r/slaythespire•
vvhy

Why is there an incentive to reach the first boss?

Can someone explain what the point of this mechanic is? Because from what I can tell it's basically the Eden token mechanic from Isaac implemented poorly. I get it - the devs don't want you to spam "start new run" until you get an initial state you're happy with.

However I think the drawbacks seriously outweigh the costs. People who really want to cheese the game are always going to be free to do so, they can download cheat engine and set their HP to 9999. Meanwhile, anyone who wants to do some runs with risk heavy plays is punished with every other run being unfun garbage.

My question is - why? Why discourage risk taking? Why set challenges like the 1 relic victory, and then punish anyone who tries to go after them? When I'm making a decision in the game, I want to weigh the risk/reward for THIS run. Instead my thought process usually goes something like this:

"Oh, well I can try and slim down to 5 cards on the first floor but I might die on the mob before the boss. Then my next run is going to be super frustrating because I won't get that starting bonus. Guess I'll just quit and play another game, fuck this."

Posted Apr 2, 2018, 9:46 PM UTC

017
JDGumby•

I get it - the devs don't want you to spam "start new run" until you get an initial state you're happy with.

That is exactly it. And it's not discouraging "risk taking". If you're scumming for a good start, that's exactly the opposite of risk taking.

12
vvhyOP•

I'm not advocating for start scumming. If they want to put a 15 minute timer on "start new run" instead I'd be 100% fine with that. By risk taking I mean I want to be able to use strategies that have low chances of making it to the first boss without having to slog through a bad start between every failed attempt.

-10
Elwinbu•

I'm really glad they're not taking your suggestions than. 15 minute timer is a terrible idea, and 100 times worse than the current system IMO

16
vvhyOP•

It's not a suggestion (although I would prefer it to the current system,) I'm just making the point that I'm not asking for the means to rerollscum.

I think if they made it something like "reach room 10 OR spend 5 minutes in a run" that would accomplish the same goal without being annoying. As it is I will probably either stop playing the game or mod this feature out.

1
drewmb10•
I get it - the devs don't want you to spam "start new run" until you get an initial state you're happy with.

That's all you need to know.

7
Cookduk•

There's a big difference in convenience between being able to abuse the system ingame vs downloading a cheat engine. Calling all runs without starting bonus garbage is exagerrated imo. True, it can feel frustrating, I like to go random start relic for the fun factor, and I can imagine other types of players who maybe try to max score, but I think the first boss is easy enough to reach, despite risky play, and without a penalty, where is the risk? In act 2 theres already time invested in the run, but dying act 1 would just be sort of ' meh i ll just retry'.

5
vvhyOP•

The penalty should be for your current run, not future runs. That's like punishing someone's child for a crime they comitted.

-6

If the child did the crime of course it should be punished.

1
vvhyOP•

Sorry for the ambiguous sentence... But it should be obvious from the context that the subject of "they" is "someone," not "somone's child."

2

You could have worded it like "Thats like punishing a child for their parent's crime."

1
Blasto_Magoo•

It’s true to a rogue like to make decisions matter.

5
vvhyOP•

It depends on which one. Some games have a lot of persistent state between runs (rogue legacy.) In others each run is mostly self contained, with some unlocks for variety (Isaac, Slay the Spire.)

The only persistent mechanics in Slay the Spire are unlocks, cumulative heart damage, and this bullshit "reach the boss or have less fun next time" mechanic. It doesn't belong. Find some other way to stop people from holding R, there are a ton of good ways to go about it.

1
RHYTHM_GMZ•

I don’t know what kind of risks you are taking, but even on a15 it is not hard at all to get the first boss, even taking risks.

1
zcbr•

Overall I agree that it's a stupid mechanic. I only play daily climb because of it.

1
bogey654•

As a "legit" player I get annoyed. If I have a bad start I get punished despite not attempting to "scum" a good start. I have done the same as you. As a hotfix playing Daily Climb and reaching first boss does count so that can kinda make up for it.

1
Lttlefoot•

Doing a normal 5 minute run to the boss after each time your achievement hunting run fails to reach the first boss so that your serious runs can always start with a bonus is a little bit annoying, but it doesn't take up most of your time. A little extra grind is part of achievement hunting

1
DuoRogue•

I lost a run on ascension and had to do a non-ascension run bc I didnt want to try an ascension run with no neow's

1