r/Dell•
CaffCast

Do we have an idea of how the new XPS 2 in 1 will compare to the current generation of XPS 15?

Discussion

Specifically in terms of video editing? I need a travel friendly quad core laptop with a decent GPU for video editing (premiere) and I am wondering if this new release will actually be a step up or a step sideways with a foldy screen.

Thanks!

Posted Mar 28, 2018, 12:15 PM UTC

230
Eason85•

CPU should be slightly better, GPU will be likely the same or negligibly better. RAM won't be upgradable. Battery should be a bit better while editing due to the lower TDP of the vega vs the 1050.

2
Africa-UniteXPS 15 9560 4K 32GB 1TB i7 7700HQ•

I have 32 GB, will I be hurt by a 16GB downgrade? I mostly just run GIS software and have a bunch of desktop/windows open, and occasionally game

1
jcarter315XPS 15 9560 16GB RAM, i7, 512GB SSD•

Haven't used GIS in a long while. Only with provided computers. Not sure what kind of RAM you'd need. I have an XPS 9560 with only 16GB and I find that more than enough to have a few window open with games too. Keep in mind that the 2 in 1 doesn't have upgradeable RAM. So if you find 16 to be too little, you'd be stuck.

1
Africa-UniteXPS 15 9560 4K 32GB 1TB i7 7700HQ•

yeah, I just don't know how little is too little since it's all an upgrade for me. Ah well.

1
aboukirev•

If you make music with massive sample libraries that do not support stream from disk or develop multi-gigabyte high resolution photographs in RAW format or work on high-polygon/vertex 3D meshes with complex multi-layer textures or if you run multiple virtual machines then you need 32 GB of RAM. You should know if you do need it.

2
isugimpy•

Where are you getting that the RAM won't be upgradable? They specifically had up on the pre-sale listing on the Dell website that the max they'll ship the 9575 with is 16GB but that it was upgradable to 32GB.

1
khalilsqu•

it is not upgradeable, the max is 16gb. This just mentioned that they probably make the ram max 32gb as an option but I think they will not.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Eason85•

Oh, I didn't catch that. Can you link it?

1
isugimpy•

I can't, now, because they pulled the page down, presumably to prep for the actual sale page to go live tomorrow. I know it was up there previously, though, because I was working with in-house IT to prep for ordering one, and he looked at the same page I did prior to contacting our rep for a quote (which I haven't gotten back yet).

1
Eason85•
Silver
8GB DDR4-2400MHz Integrated
Radeon™ RX Vega 870 with 4GB HMB2 Graphics Memory
Killer 1435 802.11ac 2x2 WiFi and Bluetooth
6-Cell 75WHr Integrated Battery
Backlit English Keyboard with Fingerprint Reader
130W AC Adapter
Operating System Recovery Media Not Included
1
justavault•

Likely the same or weaker, not better. There is no way this will be better, just starting from the power input of the Vega you just mentioned, but if anything goes really well this new 2in1 could become comparably performant as the current normal XPS. Under no circumstances it will be more powerful at all, not the slightest.

Yet again, if the 2in1 will be "comparable" it already is still on top of the market especially regarding the form-factor and the convertible feature. No matter what the new base XPS brings, it will barely be more powerful than the 2017 version.

However, history showed that the prior 2in1 was a total performance cripple. So, I'd not be too excited to hope for the 2in1 be able to be used for video editing.

-1
YoungBuscemi•

Why are you stating this like you have had hands on experience already with the machine? The laptop isn't even out yet, let alone there are NO reviews or benchmarks...

2
TarOskin•

I suppose we'll get some reviews this weekend or upcoming week and find out! :)

I'm hopeful.

1
justavault•

Why are you stating that it is "better"?

1
TarOskin•

The CPU, on paper, without knowing more about the performance of the thermals/throttling and the chosen TDP (as this chip is very flexible w that, and some suggesting Dell has chosen 45W TDP), is more powerful than the current XPS's cpu. The base and turbo frequencies are higher.

1
TarOskin•

The 2 in 1 has a more powerful processor than the current XPS 15, and a reportedly similar/slightly better performing GPU.

Depending on the TDP chosen and the level of throttling/heat management quality, the 2 in 1 should be at least comparable and potentially higher performing. Certainly, it will be higher performance vs power requirements.

1
justavault•

The GPU is advertised as similar but reported from insight bench is far away from the 1050.

HUGE difference between what marketing says and what benchmarks say and those not-official hustled benches from the CES dev device were far away, but who knows.

Especially regarding the TDP input the GPU is way slower than the 1050 and same for the 15W CPU. The XPS sports the 45W.

1
TarOskin•

The CPU is not comparable to a 15W CPU - it's much faster. The whole point of the chip is that it can manage and balance power requirements between the GPU and CPU, allowing the CPU to perform much closer to a 45W chip at times - the 15W 8650U sports a base frequency of 1.8GHz. This chip has a base frequency of 3.1 GHZ, and has a higher turbo frequency.

That base speed (3.1) and turbo speed (4.1) is higher than the current XPS's 2.8 and 3.8. The 8705G, on paper, has a more powerful CPU (TDP depending).

The GPU is in much more murky water. No one REALLY knows how it will perform. Frank has stated it's close to a 1050/1050ti. However, Intel's provided benchmarks were just.. bad. I would expect the chip to be slightly higher performance than a 1050, but below a ti.

1
usafballer•

Well at least in the GPU department, I thought Frank Azor stated the 2-in-1 would be close to a 1050ti in most titles, which is a considerable bump from the 1050. Plus the 4 lane thunderbolt is a big boon for me as I already own a nice eGPU setup.

1
MrBuzzkilllXPS 9560•

It's hard to tell. While on paper, the specs of the CPU is higher and the GPU is about as good as the 1050. This is however based on a 65 watt TDP. The 9575 will have a 45 watt TDP.

That TDP, shared between CPU and GPU, is equally as high as the TDP of the 7700hq. So it seems very likely that the package is going to be starved of power and that will severely limit its performance.

Especially when running a workload that uses the CPU and GPU at the same time.

1
psycho_admin•

Where are you getting the 45TDP? Everything I've read says the 9675 is likely to have as an option for the Core i7-8705G which is a 65TDP.

https://ark.intel.com/products/130411/Intel-Core-i7-8705G-Processor-with-Radeon-RX-Vega-M-GL-graphics-8M-Cache-up-to-4_10-GHz

1
MrBuzzkilllXPS 9560•

Dell has down-TDPed their version. Intel allows this.

1
sushicomped•

Exactly. Thermal limits are the biggest issue with it being so thin. You cant magically remove heat with small heatsinks, heatpipes, etc. Nearly every 2 in 1 throttles because of the design complexity - even though on paper they should be good performers. Frank stated it was as fast as a 1050ti - fine - for how long can it hold that speed?

1
psycho_admin•

And again where are you getting this? They haven't released the product or the specs yet so where are you getting that they are reducing the TDP of the chip?

1

Anxious to find out myself, but really everything here is speculation, even that which is based on reasonable logic.

In a few days, tops, the data will answer this question in accurate detail.

1
Chpouky•

The 2 in 1 is AMD, the regular 15 is Nvidia.

Premiere is optimized for Nvidia GPU's using CUDA, so you'll get worse performance with the 2 in 1 compared to 2017's regular 15"

1