If you are making a pixel art game, please don't make your text pixellated too!
Or, at least, make sure its very high resolution pixelation. I've played a large number of pixel-art games recently and I really do enjoy that art style, but I often find pixellated text really difficult to read. if the game has only a little bit of text, then I can ignore it, but if you have a lot of text or the text is super important, it gets very frustrating. I quit playing games because reading the pixel text was too difficult.
So please be aware of this! Thanks :)
EDIT: It seems most people are responding negatively to this. Do indie devs not find usability important? If a game is the most beautifully crafted game ever, but I can't play it because the text is unreadable (yet important to the game, not all games need me to be able to read the text), then I can't play it and I will never experience your beautifully crafted game. I'm not saying don't ever use pixel-fonts, I'm just saying be aware that some people will find it hard to read and design around that. That may mean to use a higher resolution font (it can still be pixellated looking!), but maybe you can do something else, like, as mentioned in the comments below, a larger font, better outline, or carefully choose a pixel-font that is still very clear. Not all pixellated text is created equal and I think game developers need to be aware that it can be a usability issue if care isn't taken. I'm certainly not saying never do it.
Posted Mar 17, 2018, 3:27 PM UTC · edited
I disagree. Consistency in art is important. It is INCREDIBLY annoying and distracting when a pixel art game displays text at a higher resolution than gameplay.
Except Comic Sans. Comic Sans can be used for everything.
Consistency is important, but only if I can read the text. If I can't read the text, its even more distracting than having it at a higher resolution and if the text is important, then the game is basically a write-off. You also need to keep in mind that some players may be vision impaired, or even just not a native english speaker. Nothing should trump usability. A beautiful and consistent art style is not useful if the game is unplayable. If you ignore usability in your games, then don't be surprised if people get pissed because they wasted money on a game they cannot play.
Now, in some games the text is unimportant enough that you can simply not read it and still have fun, but in my opinion, those are the games sold purely on the gameplay and having higher res text will likely not detract from it anyway, but still, I can forgive such games. If the text is in anyway important, though, because it tells a large part of the story in a story-heavy game, or its needed to solve puzzles or dialogue, then I need to be able to read it without struggling!
I agree with the usability part (100%). I guess I should ask for clarification.
Is your main problem that text is too small or that the blocky characteristics of low-point fonts make it hard for you to read? If neither of those, can you explain further?
I'd say both or either of those. If a pixel-font is too small, its a problem and if its too blocky (ie if it looks like if you used a very small font, but scaled up) then its a problem. You can certainly have a sufficiently detailed font without losing the pixellated blocky aesthetic.
Really all I'm asking for is that consideration is taken to usability and that if a pixellated font is used, that care is taken to make sure its easily readable because not everybody will be able to read it as easily as you may be able to. I'm not asking for you to ruin your games style or aesthetic at all!
the most basic fundamental requirement of text is that it must be possible to read it