Impact of Upcoming S&P and MSCI Tech Sector Reclassification

Education

Source article: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-investor/investment-ideas/getting-a-read-on-index-changes/article38279262/

 

In short, GICS is reclassifying components currently within the tech sector starting Sep 28, 2018. Many former tech companies (e.g. Alphabet, Facebook) and consumer discretionary (e.g. Disney, Netflix) will then become part of the communication services sector.

 

I know at this point, this is old news, but some takeaways from the article represent some good points to note:

  • Your back-tests are rendered useless
  • The reason you purchased a fund or ETF may no longer be relevant
  • What you have assumed about an industry may now change
  • Your industry allocations will likely need to change

 

Changes of note:

Company NameCurrent GICS SectorNew GICS Sector
Comcast Corp.Consumer DiscretionaryCommunication Services
Time Warner Inc.Consumer DiscretionaryCommunication Services
Twenty-First Century Fox Inc.Consumer DiscretionaryCommunication Services
Viacom Inc.Consumer DiscretionaryCommunication Services
Walt Disney Co.Consumer DiscretionaryCommunication Services
NetFlix Inc.Consumer DiscretionaryCommunication Services
TripAdvisor Inc.Consumer DiscretionaryCommunication Services
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. ADRInformation TechnologyConsumer Discretionary
Baozun Inc. ADRInformation TechnologyConsumer Discretionary
eBay Inc.Information TechnologyConsumer Discretionary
Alphabet Inc.Information TechnologyCommunication Services
Baidu.com ADRInformation TechnologyCommunication Services
Facebook Inc.Information TechnologyCommunication Services
Twitter Inc.Information TechnologyCommunication Services
Yelp Inc.Information TechnologyCommunication Services
Snap Inc.Information TechnologyCommunication Services

Posted Mar 22, 2018, 12:39 PM UTC · edited

5918
MasterCookSwag•

This is something that will constantly be happening. "Tech" isn't so much an industry as it was in the 90s. At some point basically all companies are going to be "tech" companies. Amazon is a huge retailer that primarily competes with Wal Mart, Target, big box stores, etc. Facebook is a provider of advertising tools and analytics that it primarily derives from social media offerings. These two companies couldn't have more different businesses yet they're both "tech". Imo changing the classifications to reflect that technology is no longer an industry isolated phenomenon is a good thing.

That said it definitely does do most of what you pointed out so people do need to he cognitive of this.

28
FearspectOP•

One item I always found hard to understand was, for example, Intel falling under tech instead of industrials (manufacturing), mostly because 'tech' refers to 'information technology' and not just 'technology'.

6
MasterCookSwag•

Right. Intel is a manufacturer, Amazon is a retailer, Apple is a lifestyle/phone company, Microsoft is a business support company, Facebook is an advertising company and yet they're all the same sector. Imo at some point the entire idea of a tech sector probably needs to be abolished because basically all companies will become tech companies.

8
rybicki•

Where do you go to find the GICS classification of a particular stock? Take Amazon, for example. I've seen it called tech elsewhere, as you do here. However...

  • Morningstar calls it "consumer cyclical," which isn't a GICS label but (I think) can safely be interpreted as consumer dis.
  • Fidelity calls it consumer discretionary, but it takes a couple clicks to find that information if you're not logged in.
  • Yahoo calls it "services," which also isn't a GICS label and can literally mean anything.
3
crash94•

I just use cap iq or research insight

2
jmlinden7•

Intel isn’t just a manufacturer, they are also a retail brand. A pure manufacturer would be something like GloFo or TSMC

1
dying_to_be_vain•

At some point basically all companies are going to be "tech" companies.

General Mills was voted the Best Place to Work in IT in 2009.

6
MasterCookSwag•

You didn't think captain crunch ran on analog did you???

6
COMPUTER1313•

And Walmart, McDonald and Coca Cola have a pretty complex logistic system.

KO is known for being the "cockroach" of logistics, because they will deliver and sell their products where no one else would. I remember a veteran claiming that most of the trucks they saw in operation during and shortly after the 2003 invasion of Iraq were Coca Cola delivery trucks.

3
dying_to_be_vain•

Coke dominates Europe today, thanks to their cooperation with the military during WWII. The bit at the end about Russian general Georgy Zhukov is great, too:

So, he had to find a way to disguise his beverage of choice. He contacted Coca Cola and asked if they could make him a clear version of the soda, so that it would look like vodka and no one would question him for drinking it in public (oh Russia). Coca Cola happily obliged, even shipping the clear cola to Zhukov in vodka shaped bottles with a red star on the side.

4
Mcwastiiee•

Tech is what the tech community decides is a tech company. Couldn't give a definition

1

Will the advertising tools and analytics bubble finally pop in 2018?

1
sarascha•

Alphabet is the only one I disagree with, but it's large enough that even a sector classification is difficult.

1
raindownsugar•

Hoping this falls under 'there are no stupid questions' but does this mean that companies such as Alphabet and FB will move from VGT to VOX on 9/28/18 or at some other point in time?

Edit: https://www.investopedia.com/news/vanguard-change-three-etfs-indexes/?partner=YahooSA&yptr=yahoo Looks like Vanguard will use transition benchmarks beginning 2Q to smooth the move. Would this indicate VOX is essentially undervalued leading into 2Q?

3
ramakris2•

Have the same question.. given this move is VOX undervalued ?

1
[deleted]•

why is disney and fox in there

2
fsu_ppg•

Disney when acquiring Fox increased its stake in Hulu to 60%. Also, they're launching a streaming service to compete with Netflix in the next few years.

1
ZiVViZ•

Important

1