Any idea what happened to Felkin?
I remember this dude is one of the most active member on this sub back on late 2015 to early 2017 (?), and s/he just sorta... disappear? I loved reading his/her chapter per chapter analysis and the fan theory that s/he made is also enjoyable to read as well. Not to mention the debate as well, oh boy.
Posted Mar 19, 2018, 9:44 AM UTC
What if I told you I have an 8 page document sitting on my desktop that I wrote 2 days ago, but am not sure if I want to let out into the world?
I caught up this Saturday. I just really dislike the direction SIU is taking right now. That's why I put the webtoon on hold in the first place.
My final few posts when FoD was ending were increasingly more critical of SIU and I started to feel bad in general about it. The posts were always "get my thoughts about the chapter organized" first and "share them with others" second. That first point just became really difficult to do without making me depressed about SIU's decisions.
Oh wow that was quick. I guess that guy did keep his word about contacting you on Discord lol. Also 8 pages?! Damn, now you're making me curious. I think you should hold on to that at least until season 2 is finished, and probably make a similar post to this with some critic and opinion of what went wrong with season 2 or about SIU's storytelling, etc. In case you want to make that one final post that is.
What about it do you dislike so much?
Not Felkin but something I noticed about ToG is that it pretty much became Bleach with better characters and Rachel. It's almost purely power vs power now instead of scheming and creatively solving problems.
Baam goes to new floor, fights someone "unbeatable", beats them, gets new power, goes to next floor, rinse and repeat. That's the hell train, name station, and FoD in a nutshell (It's also how the hidden floor is shaping up to be). From a storytelling perspective, the story is really flat and is really relying on the world building of the first season and the beginning of the second season to make the story readable. The story became about revealing the tower and Baam's destiny instead of following a close knit team who solves problems together.
Why does this matter? Because revealing who Baam is and the world of the tower means that the way our main characters interact with their problems is relatively meaningless. The becomes about finding out the major plot points.
Why is the hidden floor interesting? Is it because of the way the characters are interacting with the floor and eachother or is it because of what the floor holds?
Contrast this with the second floor up to the workshop battle and this is switched around. The most interesting part is the relationships and the interactions with the games and it does a great job with the world building too. Instead of reveals being at the forefront, it's the characters, whereas the last few arcs have been almost exclusively about reveals instead of characters.
I still read it because I am curious about the tower (and Rachel) and it's fun but that doesn't mean that it's a good story per se. It's the same reason why I kept on reading Bleach til the end, I was invested, the art was kinda fun, and I wanted to know the end. ToG is still 10x more enjoyable but still.
A counter argument to the "lower quality story telling AKA Flat": You can not create a story without some interesting dynamics to it. By that I mean, you must first build up the story with rules or characters become the forefront. So it is natural for the story to progress this way(i.e. ToG always had a slow story building so characters took a forefront first to establish reader retention. Most stories stop building relationships and interactions unless the author wants each "arc" to become a routine such as shoujo manga where you don't actually gain anything new whilst ToG is revealing secrets of the tower and Baam). Take a look at all other stories, this is how they first begin unless they want the character to be very edgy.
Also, I just wanna say the FoD arc was possibly my favourite arc due to the fact the world building has finally borne some answers instead of just presenting somewhat loose facts that we have no connection to. An example was before the incident, who the hell was Enryu and why did he go to that floor and kill the guardian? Did it affect the story? No. Did it feel like a waste of information that you needed to remember and keep? Hell yes it did.
Conversely, put this up against the Workshop. The battle at the workshop was too idealistic and did not present new answers to previous information (although the issue on thorn was presented and concluded swiftly). Not to mention Baam seemed to be saved by mega plot twists/Armor that although tolerable seemed really annoying and was a pull on my leg which could possibly be summed in one word from the author: FATE. i.e. Baam was fated to survive and live although by the slimmiest of margins. Some examples from the arc that seemed too idealistic? Baam is known to be a kind-hearted individual but how the hell did he fully convince Koon Ran to trust him? That was an important factor for him to come out with no losses but the way the story went, it just seemed bullshit at best. He also went to save Hwaryun but was saved at the last sec by Androssi's Bonbon which also seemed too idealistic as well. The biggest offender of all: Baam falling for the trap laid out by FUG and being trapped with the thorn. How the hell did they not realise Bam's fake thorn (which they delivered to him by Reflejo himself) is a bowl for the real thorn? Also why did they not know it could just absorb the damn thing? For me, The story telling of Workshop was by far the worst I have ever read and when i do re-read ToG, I tend to skip workshop altogether.
The story was shit in Workshop and has to be some of the dumbest down-played story I have ever read. Did it have suspense though with Baam in danger trying to save everyone? Yes it did; but do you also consider the use of Jump-Scares a good tactic in horror games and movies? The answer should be F*cking hell no. That's exactly what SIU pulled on us and I can only assume that he realised his mistake in the workshop and therefore decided to change his story-telling to be what it should be: Actual story telling!! Baam is there to prove a point and solve the issues of the tower. The Power struggle has been secondary to the story IMO as you should already know that it has been long established from season 1 (which is a major flaw of the story as a whole although not a plot hole) that Baam is a god when it comes to Shinsu Control. Even then, he got wasted by the King of the Tower in the past few chapters which shows how far he is in terms of power.
The Power curve is massive but will never be a Bleach/Naruto/DragonBall and become just over-the-top boring due to the fact those stories never established the Upper Cap to the story. This is the difference between them and ToG: we basically know fully the capabilities of an individual beforehand and also what the strongest are capable of and therefore won't have any surprises or seemingly lazy writing (looking at your DBS with your individual beings capable of wiping out a whole multi-verse) You should also have realised Baam was always fated to have power rivaling theirs and that he would eventually have powers capable of killing a guardian. Though this point is moot why? Because he probably never has to kill one and the "story" is going to be the STORY! In this case: the big picture of the purpose of the tower and Baam's journey to the top (you know he is bound to get their and face Jahad who is essentially a god). So what does he need? That's right! More Power! this was obvious and shouldn't even be an argument that the story rinses and repeats itself with more powerful adversaries as he is definitely going to keep encountering them. In fact, it will be more about the story and journey of going to encounter them from here on. Not his adventures with his team as this was never about making friends but a journey with baam to discover who he is and his destiny with the tower.
Thanks for writing this. Correct on all points IMHO. The story is still highly character driven, mystery driven, builds on the world, builds on the use of shinsoo (which has been a massive foundation for the aforementioned mystery ever since Headon said 'All is possible through shinsoo'), and certainly continues to deliver on all of the things it promised and foreshadowed in season 1.
My own personal gripe is much of the criticism seems to stem from the fact that people's theories (which fair enough, they have poured a lot of time into) are proven to be completely wrong, and therefore the author was wrong to not write it in a way they see as 'making sense'.
A lot of great points here.
When you mentioned bleach, I remembered the ending and fucking died again.
Don't get discouraged. If you wrote something you're satisfied about, release it. There will always be people that appreciate what you're doing!