Tactical_Sandwich•

An "Assault Weapon" isn't a real thing. It's a made up term by people with no understanding of firearms.

Read the bill language here http://www.oregonfirearms.org/gun-confiscation-ballot-measure-filed-read

Under this proposed bill almost every firearm would be classified as an "assault weapon" and would require surrender, sale, or transfer out of state within 120 days of passing the bill or you would be a felon.

"Assault weapon" is classified as any semi-automatic rifle with a detachable magazine and at least one of the following:

  • Any grip of the weapon, including a pistol grip, thumbhole stock, or any other stock, the use of which would allow the individual to grip the weapon, resulting in any finger on the trigger hand in addition to the trigger finger being directly below any portion of the action of the weapon when firing" - Oh, you mean a means of holding the firearm? This is describing all rifles
  • any feature capable of functioning as a protruding grip - all rifles
  • A folding or telescoping stock
  • A shroud attached to the barrel, or that partially or completely encircles the barrel, allowing the bearer to hold the firearm with the non-trigger hand without being burned, but excluding the slide that encloses the barrel; - This is describing a stock. This is all rifles again
  • a forward pistol grip
  • a flash suppressor, muzzle brake, muzzle compensator, or threaded barrel designed to accomodate a flash suppressor, muzzle brake, or muzzle compensator - all modern sporting rifles have flash suppressors or compensators. Threaded barrels as described do not exist
  • A bayonet mount or grenade or flare launcher - Never in my life have I met someone with one of these

The list goes on and on to classify handguns and shotguns as well. It's scary how it pretty much defines all kinds of firearms. in one way or another. This bill proposal even goes so far as to say that anyone who legally purchased or obtained a firearm classified as an 'assault weapon' under this bill would need to surrender that firearm within 120 days of the bill passing. It's not just that they would be unobtainable for future purchase, it's that you would be required to surrender them. This would make felons of hundreds of thousands of law abiding Oregonians and be very bad news for the state.

Statistically, places with tighter and more restrictive gun control laws have higher crime rates of all varieties. The attempted removal of firearms from Oregon is nothing but a hateful attack on the citizens' rights and the 2nd amendment by those who know nothing about firearms or facts.

The only assault weapon here is the proposed legislation.

25
2018Eugene•

Surrender or register them. Fuck this bill though.

5
Tactical_Sandwich•

haha yeah, that'll go over real well

6
tedted8888•

Oh and neener neener neener, section 9 says fuck your constitution

4
whslaxattack•

Oh boy, you thought the compliance on private transfers was low? You ain't seen nothin'

4
SumoSizeItPortland/Gorge/Seaside/Madras•

An "Assault Weapon" isn't a real thing. It's a made up term by people with no understanding of firearms.

As much as I hate the term and its scare tactics, it means whatever it becomes legally defined to mean. A bill could define a chicken as a duck because it has wings and feathers, and it would be legally known as such even if we colloquially knew better.

In this context, the initiative defines what an assault weapon is, so it becomes a real thing, legally.

3
Tactical_Sandwich•

If that's the case then we should start a petition to have vehicles re termed as high velocity human colliders

8
SumoSizeItPortland/Gorge/Seaside/Madras•

If the High Mobility Multipurpose Wheeled Vehicle (HMMWV) became the Humvee, and General/Government Purpose (GP) became Jeep, what would an HVHC come to be known as?

3
etherbunniesOnce Defeated a Ninja•

The Bad Analogy (tm.)

1

Hook us up with those stats on a higher crime rate with gun control. I need some ammo, as it were.

2

25% of all gun crimes happen in 4 cities in the US. All of which are under Democratic control with very strict gun laws.

9
Tactical_Sandwich•

Here's the investment of about 30 seconds of my time. You can keep digging and find lots more if you want to spend some time doing it. https://www.dailywire.com/news/7872/7-facts-gun-crime-show-gun-control-doesnt-work-aaron-bandler

3
arakboss•

An "assault weapon" will be a real thing if Initiative 43 makes it on the ballot and voters pass it. The intentions of the people/petitioners was to cover a much larger group of weapons as historically many mass shootings have been aided by handguns and shotguns. Semiauto guns are the worst offenders hence they are the target of this initiative. If this proposed law is successful then the people can work on ammunition restrictions.

1
Tactical_Sandwich•

Firearms save lives. The statistic is hard to pin down but in something like 99% (dont quote me on this) of all reported instances where a defensive weapon is drawn, simply the show of it is enough to diffuse the situation and avoid injury/death. Statistically speaking, places with stricter gun control laws have higher crime rates because there is no threat of consequence. Firearms are the great equalizer in that they provide would-be victims with a means of protection.

Trying to ban firearms is like trying to ban airbags from cars just because sometimes people get hurt by airbags, in spite of airbags saving countless lives.

Speaking of airbags, more people die in car accidents than do by the total amount of people killed by firearms every year. More people die of obesity, heart disease, and many other forms of death. Firearm related deaths aren't even in the top 10 causes of death for the US.

There are 30,000 gun related deaths per year by firearms, and this number is not disputed. U.S. population 324,059,091 as of Wednesday, June 22, 2016. Do the math: 0.0925% of the population dies from gun related actions each year. Statistically speaking, this is insignificant! What is never told, however, is a breakdown of those 30,000 deaths, to put them in perspective as compared to other causes of death:
• 65% of those deaths are by suicide which would never be prevented by gun laws
• 15% are by law enforcement in the line of duty and justified
• 17% are through criminal activity, gang and drug related or mentally ill persons – gun violence
• 3% are accidental discharge deaths

So technically, "gun violence" is not 30,000 annually, but drops to 5,100. Still too many? Well, first, how are those deaths spanned across the nation? • 480 homicides (9.4%) were in Chicago • 344 homicides (6.7%) were in Baltimore • 333 homicides (6.5%) were in Detroit • 119 homicides (2.3%) were in Washington D.C. (a 54% increase over prior years)

So basically, 25% of all gun crime happens in just 4 cities. All 4 of those cities have strict gun laws, so it is not the lack of law that is the root cause.

This basically leaves 3,825 for the entire rest of the nation, or about 75 deaths per state. That is an average because some States have much higher rates than others.

8
PromptCritical725Oregon City (Portland is our suburb)•

If this proposed law is successful then the people can work on ammunition restrictions.

I imagine before the ink is even dry.

2
Catbone57•

Do they have any idea how many AR15s they are selling?

19
SumoSizeItPortland/Gorge/Seaside/Madras•

It would require current gun owners to do one of the following with applicable firearms or high-capacity magazines: register them with the state, sell them to a registered dealer, remove them from the state, render them inoperable or surrender them to law enforcement.

Don't forget the fun clause on the last page that bars anyone who registers their shit from purchasing more.

12
MrGreg•

Also, magazines don't have serial numbers.

8
arakboss•

Large capacity magazines will have to be registered regardless if they have a serial number or not. It will be up to the state police to set up the registration requirements for a large capacity magazine. Most likely the state police will utilize the existing network of ffl dealers to perform this function and under current law the state police can not charge more than $10 for this process but the ffl dealers can add charges to this service like they do for the transfer of firearms. You will only be able to register one large capacity magazine per owner.

2
MrGreg•

You will only be able to register one large capacity magazine per owner.

Does is say this in the measure? If it does, I missed that part.

3
arakboss•

See Section 5 (6) they used the word "purchase" rather than "register" which was likely intentional to confuse people. As far as Oregon State Police are concerned all requested background checks would look the same as a purchase to them. Also note that in most of the proposed law language it addresses assault weapons and large capacity magazines in the singular.

2
arakboss•

Are you referring to the langauge in Section 4 (6) "A registered owner of an assault weapon or large capacity magazine may not purchase additional assault weapons or large capacity magazines."

I believe "purchase" was used rather than "register" as it it seems less offensive. Either way it is the intentions of the people/petitioners that owners of an assault weapon and or large capacity magazine only be able to legally own one of each. If the initiative makes it on the ballot and voters pass it owners will have up to 120 days beyond Jan 1, 2019 to decide which assault weapon and which large capacity magazine they would like to register. Any other assault weapons and large capacity magazines will need to be dealt with in manner laid out in Section 4(3)

3
SumoSizeItPortland/Gorge/Seaside/Madras•

That’s the one. Doesn’t exactly present a strong incentive for registering. Threatening people with a felony for not handing over their shit seems like it would just drive those underground. A lot of people are going to suddenly remember that time they lost all their guns and accessories in a boating accident.

5
tedted8888•

Vote how u will I guess, but I'm tired of living in a state where left wing = good and right wing = bad. http://www.oregonlive.com/mapes/index.ssf/2015/09/attempt_to_recall_floyd_prozan.html

"Williams said in a letter to recall sponsor Patricia Duffy that her petition contained 8,209 valid signatures, which was short of the 8,415 required.  Duffy's campaign had turned in 10,027 signatures, but it's common for many to be rejected because they are duplicates or are not from a registered voter in the district. "

Right wing fails by a technicality, but I doubt a left wing idea will be as scrutinized.

11
SumoSizeItPortland/Gorge/Seaside/Madras•

You think that's bad, trying being an independent right in the middle.

You like guns and gay marriage?

You want strong personal freedoms and a strong social system?

Neither party wants anything to do with that.

21
tedted8888•

Hello fellow libertarian

10
SumoSizeItPortland/Gorge/Seaside/Madras•

Yes and no. Outside of the primaries, I register as an independent no party (forgot Independent is a party here). There are aspects of every party I identify with, but not enough to throw consistently throw full support behind.

There's also the wonderful association of crazies with third parties like libertarians and greens. I would love to see us move to a ranked voting system so "normal" people can transform these parties into truly competitive and relevant entities.

4
tedted8888•

I do agree libertarian party puts in absolute crazys for election lol. And yeah Gary Johnson over simplified it by saying it's the best of the left and right.

The way I simplify it is l, if one values individual right then your most likely libertainan leaning.

3
Tactical_Sandwich•

'You turned in more than enough signatures but some of them didn't count because reasons'

5
tedted8888•

I think you mean feelings

4
kenabi•

i think you mean pulled strings and agenda.

2
arakboss•

I emailed one of the IP 43 petitioners with about a dozen questions. Most importantly, was it their intention to only allow registration of one assault weapon and one large capacity magazine per legal owner. We'll shall see if I get a response.

For those who participated in yesterday's IP 43 Q&A post, I would like to share my stance on IP 43 in case you care. I am strongly opposed to IP 43. My attempt to answer questions about IP 43 was dominated by accusations that I was supportive of the initiative. That is not the case. I plan on engaging more people in other Oregon forums across the net to try and educate the citizens on how bad this proposed law would be for our freedoms here in this state. Sometimes I will come at it with neutral approach otherwise emotions get the best of people and education goes out the window. I respect that people have different views although I will never understand how you can feel that infringing on responsible law abiding citizens freedoms is a positive thing to do. A tiny, minute fraction of people commit crimes with firearms compared to vast vast majority of gun owners who do not. Imagine if a couple of people looting in a city caused a curfew to go in to effect for the rest of the residents who did nothing wrong. We should be working together to strengthen security in our schools and not banning/confiscating weapons from responsible law abiding citizens.

2