r/EDH•
HackettMan

Need some help getting back into Commander

QUESTION

It's been I think 3 years since I last played and recently I've been wanting to get back into magic and especially Commander.

I think I originally quit because I wasn't having fun with any of my decks. I was always losing to the others I'd play with. I think a large part of this was that I always jumped to a new Commander and never fine tuned what I had. I always was like "oh that's so cool, let's try that idea out," and then the decks never worked like I wanted because they were so un-tuned. I had like 7 decks that were never able to do what they wanted because I was missing this or that for them.

I still have most of my collection so I'm not starting from scratch. I'm hoping this time around to make a deck, tune it some, and get it to a good level before I move on to another deck.

So, with that said, I've been trying to choose what to build. I've been thinking Karador toolbox, or artifacts of some form, both of which seem fun, but I'm worried I'll spend time building and tuning them only to not like them. I have trouble settling on what my gameplan/Commander should be...

What do you all recommend to test a deck to make sure I like it? Best way to choose a Commander, especially one to be my first deck to build getting back in the game and likely take to a high power level? At what point to make a 2nd deck? Make 2 concurrently but no more? Buy a precon to have a quick way to get playing again and then build a new deck later? Resurrect an old deck and retune it?

Even just a strategy to help guide my deck building might be enough to really help me out. I definitely like a slower/more control and late game approach. Just want some advice to help me get back to playing again soon.

TL;DR: want to get back into Commander, stopped playing because I didn't like my old decks. Feeling lost and looking for guidance so I can start playing again

Posted Apr 3, 2018, 3:20 PM UTC

612
PrestigiousBum•

To me it's all about commitment to a Commander that offers me a playstyle I really like. If I find other Commanders I would like to try I write them down on a list of "next decks" and continue building my deck until it has the bare minimum cards to work. Also, if the deck i brew just doesn't make it no matter what I try, I disarm it and use the cards to build another deck from the "next decks" list. Works for me every time.

5
HackettManOPI need help•

Thanks for your input! I think I will be making a list of commanders/decks I am interested in and then select one to start building, and not start on the next one until that one is at least at a reasonable level.

1
Socatdnareeb•

And if you like more combo-oriented decks, finding any overlap in cards and picking those up earlier can help when you need to audible to something else to avoid burnout. I'm a R/G/x meathead in most of my decks so quite a few of the lands/rocks/spells overlap, which helps.

1
Loozar402Welcome to the Jungle•

The way I usually choose Commanders is either finding a Commander with abilities I like and building around that, or thinking about a playstyle I really enjoy and then finding a Commander that fits or supports it.

2
HackettManOPI need help•

This seems like a good start. I kind of feel like I need to figure out what my win cons are going to be and go from there. A shame that a lot of my favorite deck styles tend to win with combo, since I like to interact with other players. Maybe find a interactive deck wins with combo but doesn't run much tutors and more draw instead. And make the combo not too insane... Hmm

1
Loozar402Welcome to the Jungle•

Combo doesn't always have to be fast, uninteractive combo though. Especially in more casual and lower power groups, you have a lot of freedom with what to do and can have fun with janky combos. One of my favorite janky combos is the Worldgorger Dragon + Animate Dead loop to kill everyone with repeated ETB triggers of Piranha Marsh or Sunscorched Desert

2
HackettManOPI need help•

This is a really good point. I could still play some combos but make the game plan to be a slower grind until I can assemble a combo, instead of making it race to the finish line can I get my combo off right away

1
Loozar402Welcome to the Jungle•

To give you an actual example, Tana/Tymna Blood Pod in cEDH plays like this. It has combo lines, but it doesn't try to race for them immediately every single game. Mainly because the lack of blue for counterspell protection. Instead it's a Stax deck at heart that applies pressure with Tana and her 1/1 Saprolings, generates card advantage and gas with Tymna, and pretty much only combos out when the coast is clear.

Ayli Ad Nauseum is another deck I've played against once. It's a midrange deck that can combo off with Ad Nauseum but prefers to play a longer game and grind out opponents.

3
frwtr1968Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker•

Find a good friend to skirmish with, and use proxies for cards you don't own. It can be tedious, but it's probably the safest way to make sure you'll enjoy it prior investing alot of money into a deck. If I'd of done this it would of saved me the trouble of owning both kozilek, butcher of Truth or mizzix storm just to split them apart because it wasn't the style I enjoy playing.

2
HackettManOPI need help•

Yes, this would be good. None of my friends really play anymore though. I'm in reasonable range of 4 LGSs though, so I can find someone probably.

1
HerbySK•

I built an entire Breya artifact combo deck only to realize afterwards I had absolutely no desire to actually play it - which was kind of sad. Then I found my true love in Thrasios/Bruse Tarl Blink Combo! It's not the most powerful given that I didn't include a lot of tutors, but it can win enough that I am satisfied. However, if you like artifacts and combo decks, [[Breya]] may be just the commander you are looking for.

1
MTGCardFetcher•

Breya - (G) (SF) (MC) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1