Weight or BF as a metric for cutting?

Hi there,

I'm a 6 foot 17m, I weigh about 170 at 20% BF (according to my handheld BF device). How low of a BF % / weight should I aim to get down to as a solid building point (without being too fat) before I bulk? Is there even a point of cutting down to the point of having abs if I'm going to bulk? Is it possible to keep your abs on a bulk?

Thanks

Posted Apr 3, 2018, 1:42 AM UTC

2646
Josh1billionBodybuilding•

I recommend using BF% as the metric for cutting. Ideally, I'd cut to 10% bodyfat before starting a bulk, which in your case (if your numbers are accurate) would be about 19 lb.

Realistically, you probably won't need to lose the full 19 lb to get there, because at your level, you'll be able to gain muscle while cutting. So the scale may only need to move 10-15 lb to get there.

Once you're at 10%, you can safely bulk to 15% before cutting back to 10% again. Staying in this 10-15% range should allow you to keep your abs and not get fat. Another advantage of getting to 10% before you bulk is calorie partitioning: studies have suggested that the leaner you are, the more of your bulking calorie surplus goes toward muscle instead of fat.

13
BaXeD22•

Why 10% and not, say, 12%? 10% seems low, although I think there's maybe a difference between somebody's first cut and cutting once you've bulked up. Going from, say, 12% to 10% before you bulk seems potentially unnecessary.

Am I completely off base here? I'm trying to figure out the target weight for my own cut.

10
Patrogenic•

It's because of the skewed perception of what people think 10% BF looks like. :p

8
OkeepToothOP•

I've seen the 10% tossed around before for men, but it really depends on your body. I think OP gave solid advice, and I'm probably going to follow it.

2
Josh1billionBodybuilding•

12% is a good goal too, especially for your first cut. 10% just leaves a bit more room for bulking before you hit that 15% ceiling, and looks slightly better.

1
OkeepToothOP•

I'm having a lot of trouble getting my BF to drop, but my weight is steadily going down. Does that just mean im just not working out enough?

2
epwnym•

Put down the BF% device. They’re bullshit.

Use photos and a measuring tape if you want to track progress. But otherwise stick to a plan and use common sense and eyeballs.

Neither your actual bf % (which you can’t truly know), nor whatever estimated % a machine tells you actually matters.

5
OkeepToothOP•

Ok thanks, I’ve dropped a lot of pants / shirt sizes so ill just stick with that. Im just going to cut until I can see abs.

2
LHB2010•

Yeah, that means you're roughly losing as much muscle as you are losing fat. Are you making sure you're getting enough protein? While cutting I try to stick to protein heavy food so I barely lose weight but my bf is dropping by roughly 0.5% per week.

3
OkeepToothOP•

I think I just haven’t been working out enough, I’ve been really busy so for the majority of my cut I didn’t work out that much only diet.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
OkeepToothOP•

Hand held device.

1
Schanzii•

What about him makes u say he can gain muscle while cutting? Sorry if it’s a noob question just getting into the whole fitness thing as of recently

1
Josh1billionBodybuilding•

Just his weight is low for his height, and if he says a good chunk of that weight (20%) is fat, then he must have very little muscle on him, which means he's a beginner. Beginners with some bodyfat (say 15-20% or higher) are the one group that can gain muscle while cutting.

1
Schanzii•

I would probably fall into the beginner category then, do you think its better to go for a bulk or a cut first since beginners can likely gain muscle while cutting?

1
Josh1billionBodybuilding•

I'd say cut first if you're above 15% bodyfat. This is the only time in your life that you'll ever be able to gain muscle and lose fat at the same time, something every natural lifter wishes they could do, so best to do it while you can.

Probably won't take long to hit that point where your bodyfat is low enough where you're no longer gaining muscle on a cut. Someone told me once "nobody's gaining muscle on a cut below 12%." So around then is when I'd say to do your first bulk. That's the path I followed when I started-- cutting for a couple of months down to ~12%, and then bulking from there, and knowing what I know now, I'm glad I did it that way.

2
Soccer1297•

How do you approximate body fat?

1
Josh1billionBodybuilding•

I use a tape measure and punch the measurements into a calculator. Calipers are supposedly more accurate, but only if you use them just right, and I've had trouble using them accurately.

These two calculators seem pretty accurate for me. They spit out roughly the same numbers when I use them, and the numbers they spit out seem mostly consistent with the mirror test (i.e., I more-or-less look like people who have that bodyfat%).

https://www.active.com/fitness/calculators/bodyfat

http://fitness.bizcalcs.com/Calculator.asp?Calc=Body-Fat-Navy

1
RemoteProvider•

For the record, your handheld body fat percentage device is absolute garbage. All of them are.

8
OkeepToothOP•

What method would you recommend to calculate body fat?

1
NotTheMarmot•

Get a measuring tape and use the navy test alongside your handheld one for a better idea. I have a bio impedance scale and while it might not be accurate, I mostly just use it as a tool to confirm things are moving in the right direction.

3
Rgreene80•

Any idea how accurate (roughly) the navy test is? I have a 40" waist and 17.5" neck. I'm 5'8" and weigh 235lbs, so the test tells me 26% body fat, which seems really low for my weight. I've made sure not to suck in or anything like that on waist measurements, and even if I add a few inches to the waist to cover for error, it still doesn't put me above 30%.

I am relatively strong for my height, but there are plenty of dudes putting up more weight than me. Just doesn't seem right that I already have 165-175 lbs of lean mass.

1
NotTheMarmot•

As long as you don't have a weirdly thin or thick neck in relation to the rest of you, it's not too awful. Definitely better than the bio impedance stuff. Also I wouldn't be surprised if it gets less accurate the more body fat you have. Honestly at your amount I wouldn't worry too much about specifics, as long as you are losing weight and lifting I guarantee you'll be moving in the right direction.

1
GodLemon•

DEXA scan if you have the funds

1
OkeepToothOP•

Other options?

1
GodLemon•

A Bod Pod might be a little cheaper. I think if you want very accurate percentages, you’re gonna have to spend a little more. If you are just interested in seeing a change in BF, it doesn’t really matter if you’re getting the most accurate number as long as you are using the same method for measurement each time, and the percentages are going up or down depending on your goals.

3
Crossfox17•

Dont bother with it, it isn't worth your time. Get lean to where you have very little fat and then bulk and cut while staying at a level you feel comfortable with.

3
Bonsai006•

The mirror is a good metric for cutting.

7
Kr1ggs•

And progress photos, always under the same conditions of course.

1
ProfessinMySwole•

If your goal is leanness than bf% would be a good metric. If you know roughly what weight you would be at that body fat then you can use weight, but it's based off of projected body fat.

4
OkeepToothOP•

thanks

1
FinancialEconomist•

Do both. Weigh yourself and use a measuring tape around your stomach. If either of these is “improving” you’re doing fine

3
OkeepToothOP•

Is the caliper method more accurate than measuring tape? I haven't actually measured my waist size, but I have dropped pants sizes numerous times since I started (210~~ -> 170).

2
FinancialEconomist•

Probably, but I lost my calipers and have been too lazy to get new ones!

1
Fun_bot69•

Use the mirror. Do you look fat and out of shape? Cut. Body fat is extremely hard to measure properly and most methods are way off, so I wouldn't be to hung up on a stupid arbitrary number, just focus on what you see.

3
OkeepToothOP•

Ok thanks

1
pick1already•

at 20% 170, thats 34 lbs of fat mass.

10% would require 17 lbs of fat loss.

2
OkeepToothOP•

I don’t know how accurate my measuring device is but yeh.

1
pick1already•

If it's bioelectrical impedence those normally overshoot. I'll tell you why that doesnt really matter...

It's not so much the accuracy of these devices that matter, but the precision. As long as it's consistantly wrong the same way, it can be a valid tool to track changes. It doesn't matter if it always shows 3-6%bf over, because if you're losing real fat the inaccurate overshoot will be moving down in nominal value was well.

Just keep losing fat until you hit a level of lean you are satisfied with.

1
OkeepToothOP•

I'm having a lot of trouble getting my BF to drop, but my weight is steadily going down. Does that just mean im just not working out enough?

1
pick1already•

How long has this been happening? Are you gaining strength or at least maintaining it? Is your protein .64g/lb+?

When you go in a deficit, cortisol goes up, causing water retention, which will show on Bio-electrical impedance as fat%. So you can get a sort of cloaking effect going on.

When you go back to maintenance, does your weight stay the same or even decrease? If so, your water retention is masking things and screwing with your BEI reading.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
ByizoBasket Weaving•

Without a DEXA scan you won't be able to tell your BF% with any real accuracy. Watch the scale and be honest with your reflection in the mirror.

1
double-you•

You are made roughly out of fat, muscle, water, bones and internal organs. Bones and internal organs are hard to lose, which is good. When your weight is going down, you are losing any combination of fat, muscle and water. Muscle you should try to keep. Water is very much needed for life so keep replenishing it. But extra fat you should get rid of. So keep an eye on the bodyfat.

If you want to lose weight, the fastest way is to amputate a leg.

0