3.2 Meta Shift Report — I hope you like tables!
EDIT: Great news! u/rasmuskl has shown me how to download all the data from http://poe.ninja/builds, and I've now got it into a format I can work with! There's almost no limit to what I can do with this. Stay tuned.
There's a summary at the bottom!
I thought it would be cool to use the shiny new http://poe.ninja/builds data to look at some of the differences between the Abyss and Bestiary metas, and to dig deeper into the effects of the ascendancy rebalance. GGG somewhat beat me to it with yesterday's news post, but I'm going to go into a lot more detail here.
Raw data and all tables are available as an Excel spreadsheet here. The data used for everything below are the temp league softcore characters indexed by poe.ninja (used with permission — thank you u/rasmuskl!). This means that this can't tell us anything about hardcore, and is skewed towards only the most dedicated players - only characters level 91ish and higher are indexed. Unfortunately, unless you're GGG this is the best data set we have. Finally, because http://poe.ninja/builds only launched at the very end of Abyss league, the datasets were not collected at the same point in the league. This will mess with a few things (e.g. the abundance of expensive unique items), but the comparison still seems mostly valid. If I do this again in future, I'll be sure to record data at the same point in each league. Also, I apologise if there are any mistakes anywhere in this. It's mostly just a bit of fun and I didn't want to commit too much time to it.
Ascendancy Breakdown
GGG already covered this in yesterday's news, so I'm not really going to comment other than to say that diversity of ascendancy class picks has definitely increased overall, and to point out that Berserker has even less representation at level 90+ than at 70+.
| Ascendancy | Abyss % | Bestiary % | Diff ↓ | Fold Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Juggernaut | 2 | 15 | +13 | 7.50 |
| Deadeye | 0.2 | 10 | +10 | 50.00 |
| Hierophant | 0.2 | 8 | +8 | 40.00 |
| Champion | 1 | 7 | +6 | 7.00 |
| Saboteur | 2 | 5 | +3 | 2.50 |
| Chieftain | 0.7 | 3 | +2 | 4.29 |
| Occultist | 0.8 | 3 | +2 | 3.75 |
| Trickster | 2 | 4 | +2 | 2.00 |
| Elementalist | 0.5 | 2 | +2 | 4.00 |
| Ascendant | 5 | 6 | +1 | 1.20 |
| Assassin | 2 | 2 | 0 | 1.00 |
| Guardian | 5 | 4 | -1 | 0.80 |
| Berserker | 4 | 0.1 | -4 | 0.03 |
| Pathfinder | 8 | 4 | -4 | 0.50 |
| Gladiator | 6 | 2 | -4 | 0.33 |
| Necromancer | 16 | 9 | -7 | 0.56 |
| Inquisitor | 11 | 4 | -7 | 0.36 |
| Raider | 16 | 6 | -10 | 0.38 |
| Slayer | 17 | 6 | -11 | 0.35 |
Ascendancy Passive Diversity
One of the other stated goals of the ascendancy rework was to give every node within the ascendancy trees a purpose. For the most part this seems to have been successful, and I'm not going to talk about every class because that's boring. Rather, I'm just going to highlight a few, mostly the failures. If you want to see the rest, they're in the Excel sheet linked above.
| Hierophant | % taken |
|---|---|
| Pursuit of Faith | 99 |
| Ritual of Awakening | 99 |
| Conviction of Power | 85 |
| Divine Guidance | 74 |
| Illuminated Devotion | 26 |
| Sanctuary of Thought | 10 |
| Arcane Blessing | 5 |
It seems like people are only picking Hierophant for totem builds, and it's interesting to speculate why. Is this just because most self-cast spells are weak at the moment? Is it because level 1 Arcange Surge is not enticing compared to the possibility of getting a higher level one from the support gem? Is Hierophant just not as obvious or enticing for selfcast builds compared to other ascendancies?
| Saboteur | % taken |
|---|---|
| Bomb Specialist | 97 |
| Pyromaniac | 85 |
| Demolitions Specialist | 85 |
| Explosives Expert | 59 |
| Born in the Shadows | 58 |
| Perfect Crime | 3 |
| Chain Reaction | 3 |
I think we can generally agree that this has more to do with traps themselves than anything about the nodes. People really don't want to play trappers anymore.
| Pathfinder | % taken |
|---|---|
| Nature's Boon | 100 |
| Master Alchemist | 100 |
| Nature's Adrenaline | 99 |
| Veteran Bowyer | 96 |
| Master Surgeon | 3 |
| Master Herbalist | 1 |
Probably not too surprising as these nodes are conspicuously weak. Master Surgeon has felt a bit pointless ever since it got shackled with a cooldown, and Master Herbalist isn't ever going to tempt poison builds away from the far stronger Assassin.
| Raider | % taken |
|---|---|
| Way of the Poacher | 98 |
| Avatar of the Slaughter | 97 |
| Rapid Assault | 53 |
| Avatar of the Chase | 52 |
| Quartz Infusion | 50 |
| Avatar of the Veil | 49 |
Just pointing this out because it's cool. Accepted wisdom pre-3.2 was that Avatar of the Chase sucked and no build should ever take it. The changes have now made people split right down the middle between the two secondary paths. A big success from quite a small adjustment.
| Inquisitor | % taken |
|---|---|
| Righteous Providence | 97 |
| Inevitable Judgement | 96 |
| Instruments of Virtue | 94 |
| Augury of Penitence | 91 |
| Sanctify | 10 |
| Pious Path | 8 |
No matter how strong the effects are (and they're insane by the way), it's a hard sell to convince people to stand still.
| Slayer | % taken |
|---|---|
| Headsman | 100 |
| Bane of Legends | 96 |
| Endless Hunger | 96 |
| Brutal Fervour | 96 |
| Impact | 5 |
| Overwhelm | 3 |
Probably the biggest failure in this category. Reshuffling Slayer's passives was presumably intended to force players to make more choices about which nodes to take, but it's actually done the opposite. All that's happened now is that builds that wanted to take Impact have crashed in popularity, and builds that didn't take it barely notice the difference. Overwhelm is still pointless.
| Ascendant | % taken |
|---|---|
| Slayer | 41 |
| Raider | 31 |
| Guardian | 28 |
| Necromancer | 28 |
| Path of the Duelist | 26 |
| Path of the Witch | 24 |
| Path of the Ranger | 19 |
| Elementalist | 14 |
| Assassin | 13 |
| Path of the Templar | 12 |
| Path of the Shadow | 11 |
| Inquisitor | 10 |
| Deadeye | 9 |
| Juggernaut | 7 |
| Pathfinder | 4 |
| Path of the Marauder | 4 |
| Chieftain | 3 |
| Trickster | 3 |
| Hierophant | 2 |
| Saboteur | 2 |
| Champion | 2 |
| Occultist | 1 |
| Berserker | 0.1 |
| Gladiator | 0.1 |
The sweeping changes to Ascendant definitely brought new life to the class, even though its overall popularity hasn't changed much. Almost all the mini ascendancies are seeing some degree of use. Just a couple look like they're in need of further tweaking.
Primary Damage Skills
First let's look at overall percentages, then we'll take a bit of a look at what's happening for each ascendancy. "Rank" here is based on popularity alone, i.e. rank 1 means the skill used by the largest number of characters. This is also use poe.ninja's criterion of only counting 5- and 6-linked skills, which is imperfect but as good as you can feasibly get. Only skills with total usage >1% are ranked on this list.
| Skill | Abyss Rank | Bestiary Rank ↓ | Rank Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barrage | 1 | 1 | 0 |
| Raise Spectre | 2 | 2 | 0 |
| Glacial Cascade | 15 | 3 | +12 |
| Tornado Shot | 4 | 4 | 0 |
| Cyclone | 3 | 5 | -2 |
| Reave | 16 | 6 | +10 |
| Molten Strike | 5 | 7 | -2 |
| Blade Flurry | 6 | 8 | -2 |
| Scorching Ray | 13 | 9 | +4 |
| Ancestral Warchief | 8 | 10 | -2 |
| Righteous Fire | 10 | 11 | -1 |
| Sunder | 7 | 12 | -5 |
| Frost Blades | 11 | 13 | -2 |
| Essence Drain | 17 | 14 | +3 |
| Blight | 22 | 15 | +7 |
| Kinetic Blast | 12 | 16 | -4 |
| Molten Burst | 14 | 17 | -3 |
| Ice Shot | 21 | 18 | +3 |
| Cleave | Unranked | 19 | New |
| Frostbolt | Unranked | 20 | New |
| Dark Pact | Unranked | 21 | New |
| Summon Flame Golem | 18 | 22 | -4 |
| Summon Skeleton | Unranked | 23 | New |
| Tectonic Slam | Unranked | 24 | New |
| Lightning Arrow | 20 | 25 | -5 |
| Spectral Throw | 19 | 26 | -7 |
| Blade Vortex | Unranked | 27 | New |
| Ethereal Knives | 9 | Unranked | Gone |
| Flicker Strike | 23 | Unranked | Gone |
| Summon Raging Spirit | 24 | Unranked | Gone |
Or, if you'd rather sort by change in rank:
| Skills | Rank Change |
|---|---|
| Glacial Cascade | +12 |
| Reave | +10 |
| Blight | +7 |
| Scorching Ray | +4 |
| Essence Drain | +3 |
| Ice Shot | +3 |
| Barrage | 0 |
| Raise Spectre | 0 |
| Tornado Shot | 0 |
| Righteous Fire | -1 |
| Cyclone | -2 |
| Molten Strike | -2 |
| Blade Flurry | -2 |
| Ancestral Warchief | -2 |
| Frost Blades | -2 |
| Molten Burst | -3 |
| Kinetic Blast | -4 |
| Summon Flame Golem | -4 |
| Sunder | -5 |
| Lightning Arrow | -5 |
| Spectral Throw | -7 |
| Cleave | New |
| Frostbolt | New |
| Dark Pact | New |
| Summon Skeleton | New |
| Tectonic Slam | New |
| Blade Vortex | New |
| Ethereal Knives | Gone |
| Flicker Strike | Gone |
| Summon Raging Spirit | Gone |
The top ranks aren't really a great surprise, are they? All the usual strong contenders. Glacial Cascade was already a popular choice for Saboteurs (more on that later), but it's also one of the top contenders for totem builds so new Hierophant has given it a huge boost. Reave is presumably mostly benefitting from the intense popularity surge of Juggernaut and Champion builds. Most of the skills that lost ground seem to just be making way for the latest FotM rather than being any worse, with the notable exceptions of Flicker Strike (rip Slayer) and Ethereal Knives (which is still really good guys! That Lightpoacher "nerf" wasn't actually a nerf for EK builds!).
I think you can go either way with this. On the one hand, 3.2 had almost no skill balance changes, so it's nice to see this degree of movement. On the other, maybe you were hoping for the ascendancy rebalance to make more skills viable, and in practice it seems like Summon Skeleton is the only skill that's really gone from zero to hero thanks to the ascendancy changes.
Finally, the new skills have landed with a quiet plop. Tectonic Strike barely makes it onto the ladder, and SST is...yeah. Buff time in 3.3?
Skill Diversity by Ascendancy
| Ascendancy | Number of Skills >5% Usage ↓ | % Usage of Most Popular Skill | Most Popular Skill |
|---|---|---|---|
| Juggernaut | 10 | 17 | Righteous Fire |
| Trickster | 7 | 38 | Essence Drain |
| Hierophant | 6 | 30 | Glacial Cascade |
| Assassin | 6 | 29 | Herald of Thunder |
| Berserker | 6 | 38 | Ancestral Warchief |
| Raider | 6 | 28 | Tornado Shot |
| Slayer | 6 | 57 | Cyclone |
| Deadeye | 5 | 56 | Barrage |
| Chieftain | 5 | 34 | Cyclone |
| Ascendant | 5 | 13 | Molten Strike |
| Pathfinder | 5 | 54 | Barrage |
| Gladiator | 5 | 35 | Sunder |
| Necromancer | 5 | 72 | Raise Spectre |
| Champion | 4 | 39 | Reave |
| Occultist | 3 | 46 | Blight |
| Elementalist | 3 | 48 | Summon Flame Golem |
| Inquisitor | 3 | 39 | Molten Strike |
| Guardian | 2 | 56 | Scorching Ray |
| Saboteur | 1 | 90 | Glacial Cascade |
Again, not many big surprises here. The two monsters in the room are Raise Spectre (which I think just about everyone was surprised didn't see nerfs in 3.2), and GC mines (ditto). Both are dominating their class, although at least Necromancer has a lot of variety among spectres and plenty more builds hidden in the wings. Elementalist is not quite as golem-heavy as many people expected — there are a lot of people playing shock builds out there — but it still seems a bit odd that a class new players gravitate towards as a caster is mostly being used as a summoner. Chieftain has soaked up all the Ngamahu players. And finally, Assassin's poison nodes may have gotten huge buffs, but (probably due to poison's general awkwardness right now) Autobomber is still the most popular single build for the class.
By the way, if you expected Scion to be at the top of this list, you'd probably be right. That's actually a flaw in my methodology. Scion has so many good skills that not many of them hit the 5% threshold required for inclusion. I'll probably lower that to 1% in future.
Unique Item Popularity
I'm just going to present the movers and shakers here. If you want the full list of ranks for each league, check out the Excel file linked above. Only items used by >5% of characters are ranked here.
| Item | Rank Change |
|---|---|
| Essence Worm | +20 |
| Witchfire Brew | +13 |
| Kaom's Roots | +13 |
| Kaom's Heart | +11 |
| Starkonja's Head | +8 |
| Brightbeak | +7 |
| Sin Trek | +7 |
| Tombfist | +5 |
| Goldwyrm | +5 |
| Lion's Roar | +4 |
| The Wise Oak | +4 |
| Sadima's Touch | +4 |
| Queen of the Forest | +3 |
| Wildfire | +3 |
| Lioneye's Fall | +2 |
| Windripper | +2 |
| Atziri's Promise | 0 |
| Belly of the Beast | 0 |
| Devoto's Devotion | 0 |
| Rat's Nest | 0 |
| Bones of Ullr | -1 |
| Watcher's Eye | -4 |
| Ventor's Gamble | -4 |
| Vis Mortis | -4 |
| Taste of Hate | -5 |
| Lycosidae | -5 |
| Rumi's Concoction | -6 |
| Shavronne's Wrappings | -6 |
| Bisco's Collar | -15 |
| Dying Sun | -15 |
| Vessel of Vinktar | -16 |
| Abyssus | New |
| Belt of the Deceiver | New |
| Clear Mind | New |
| Bisco's Leash | New |
| Doryani's Catalyst | New |
| Lightpoacher | Gone |
| Darkness Enthroned | Gone |
| Headhunter | Gone |
| Prism Guardian | Gone |
| Presence of Chayula | Gone |
| Conqueror's Potency | Gone |
| The Scourge | Gone |
| Unending Hunger | Gone |
| Energy from Within | Gone |
| Inspired Learning | Gone |
| Alpha's Howl | Gone |
| Conqueror's Efficiency | Gone |
| Shaper's Touch | Gone |
| Carnage Heart | Gone |
In four words: MoMs, Juggs and Rippers. These data are best analysed by pairing them with skills and classes, but that would take an age and I am not at all keen to do so. Mostly presented here for curiosity's sake.
Summary
-
The ascendancy rework appears to have mostly succeeded at giving players a reason to pick every ascendancy. A couple seem in need of further tweaking.
-
Within each ascendancy, some nodes are still mostly ignored. This is particularly a problem when an ascendancy is only used for a single build archetype. However, again it seems like the vast majority of ascendancy nodes now have genuine uses. Another success.
-
In terms of actual builds, the meta hasn't shifted very heavily. The top skills are pretty much unchanged from last league. A lot of skills are being used by different ascendancies compared to pre-3.2, or have received straight buffs, but the builds are mostly the same otherwise. The new skills have fallen flat.
I hope you've found this at least mildly interesting, and please let me know if there are any mistakes, glaring omissions, and/or things you'd be interested in seeing next time (if there is a next time).
Posted Mar 27, 2018, 2:25 AM UTC · edited