Is all the processing in the TV now?

Install/Placement

Currently I have Yamaha Aventage. Cable and BR player feed into it by HDMI, with an HDMI out to an old TV and the Yamaha powers the FRC speakers. No rear surrounds due to room configuration.

Just ordered an LG B7 and it seems to me that all the processing is in the TV itself, with lots of inputs and an HDMI ARC and TOSLINK (optical) out.

So what I'm wondering is, instead of plugging everything into the AVR and running video to the TV, wouldn't it make sense to plug everything into the TV and run just audio to the AVR?

Specifically I have an old (1999) HK ARV-85 that I love but got retired when HDMI came out. I'm thinking of running the TOSLINK out of the TV into the HK. I know optical doesn't carry the latest, greatest audio formats, but since I'm just running the front 3 it makes sense to me, but I may just be stupid.

Posted Mar 30, 2018, 3:57 PM UTC

13
umdivx5.2.2|Denon X4200|Klipsch RF-35 RC-35 RB-35|Dual SVS PB 12 NSD •

So what I'm wondering is, instead of plugging everything into the AVR and running video to the TV, wouldn't it make sense to plug everything into the TV and run just audio to the AVR?

The question you have to ask yourself is do you want to lose the ability to get the lossless audio formats (DD True HD, DTS MA)? Yes you're only running the front main speakers, you're still losing out on quality even with 3 speakers.

If not, then you still need to feed HDMI from your BR player into your receiver.

ARC and Toslink can't send your receiver lossless audio formats back into your receiver. Only HDMI directly from your BR player into your receiver will give you the lossless audio.

All that said, AVR's DO NOT need to process the video, they can pass it right through without touching the video, meaning what is sent into the AVR is what is sent back out of the AVR and into the TV.

5
cokoopOP•

Thanks for the reply. If I may follow up, does the TV actually decode the audio formats you mentioned or simply pass through the signal to a receiver that decodes?

1
umdivx5.2.2|Denon X4200|Klipsch RF-35 RC-35 RB-35|Dual SVS PB 12 NSD •

Decode? No, your TV will not decode a DD or DTS or any digital format and then try and send it back via ARC.

 

The main reason ARC or SPDIF/Toslink is even in and TV is for two reason, OTA HDTV tuner for over the air broadcast to send 5.1 DD out of the TV and into a AV Receiver for surround sound.

Also with the advent of "smart" tv's and having Netflix, Roku, Amazon, ect... that is the other reason, sending the surround sound from the "apps" built into the TV and sending that DD encoded audio stream out via ARC or SPDIF into a receiver.

 

So if you were to take a BD player, Xbox, PS4, FireTV, and feed that into a TV, then try and use ARC back out and into your AVR, the TV may or may not pass it through, it won't decode that audio but it may not pass it through either.

2