Germany demands answers from Facebook over data breach
dw.com/en/germany-demands-answers-from-facebo...Posted Mar 25, 2018, 7:34 PM UTC
Posted Mar 25, 2018, 7:34 PM UTC
Germany or any other country with respect to this matter will get nothing but deliberately misleading press releases and false promises. No government has the power to enforce the law over big multinational companies (especially if they're American).
I started to think that politicians do this kind of demands just to save their faces in front of the public.
The law that gets applied in everyday life and courts gets interpreted differently at higher levels, and its meaning and objectives are really watered down so much by then.
Source? Use Google and see the endless list of law-breaking corporations that ALWAYS get away with what they do. The Wall Street cartels for example brought the world to its knees back in 2008 and yet nobody even went to jail over what happend.
Take the arms companies and the terror they imposed on people in the middle east and elsewhere --> Again, nobody dares to ask a question let alone start a trial.
I could keep going on till tomorrow and I won't be done. I am pretty damn sure at this moment that the world is heading toward a big oligarchic system and honest to god, I only see hope in the EU and believe that it's humanity's last shield against the craziness taking place in this world.
Let’s just block Facebook in Germany.
Personally I think this is a great idea. Block facebook for a day and replace it with a message "Facebook is temporarely blocked since it doesn't respect your european rights"
One needs to make sure that facebook can't spin it in a way that makes the EU law look bad.
YouTube does it with the german GEMA. The GEMA wants get money from broadcasters to the artists. Basically, if you play music you should give money appropriately. Sadly, paying GEMA for music videos isn't so profitable for YouTube. Thus, YouTube replaced all videos containing licensed music with a message similar to "please blame GEMA for the unavailability"
That's no longer the case (they did finally come to some agreement). Nevertheless, despite YouTube paying peanuts, the way GEMA works makes it only profitable for pop-stars and established artists (i.e. artists with a lot of sales) while the rest ends up paying more than they get while at the same time giving up part of their rights (in regards to collecting fees for their music). Let alone that GEMA works on the assumption that they represent every single artist and may try to collect fees even for works they don't have any rights to. Nowadays there's no motivation to join GEMA as an artist unless you've already become successful.
GEMA
good idea ; bad execution
[removed]
Please don't. I hate Facebook as much as the next guy and I don't use it at all but that can't be the answer.
Time for a good 'ol ^^face book burning...
I would rather ban German Government data collecting than Facebook.
German Government data collecting? What do you mean? What are you referring to?
All Germans should demand clarification from the government and local registration offices as to under what 'data protection' law is it allowed for GEZ- ARD/ZDF and their bitches to get the addresses of those registered in a particular city.
information privacy level ZERO
refer to this post of mine.
interesting user name
Well if our european constitutions are not overthrown by saria law or we maintain our freedom of speech and enhance our democratic values, we will be the beacon of hope in a very dark future. We have problems but if we manage to find unity and good poloticians, we can hope for a brighter future
Germany throws a tantrum, but not too loudly so our American friends still like us.
Facebook proceeds as usual. You'll be able to tell by 2019Q1 earnings reports.
Let's just wait for the "General Data Protection Regulation" to kick in maybe that will give citizens more power if somehow the EU manages to enforce it.
Here some important parts:
- The right of access is a data subject right. That gives citizens the right to get access to their personal data and information about how this personal data is being processed. A data controller must provide, upon request, an overview of the categories of data that are being processed as well as a copy of the actual data. Furthermore, the data controller has to inform the data subject on details about the processing such as the purposes of the processing with whom the data is shared and how it acquired the data.
- A right to be forgotten was replaced by a more limited right to erasure in the version of the GDPR that was adopted by the European Parliament in March 2014. Article 17 provides that the data subject has the right to request erasure of personal data related to them on any one of a number of grounds, including noncompliance with Article 6.1 (lawfulness) that includes a case (f) if the legitimate interests of the controller is overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject, which require protection of personal data. Data portability
- (...) a fine up to €10 million or up to 2% of the annual worldwide turnover of the preceding financial year in case of an enterprise, whichever is greater (...)
GDPR will be great. I'm looking forward to it :)
Good luck. They'll just give you some corporate answer with no substance at this point.
To get any answers from Facebook you must get them where it matters - their money. Facebook is just another American corporation at this point looking to make coins and not caring about morals. Making them feel guilty or asking for answers won't do anything. Their money comes from their users' information - so I recommend not giving them any more data via using FB.
If you are an Android user, they have all your phone calls and texts if you have used the FB app. You can see this info in the zip file when you download your Facebook data: https://www.facebook.com/help/131112897028467
You all agreed to the data sharing when you signed up, didn’t read the terms of service ? Who’s fault is that?
It’s the same how ever foreigner gets slated on this sub for not reading the details of german contracts.
All Germans should demand clarification from the government and local registration offices as to under what 'data protection' law is it allowed for GEZ- ARD/ZDF and their bitches to get the addresses of those registered in a particular city.
information privacy level ZERO
All EU citizens should also demand answers from the Irish Data Protection commissioner. The previous one ignored all complaints and requests about Facebook etc. for years without legal consequences.
Ireland is a terrible member of the EU. They take all the benefits and give companies a safe haven to do whatever the fuck they want.
At least the previous commissioner behaved as if being in that position was just a continuation of his previous job. His only concern was to promote job creation in Ireland. The Schrems vs. Facebook case made is blatantly obvious.
I don't know how the current commissioner is. I hope she's doing her job.