r/RPGdesign•
Priyon

How to create a sandbox, simulation village/tribe RPG? Asking as someone entirely new to Tabletop RPGs.

Mechanics

Hi there. I was wondering if I should post here or not, in case the post might get hate for my sheer lack of experience in tabletop RPGs.

A few months ago I wasn't even familiar with the concept tabletop RPGs (even after over a decade of PC and NES RPG games). I discovered Dungeons and Dragons completely by chance while looking for random generators. Looked up a few videos, read up lots about D&D and the vast world of RPGs, and I immediately fell in love with the concept since I love sandbox gaming and role-playing in video-games so much.

Unfortunately I live in a country where tabletop RPGs are completely unheard of. Hardly any have ever seen, heard or played such games here. So of course, to may dismay I realized that I will never have a chance to play most of the RPGs since they require a group.

So I have decided to design a solo but functional RPG game simply for my own amusement (without any intention to publish it so far). I have few ideas in my mind, the first of which is a sandbox RPG based on isolated tribal life. I intend to create more games simply for my own fun. I like to travel to places where I can't bring my PC everywhere, so a few books, die sets, notebooks and such won't be a problem.

But so far, trying my game free-form without any systems and rules got boring fast.

I looked around on how to develop some "systems" if that is the right term. People told me about "homebrewing" rules as I go along. And told me to ask here for help in developing it further. And here I saw people taking some heat for taking mechanisms from other games or making them too complicated to play, so I was worried if I should post this. Anyway, let's see what the game is about.


Basic idea -

So the basic idea for my RPG is that:

  • The game is completely solo based.
  • It is a sandbox game and almost a simulation. Yes I know that would be ridiculous, as RPGs have stories.
  • It is completely for my own amusement and in the extremely rare case someone else would want to play it, so quality of "game rule book" wouldn't matter. I would love to jot down charts and rules in my notebooks.
  • It doesn't have to use miniatures or figures, pen and paper only.
  • It is very realistic, so humans are the only race playable. And creatures are also real-life animals and critters.

The gameplay goes as such:

  • You create/generate a tribal village situated on terrains like tropical rainforest, hills, mountains, river plains and such.
  • The player character is essentially a person living in that tribe.
  • The aim of the game is to live out a usual, boring human life.
  • On the character sheet, you create a character and can generate or choose their backstory and starting conditions. You can also generate a family and dynasty for him/her.
  • Stats (still WIP) are chosen.
  • Choose a job, work in tribal society as a craftsman, or a hunter, fisherman, or enlist as a warrior.
  • The game plays out in turns, each turn a random event happens from a huge list of random events.
  • Have kids, feed your family, ensure their survival.
  • Those kids will grow up, socialize, work and start their own families.
  • Build up your housing, from shacks to fortified halls.
  • Once your character dies (either in fight, through disease or simple old age), you continue on playing as one of your children of your own choice.
  • The game goes on like this, generating unique mundane-life stories for as long as the player plays it.

If anything Crusader Kings 2, The Guild 2 and Dwarf Fortress have showed me, games like these can be very fun to play if done correctly.


Systems I have worked on so far -

  • Age Division - Borrowing from games like Sims series, every character is categorized into age groups of Infant (representing age 0-3) -> Child (4-11) -> Teenager (11-16) -> Youth (16-30) -> proper Adult (30-50) -> Elder (50 onwards). I was going originally relying on number of years, but I think it would be too complicated.

  • The above ages have a life-span after which they automatically advance to the next stage. Problem is, way too hard to keep track of for more than one character.

  • Body hit areas, which will basically be legs, arms, torso and head. I could improve on this but I want a system that works on every species, human or otherwise.

  • A full collection of weapons, ranged and melee. From clubs, spears, slings, bows and arrows, darts, blowpipes, poison, axes and so on. I have not decided on their stats yet. The few wooden, leather, obsidian-gilt armour sets are also designed except for their stats.

  • Resources and means to acquire them, from wood, flint, stone, crops and meat and everything.

  • A system for crafting and cooking, although only partially done for now.

  • I've created a list of occupations/jobs that would be present in a tribe, after some detailed research.

  • A system of religion, and marriage, rituals and so on. I have decided on what it will be and how it will play out.

  • I have a clear idea about a needs system. Hunger, shelter, thirst, socialization and so on.

  • Buildings are also mostly decided, from housing to storage to shrines and the large huts of chiefs.

  • There is also planned to be a system of carry capacity and action points, since this is probably going to be turn-based.


Things I would like to ask and wish for -

  • What should the base stats be? Should it be a simple system of strength, charisma and so on, or should it also have derived stats like Strength affecting carry-capacity, spear throwing and archery skills?

  • What time should a turn represent? A day? A week? A month? An entire season? Should it be interchangeable as needed for RPG?

  • A dynasty and family system. The character doesn't live alone, they will marry and have children with their spouse. And have to feed and clothe their family and take care of their survival. For this we need a sex/pregnancy system, progression from one age category to other as kids grow, and so on.

I've read how other games take this element, and it eventually led me to the weird and horrible thing that is FATAL. So no, it doesn't have to be in detail at all, just a representation like other games do it.

  • Something about building huts or shacks, and storing belongings in them (from beds to weapons and such). My solution so far has been to make a box/circle on paper, put beds inside, a rack or two for food, a place for weapons, a fireplace, and then roleplay it. But that isn't satisfactory.

  • How to handle other NPCs roaming around the village? Especially since player character will be able to interact with all of them. Should I create a system of relations (a 10-point meter), and a list of interactions? Should the NPCs be generated randomly or should I keep a detailed stat record of them?

  • What should be the system for hunting? I have no experience in how other RPGs do it.

  • How should a system for crafting be (which is going to be very important)? Should it be simple "gather wood rope and stone, wait a turn, viola you have now crafted an axe" or should the process be more complicated? With actual job skill playing into what you can craft and how durable/high quality it is?

The cooking system is also a part of it.

  • A system for feasts and dances, especially since harvest festivals and celebrations of marriages, funerals and ascensions are planned.

  • How to handle economy without a currency? How to create a barter system without actual players? Or should I put in some sort of prehistoric currency to trade (like knives, bushels of grain, amber pieces or such)?

  • A system of diseases and medicine. Should this be handled by random-event roll every turn as a check whether someone gets ill? Also, medicine and herbalism to heal wounded characters, especially player and family.

  • So far the game of the goal is only to survive and thrive for generations, because I found no need to create dungeons or artifacts or such. But I wish to add nearby tribes who may launch raids, and can be raided by me. What would be the system for this?


And the biggest question that is making me pull out my hair - Politics and Law. I have no idea how to create a system for it in this solo game.

The idea is that tribe should be democractic and changeable. There is a High Chief, the leader of the tribe, who has power over the management of entire tribe. But every time he/she dies, a new one is elected. But how is voting handled, especially in a game with only one human player and so much random generation?

  • There is also a council of venerable tribe elders (from 6 to 20 members) who can veto or propose new stuff. A primitive assembly to keep the chief's power in check. But how should that take place?

  • And a high priest/shaman for the religion part of the game, which may or may not feature some low-key divine magic. I am out of ideas for that one.

  • Under the chief is the warchief, basically the tribe's most fearsome fighter and general who leads warriors on campaigns and defends the tribe. Warchief can be challenged to a ritual duel to be replaced by the winner. He gets bonus to stats, but how do you handle appointment for NPCs...do you have to generate a few?

  • If the player becomes the high chief of the tribe, they can turn it into monarchy, meaning that their children succeed them as hereditary leaders from then on.

  • Warriors can revolt against the high chief too, so a system of loyalty and rebellions.

  • The system of laws covering aspects of life, which is to be decided by the chief and the elders. From gender stuff (that I really want to leave out of the game) to number of warriors allowed in the warband (tribes don't have organized armies), polygamy and polyandry, diplomatic conduct with other tribes and so on.

  • The crime system, where crimes happen (and can be committed by the player), and punishment system where defendants can be exiled, killed, imprisoned (or if laws allow it, sacrificed) or forced to work off the punishment (like getting caught stealing a bread loaf from someone has the punishment of returning ten bread loaves to the victim). That is what law is.

  • A crime or dispute is presented before the chief and elders who act as judge. The player committing crimes would also be taken to this "court". Question is, how should I go on creating a system for this?

  • And we haven't even began about leading and defending against raids, and the entire warfare part.

If I successfully create these systems, I have plans to improve and use them to develop more solo RPGs featuring medieval towns, modern village governments and so on that I have in my mind.


Finally, what should be the format of the game's documentation? Since it is for personal use, professional look and art stuff doesn't matter.

I was thinking of making it like a gamebook, especially for random events. With dedicated lists of items and resources and other things in the back. But I have a feeling that this isn't the ideal format.


Conclusion:

And there you have it. Apologies for the long rambling post, kudos if you read it this far. I literally have near-zero experience with actual tabletop RPGs beyond some small solo plays, videos/podcasts that I keep watching and homebrewing. I am very confused after months of researching, looking up various RPGs and their systems (which don't work well for solo anyway) and most places where I ask, direct me here.

I request you to please help me construct this game. :)

And advise me if I am making it overly complicated for a tabletop game (which I had to, because simulation) and should I make it more simple. And sorry again for this post, and thank you for your help.

Posted Mar 25, 2018, 7:33 PM UTC · edited

1311
blindluke•

Glad to hear that you are interested in the hobby. A lot of the work you have done on your game looks like development of a game world / game setting, and not a development of a game itself. Have you tried playing a solo RPG, before you decided to create your own?

Edit: and by solo RPG I mean something created for that purpose, "Scarlet Heroes", "Quill", or "9 questions"/"Mythic" being good examples.

8
PerfectLuck25367•

My reccomendations are:

  1. Go to r/Gamedesign and post the same questions, if you haveny already.

  2. Before you try anything else, split your game into elements (An element for crafting, an element for clan- and family management, and so on) and try to figure these things out as individual mechanics before putting them together into a big game. This way, you'll be sure that each mechanic is usable and entertaining in its own right, and don't end up as "That thing you have to do between turns".

  3. As often as possible, playtest and let other people (friends or family) playtest your game. Even if the game is for your own personal use, you will stare yourself blind at the finiky details. It's reffeshing to get some insight from the outside.

  4. Don't stress it. I get the feeling that you've got allot of balls in the air with this project, and that might make you burn out. Let it take time, because it will take time. Assume that each element of the game will take about twice as much time as you expect it to.

  5. Learn Excell or Google Sheets. Working in a spreadaheet manager while designing your mechanics allows for massive data analysis in a whole new way, and I've even started using sharable, interconnectable Google Sheets documents to play some campaigns I have going. With that, you may eventually want to learn C#, Microsoft Access, or Javascript, but that's not necessary to grasp immediately as you start to work in a spreadaheet platform.

Finally, I'd reccoment looking into known games of a similar nature, analysing their elements, scavenge them clean, and then apply your game on top of those base mechanics. There's a reason why so many classic-style RPG's separate character attributes into generalized Abilities (like strength and intelligence) and specified Skills (like specific knowledges, languages, crafts or professional skills). With some analysis of existing games, you might find there are mechanics here, in RPG's or in other genres and on other platforms, that you could borrow from to enhance your game.

P.s. Sorry if all of this was "well duh" information, but I hope at least someone who reads this gets some joy out of it. Hapoy Gaming!

3
ShuffKorbik•

Are you sure they're unheard of in your country? You might be surprised.

3
PriyonOP•

Thank you for replying. I agree with you, but the only two groups I found that play tabletop RPGs, consisted of around 15 people each. Both almost a thousand miles from me. There is a large group as well, also very far away.

There are certainly lot more players than that, but they are thoroughly scattered where I live. We unfortunately don't have RPG and tabletop libraries, and RPGs are not sold in shops either, so only people with internet (and time and money to spend on a long series of Amazon purchases) have access to the concept.

2
jamesja12Publisher - Stormforge West•

Have you looked into the quiet year? I would highly suggest doing so.

3
PriyonOP•

Thank you, I will take a look into that right away.

2
Sir_CrownRising Realms Rpg - Genoma Rpg•

I like your idea and premise but..

The aim of the game is to live out a usual, boring human life.

Why? Every story, game and piece of narration in general is fueled by conflict. I'm not necessarely referring to physical combat (altough many rpgs feature this as the main conflict resolution). Would you read a book where the protagonist lives a normal, boring day-to-day life? I dont' think so. The same goes for an rpg.

3
soapoperaist•

And of course there is also conflict in "usual, boring" human lives!

1
PriyonOP•

Hey, thanks for replying. My personal experience is that even games revolving around mundane lifestyle can be made very enjoyable. Provided the player is up to the antics, that is.

As for the story, I was not intending for one originally. The game is to be made and run like a simulation. The plan is to use the system from this game into my future planned games which will actually have stories and lore. :)

1

Unless you’re living alone on a remote island without Internet, all you really need to start a gaming group is

(A) a bunch of friends you can rope into this, a big enough table, paper, pens, dice

(B) a working Internet account with access to sites like roll20.com

Nothing against your plan to write an RPG, that’s totally cool.

It’s just that writing an RPG without ever having played one is kinda like a nun writing an erotic novel. It’s all coming from your imagination, but it’s not coming from real experience...

So next time you are hanging out with your friends, just rope them into playing one of those games and start one.

In fact, look at r/lfg, you might be surprised about how gamers are in the most remote of places. I’ve gamed with people from places such as Lahore, Pakistan and Ljubljana, Slovenia. So I call BS on the theory that there are no gamers around you. Maybe you just haven’t looked hard enough?

With a few games played, you’ll have a much better idea about how to build your own game.

EDIT: Not sure which city you’re in, but search for groups like this:

https://www.meetup.com/tabletopindia/

2
4thWorlder•

Discord voice and post chat app is an excellent way to join one time or campaigns although time zones may have to take time to figure out. A way to play and survey while you continue development. Ask around D&D sub Reddit for invite links. Mythic has a GM-less emulator that supplements different rpgs

1