goblin Charbelcher]]. He didn't have a counterspell for that one. So I proceeded to activate Charbelcher and hit him for 41 damage.

I took out a bit of ramp ([[Harrow]] is terrible against Counters) and 1 Goblin Charbelcher, and brought in 2 [[Autumn's Veil]], 1 [[Defense Grid]], 2 [[Spellskite]], 2 [[Scavenging Ooze]].

Game 2 was really funny (for me). I kept seven cards, one of them was [[Carnage Tyrant]], the rest were cards to get me to six mana. I got to six mana, I cast Carnage Tyrant, and my opponent had to do stupid shit with Cryptic Command (tap + bounce to get rid of [[Utopia Sprawl]]). I promptly abused that and resolved a [[Blood Moon]]. His only out had been a one-of [[Supreme Verdict]], now that it was shut off he simply conceded (he was also dead on board I guess).

Round 2 vs. Red Goblins

So this was a strange Goblin deck, it played [[Foundry Street Denizen]], [[Mogg War Marshal]], [[Lightning Bolt]] and [[Goblin Heelcutter]]. I resolved an early [[Wall of Roots]] while he didn't have much action going on. Unable to get to 4 mana, he had to dash in his Heelcutter every turn to get past my Wall. Meanwhile I played a Goblin Charbelcher. Then he used a [[Goblin Bushwhacker]] to pump his team and swing for 8 (while I was at 7 life). I blocked one guy, then activated Charbelcher targeting him. After revealing 11 nonlands, I got to a [[Stomping Ground]], dealing 22 to his face.

I ended up boarding out 1 Charbelcher, and a few of the slower cards in my deck, as well as Blood Moon. In came 2 Spellskites, 2 Scavenging Oozes, 3 [[Kitchen Finks]].

In Game 2 I kept a 5 card hand with 1 [[Kitchen Finks]], 3 ways to produce mana and a [[Chancellor of the Tangle]]. I drew another [[Kitchen Finks]] and it didn't help him, that I was able to steal his [[Contested Warzone]] which really screwed him out of mana. My Finks beat him down to 14 life while I stayed around a comfortable 12. Then I resolved [[Goblin Charbelcher]], hit him for zero in his end step. But in my upkeep, I shot him for 20 damage.

Round 3 vs. Mono G Robots

My opponent built a very sweet deck around [[Hardened Scales]], [[Walking Ballista]] and [[Hangarback Walker]]. Unfortunately, my deck is a lot sweeter and he punted on the math when he played a [[Verdurous Gearhulk]], deciding to spread the counters to maximize the effect from [[Hardened Scales]]. Had he put one more counter on his giant [[Walking Ballista]], I would have been toast from the pinging. But as it was, I managed to hit him for six with my Goblin Charbelcher. Then I followed it up with another hit for 39 that came just in time before he could finish me off.

I boarded out my 2 Blood Moons, and a few slow cards, in exchange for [[Ancient Grudge]], 2 [[Seal of Primordium]], [[Fracturing Gust]], [[Pithing Needle]], 2 [[Spellskite]], 2 [[Scavenging Ooze]].

I then kept a hand with enough mana, a [[Seal of Primordium]] and a [[Goblin Charbelcher]]. I laid down the Charbelcher early, and got a lucky hit of 16 damage. His [[Bow of Nylea]] brought him back up to 7. My [[Seal of Primordium]] killed a [[Steel Overseer]]. [[Nissa, Voice of Zendikar]] was too slow to really make a difference, and when he shot down my Goblin Charbelcher, it didn't really matter since I had already drawn 2 more. I hit him (or didn't hit him...) for another zero damage, and then for 11 which was enough to finish the game.

Round 4 vs. Mono White Weenies, Death and Taxes

I knew from the beginning that this wouldn't end well for me, mainly because my Sideboard was not made to compete with creature heavy strategies. In hindsight, I should have really put in a few [[Pyroclasm]].

In Game 1, my opponent had rather little going on, but when he flipped his [[Kytheon, Hero of Akros]] he was able to force my fat creatures to attack into his first strikers. Then I forgot to pay for a [[Leonin Arbiter]] which broke me. Then I died.

There weren't a lot of things to sideboard in, so I decided to take 2 [[Scavenging Ooze]], 3 [[Kitchen Finks]] and 2 [[Spellskite]] (I did see a [[Flickerwisp]] Game 1, and maybe he'd play [[Disenchant]] or Eldrazi Displacer), siding out 2 Blood Moon, 1 Harrow, 1 Recross the Paths, and some more ramp cards.

We went into game 2, and it started off with a mistake on my part. Wanting to avoid 2 damage from a [[Thalia, Guardian of Thraben]], I bolted her, but he simply played a second one. Had I waited a bit longer, I would have been able to shoot down a [[Blade Splicer]] or his Golem. He played a [[Gideon of the Trials]] plus a few more creatures. I played a Scavenging Ooze and an [[Obstinate Baloth]] to seal the ground, but it was not enough. A [[Thalia, Heretic Cathar]] finished me off, because I wasn't able to deploy enough blockers. So he swung for 14 damage with his entire team which was exactly lethal.


So I finished in 3rd place behind Abzan Rites (3 - 0 - 1) and DnT (4 - 0). I am quite happy with that result. My deck did what it had to do: Hit people for a lot of damage with Goblin Charbelcher. For future tournaments, I might consider tweaking the flexible slots a bit, maybe add a 4th Bolt to the Main Deck, add a board wipe to the Sideboard.

I hope you enjoyed reading this :) If you have any questions regarding card choices or how the deck plays, I am happy to reply in the comments.

Posted Mar 17, 2018, 1:44 PM UTC · edited

4416
PyroMechanicalWurmcoil is the best Blue Creature•

How do you feel about an additional [[recross the paths]]? Once you have no lands it stacks your deck for 3 mana.

9
MythSteak•

I think this is a clear “win more” card. 3 mana for one land is an absolute terrible rate, and faithless looting is so much better at digging in any other situation.

This kinda deck lives or dies on its sequencing in the first couple turns.

Personally: the very first thing I would do is add the fourth looting and the fourth Sakura tribe elder, and the first traverse the ulvenwald, cutting all of the land-search three drops.

5
REMagic42OPBW Emeria's Pact Control•

You are absolutely right about this. My list currently doesn't play Traverse because Delirium is pretty much impossible unless I discard a card I probably shouldn't discard in the first place (Bolt, Charbelcher, Forest), and it's just too expen$ive for being a [[Lay of the Land]] 99% of the time. But it certainly is an upgrade worth considering if I continue optimizing this deck.

4th Sakura-Tribe Elder will probably come in, but I'm not yet sure about a 4th Looting. My consideration was that multiple Lootings make a lot more hands unkeepable, because I don't have a lot of access to red mana. Also, it's a bit like the [[Gitaxian Probe]] conundrum, where obviously the card is better than any other card you can play, but it makes your opener less predictable and mulligan decisions more difficult.

I will definitely cut the [[Harrow]] - I boarded it out every game.

However, Recross the Paths is a very important card in grindy matchups (and a lot of matchups are grindy). When I went for the kill in G1 of Round 1, I actually had 10 mana available with Blood Moon, Charbelcher and Recross the Paths. I sequenced it in a way where Cryptic + Logic Knot for the first two spells would have led to a resolved Recross the Paths that stacks the deck (and returns itself to hand because I can put Chancellor on top and then scry it to the bottom). I think two Recross the Paths are fine. I wouldn't want to play more, but it's an excellent topdeck, which is something this deck is otherwise really lacking.

4
MythSteak•

If cost wasn’t a consideration, then you would definitely want all four traverse. There is also the energy search one from kaladesh.

As for red sources, I currently count 15. That should be enough for your small red splash. I get that multiple faithless lootings can complicate mulligan decisions but shifting to more one drop land search spells should do a ton to mitigate that (16 is a lot more than 12). Looting discarding looting isn’t the worst either, as flashing back looting is pure card quality with none of the card disadvantage of casting it from hand.

If recross stacking really is that essential, you could consider shaving a simian or wall or Baloth. Walking ballista is also a fine creature to consider as a win condition, it’s a mana sink and is great for turning on delirium.

Do you have any thoughts about scooze or tireless tracker in the main (over say baloth)?

3
REMagic42OPBW Emeria's Pact Control•

Hmmm, I just checked the card prices and realized that traverse is a lot cheaper than I thought it was. I thought it was around 10$ each, but I was wrong o.O

So this sounds great, thanks for your advice.

2
MTGCardFetcher•

Lay of the Land - (G) (SF) (MC)
Gitaxian Probe - (G) (SF) (MC)
Harrow - (G) (SF) (MC)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
MTGCardFetcher•

recross the paths - (G) (SF) (MC)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
nickthedrumstick•

This deck looks too fun. And surprisingly cheap! Great work

2
REMagic42OPBW Emeria's Pact Control•

Yeah. [[Blood Moon]] are expensive (also cards like [[Kitchen Finks]], [[Wurmcoil Engine]] and [[Carnage Tyrant]]), but they are completely worth the cost. They wreck any deck with a greedy manabase. It doesn't help our worst matchup (Burn), but every other deck that kills us will struggle against a T1/T2 Blood Moon (please don't actually play it on T1, because you need to set up your ramp!)

2
MTGCardFetcher•

#####

######

####

Blood Moon - (G) (SF) (MC)
Kitchen Finks - (G) (SF) (MC)
Wurmcoil Engine - (G) (SF) (MC)
Carnage Tyrant - (G) (SF) (MC)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
chukbuckKikiMoon/NayaZoo/HardenedSnek•

Congrats on the finish, I love the Carnage Tyrant. That dude is sweet.

2
REMagic42OPBW Emeria's Pact Control•

Yep. He turns a bad matchup (blue control) into a winnable one, because they usually don't play answers post board. Especially if they didn't see the creature plan in G1.

1
Geegoat•

I've had a few versions of Green Belcher for a while but saw this report and decided to try your list last night at the LGS. Round 1 vs UR Kiki I lost in 2. Round 2 was a bye.

Round 3 was against Restore Balance and we had a lot of back and forth but I won in 3. Pithing Needle'd a Nahiri that was about to ult after stacking my deck with Recross to get the Seal of Primordium to free my Belcher from an O-Ring.

Round 4 won against Burn in 3. Funniest part about that game one is I kept a zero lander and played two Obstinate Baloth before finding land. All star in game 3 was the Defense Grid as they could not afford to Deflecting Palm me.

Round 5 lost in 2 to Jund. Disruption+clock did me in both games.

Loved this version although I missed Stirrings and more Wurmcoils from my previous lists. Baloths in the main were great all night although they didn't get to shine vs Jund in round 5. Tracker felt awkward but I only saw him once or twice. We make our land drops pretty quick and he's an awful topdeck if we've made them and are grinding. 10/10 experience, thank you for writing it up and giving me some ideas!

2
ate50eggs•

Why Attune instead of another Traverse?

1
REMagic42OPBW Emeria's Pact Control•

This is an updated list and not the one I played at the tournament. Refer to this revision Revision 10 to see what I played.

The tournament list contains neither card. Since I have 4 Attune and only 1 Traverse, that's what I have to play right now.

1
Stringpeas•

Nice tournament report! Some questions about card choices based on your Revision 10: -Have you considered [Arbor Elf] over [Birds of Paradise]. It plays well with [Utopia Sprawl]. -Why dont you play [Traverse the Ulvenwald].

1