Will the new online MTG game slowly kill MTGO?

GENERAL

The new game looks to be a combination of hearth stone and MTGO, but also looks to be where they're going to focus most of their online efforts. Is now the time to dump my mtgo cards? At worst, park my cards into tickets and. Buy back in in a couple years after the market is done tanking?

Posted Mar 27, 2018, 1:28 AM UTC

1315
MTGsubredditor•

I expect it will be noob crap, same as Duels.

In a few years Wizards will can it, same as Duels.

MTGO is the dumpster that contains Hell itself and can never be extinguished.

24
IronCookuru•

With the current free to play economy the game is using? Not a chance.

If Wizards pulls their head out of their asses and puts a system in place that lets players get cards at a reasonable rate? Absolutely.

12
waaaghbosss•

Isn't it trying to monetize like hearthstone? Freer packs, but to get the cards you need you'll eventually buy packs? Plus you aren't allowed to trade cards high is insane.

3
IronCookuru•

They really botched things by not having a dust system and giving you fewer packs than Hearthstone, despite the fact that if they used Hearthstone’s exact economic model it would take 3 times as many packs to build a tier 1 deck. Their big idea was “you don’t need dust because we’re going to give you free cards for every game you win” but it turns out that no one gives a shit if you give them a shitty card that they’re then forced to keep forever. They basically throw a bunch of stuff at you to distract from the fact that they aren’t giving you anything you want or need. If someone gave you a Cancel for winning a game at FNM you’d leave it on the table.

7
ToadBrews•

"If someone gave you a cancel for winning a game at FNM you'd leave it on the table."
This sums up my feelings on the garbage reward system of this game perfectly.

5
IronCookuru•

I’ve been using that example around because I think people look at it like “I could get that Scarab God if I just win one more game!” but theu’re just going to get another cancel. If there was dust like Hearthstone, 10 dust is only 1/160 of a Scarab God, but it’s 1/160 closer than a Cancel gets you.

1
waaaghbosss•

Interesting, I read the faq on the game and saw the mystery card thing, but wasnt fully aware of how it works.

I guess, to play devil's advocate, the game is still in beta, and they may fix this archaic system. I signed up for the beta but still waiting to see if I get in :)

2
IronCookuru•

They said they’re making some changes because feedback to the latest iteration was not good. Basically, before the latest patch, people were saying what you were “oh, maybe they’ll make it better, they said they’re updating it in the next patch” and they actually just made it harder to get wild cards and everyone lost their damn minds.

One of the devs was going to do an AMA and he cancelled it for “health reasons” (he thought getting roasted that much would be unhealthy, I guess) and they posted saying “well, there’s event prizes guys, calm down, we’ll fix it”.

2
Cmonman887•

More like, it's like Hearthstone because 1) they're able to disassociate card values from real money (because there's no secondary market, going to be very important if loot box laws take off), and 2) so all transactions go through them, rather than having to rely on hush hush bots and traders which all technically violate their TOS but they can't really shut off without making the economy worse.

The Hearthstone economy benefits WotC a lot more than the current MTGO economy because they get a piece of every transaction. Even if they give some stuff away for free it's a whole lot more profitable. That's one of the main draws for Arena for them and why they will be pushing it come hell or high water.

2
scarmask•

I sold out recently. Arena is just one of many reasons.

I don't have enough confidence in wizards to leave hundreds of dollars in their hands at the moment.

5
KangaMagic•

Wizards just released their economy goals for Arena today. Their goal is to be slightly more stingy than Hearthstone. There's no need to sell your mtgo collection out of fear.

5
Cmonman887•

A year ago was the time to dump your MTGO cards but luckily Magic players are pretty slow on the uptake so you still have time now.

There is a 100% chance that Arena will be pushed to replace MTGO, they have completely stopped improvements on MTGO and are simply maintaining it until Arena can take its place. It's a huge albatross for them and requires them to keep a (bad) digital team in place when they've already proven they have no ability to create or maintain software.

MTGO is living on fumes.

5
mnemosyne-0002•

Archives for this post:


I am Mnemosyne 2.1, Actually, it's about ethics in governing. ^^^^/r/botsrights ^^^^Contribute ^^^^message ^^^^me ^^^^suggestions ^^^^at ^^^^any ^^^^time ^^^^Opt ^^^^out ^^^^of ^^^^tracking ^^^^by ^^^^messaging ^^^^me ^^^^"Opt ^^^^Out" ^^^^at ^^^^any ^^^^time

2
DLJeff•

If and when Arena implements drafting, it will be more of a threat to classic MTGO. If you're drafting a lot on MTGO, or playing Modern, Legacy or even Pauper, then Arena is not going to cannibalize that in the immediate future. You have to evaluate for yourself based on: How much is your MTGO collection worth in actual cash, and do you actually get enjoyment out of playing MTGO events with your collection. If you have a Modern deck on MTGO and love playing Leagues with it... it would kind of suck to sell out and not be able to play anymore because you're unsure of how Arena will impact your value.

2
taazaj•

People have been trying to rip off Hearthstone and failing miserably for years. This is like Wizards 3rd attempt, and it will fail too.

1