r/Amd•
mkrmec

Liquid metal and a FX8350

Discussion

Hello

Some time ago I used a Coollaboratory Liquid Ultra LM thermal paste on my CPU. My CPU was lapped completely flat up to 7000 grit. It was a mirror finish. My cooler is a NH-D14, which already has a very nice smooth Nickel finish on the cooling plate.

So yesterday I took my PC apart to test some watercooling parts I got to see how they fit. I twisted the cooler so that the CPU and cooler separated. The bond was so high I couldn't do it, fearing for the motherboard and CPU. Then I opened the latch as far as it would go and pulled the CPU out still attached to the cooler. Not ideal, I know. This happened to me once before with Noctuas thermal paste.

After that, I couldn't get the CPU off the cooler at all! I tried twisting, making a twisting jig out of wood so I don't damage the pins. It didn't budge at all. After that I took a metal guitar pick from my prying tools, I ground it to less than a millimeter on one side with sandpaper, to make a tiny wedge.

I aligned the metal pick on the corner of the CPU, between the CPU and cooler and smacked it one time lightly with a small hammer, and not expecting it, they broke apart in one go. CPU falling to the ground, bending many pins and breaking ONE pin clean off!

Panic!

I bent all the pins back with precision and care, to not break more off, after 40 min, my head really hurt because I was focusing a lot on such small pins. Finally it popped into the socket no problem. Only one thing left to fix now, the broken pin.

I saw someone soldering pins back to CPUs on YouTube some time ago, and I knew that I had no choice. Either do this, or buy a new CPU (no money for a "new" CPU). I found a older AMD CPU in my collection, a AMD Athlon 64, which had the same size of pins as the FX, desoldered a few of them and practiced resoldering them back on without any tweezers, because I couldn't find them at all?! To say that was hard and randomly successful was an overstatement, plus as if that wasn't enough, my soldering iron has a big tip, definitely not for microsoldring.

After I done practicing, I tried it for real on the FX CPU. I used the best flux I had to clean off the broken pin. I applied the same flux to the spot again, and to the tip of the iron to clean it off nicely, I applied new solder on the tip, picked up the very small pin, placed it on the spot on the CPU, and it snapped into place on its own on the first try!! I cleaned the flux off with acetone and it was as good as "new".

Relief!

So the interesting part now ;-) the CPU IHS and the cooler plate were really rough and I couldn't remove the liquid metal thermal paste / marks on the surface with acetone or alcohol. It seems that the LM got bonded with the copper and nickel! I thought copper and nickel were fine with liquid metal thermal pastes, it seems it not that simple. The LM didn't destroy the material like it would aluminum/aluminium, but it certainly did damage to the surfaces. Maybe the mistake was, using copper on one side and nickel on the other. Maybe copper to copper would be ok, I just don't know.

I lapped the CPU and cooler again to 7000 grit, it took quite a bit of work to remove all the LM paste. The whole CPU was not copper colored when I started, after I ground off some material the copper started comming out slowly. It seems that the LM somehow seeped into the copper, or some like that. As for the cooler, I couldn't tell, since the LM and nickel are the same color. After I lapped both surfaces to 7000 grit, they were again reflecting like a mirror.

I put the PC together again, using the ThermalGrizzly Cryonaut TIM this time, and IT WORKED!! I was so happy I didn't break my stuff :-)

If you had a similar problem or no problems using LM, please, let me know your opinion on this subject.

Thanks for your time :-)

PS: sorry no pictures, was too hyped to even think of taking a pictures, I'm kinda mad at myself for that at the moment.

Edit: some grammar fixes

Posted Mar 25, 2018, 9:20 PM UTC · edited

2532
Loading comments…