SaydrahOP•

In case of flag/filters:

I went to look at the statistics and data link on the Youtube video and it shows a location in Mexico where the video was recorded. Also another Youtube viewer posted that they noticed a billboard in the background and it named a company called UNIFRUT which is in Mexico. It may be that this guy who uploaded this sick video is getting videos from friends in Mexico to upload (note his other video on his channel also from Mexico) - and besides, how on earth would he get an employer name like Hirzel Farms & Canning Company from the U.S. unless he probably works for them and doesn't feel he he's doing anything wrong and just pulling a sick prank?

Either way, that employer needs to know that someone is on Youtube with an animal cruelty video who claims to be their employee. And perhaps the Toledo Humane Society can assist in prosecuting this guy any way for this.

I've left the rest of my post below just in case anyone wants any of the information I gathered prior to this update.


I contacted the Maumee Ohio police dept (closest to this small town) and they referred me to the Toledo Humane Society at this link http://www.toledohumanesociety.com/tahs/faqs/display.asp?id=185&subj=faqs

I found out that the Toledo Humane Society is OPEN TODAY SUNDAY, APRIL 5th from 10am - 6pm (eastern time zone)

Please email them at the address given on the link above with the following information:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_p9RlJMqHyo (video of him turning his dog loose to document his dog killing a cat)

Please note the youtube channel it was uploaded onto: http://www.youtube.com/user/carlossujohz

*His name is apparently listed as Carlos - age 21 - located in Monclova Ohio and his employer company Hirzel Farms & Canning Company. I found a link to his named employer here http://www.cift.eisc.org/local/mfg-info.php?mrkt=Hirzel%20Canning%20Co.%20and%20Farms&county=wood

Let's all phone the number listed there for his employer at (419) 693-0531 tomorrow, Monday morning and tell them to turn this employee of theirs named Carlos into the police and/or the Toledo Humane Society.

*Whether this employee is the owner of the dog, someone, an employee of theirs has uploaded a video of animal cruelty onto Youtube and this company NEEDS to know about this. Any decent employer (and they list themselves as a family owned company on that link above) would be outraged to know that one of their employees is somehow related to this video - participating in filming, or uploading, makes no difference and they didn't think at all to add their employer on the Youtube channel to which it's uploaded.

Although he could change the information by the time you are in receipt of this, I wanted to document the information for you.

*Please also call the Toledo Humane Society's phone number listed as 419-891-0705 ext. 301 - Please call them today.

I'm going to try the phone number at 8am Mountain time today without entering the extension first to see if I can get someone.

I've also contacted The Humane Society of The United States on their website at http://www.hsus.org/contact_us/contact_cruelty_fighting.html

I would copy/paste the same information that you email the Toledo Humane Society for the HSUS - they will pursue things often when others do not.

Hopefully together they can get the guy's ip address information through his phone company and locate his address, etc and seize his dog who has sadly been trained to engage in this behavior and prosecute this man to the fullest extent of the law. He is in violation of animal cruelty laws as well as Youtube's terms of agreement.

Please everyone, let's help with this.

Thank you

158
[deleted]•

[deleted]

53
[deleted]•

Excellent work, detective.

It's amazing how much information the average idiot has posted of themselves online. I guess it's not the average users fault that Facebook makes you go through 5 different menus to opt out of Google search linking or the Facebook general search feature.

EDIT: Are you sure you're searching for the right guy? I was under the impression that his name was "Carlos Sujohz," not the "Carlos Sujo" you linked to.

12
noxyu•

From the picture of the doberman and the cat in the tree in Carlos Sujo's albums I'm pretty sure it's the right guy.

5
sdsdsdsdsd•

How do you know? Is "pretty sure" the standard we apply these days when determining guilt? I watched the movie, didn't see his face. Are you any better than the guy in the video, saying "sic 'em" to an Internet lynch mob?

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

Typing in all caps makes it look like you're yelling, and the bold text simply makes it worse.

We have such little control over foreign policy issues, and with this, we clearly have some leverage and strength to right this wrong.

We have a Facebook profile, name, city, video, photographs; someone will turn this guy in.

P.S. You're a terrible troll. Shut it down, start a new account, with a new angle. GG.

EDIT: Why did you delete your comment, AbstinenceOnly?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

It's amazing how much information the average idiot has posted of themselves online

Not according to future man.

-1
TyPower•

ROFL "white looking people".

For all of those on here who are not of the correct color/race or are not "white looking enough" and by implication, might condone what was done to the cat, be warned, there's a lynch mob "a risin" here on reddit and if you dare draw attention to any of the logical fallacies contained within the overarching argument, thou shalt be downmodded to oblivion!

(Like this comment will be)

What are we now on Reddit?

4chan?

-3
noxyu•

You should be downmodded to oblivion for a) being a goddamn idiot, and b) whining about downmodding. I mentioned that "he might be Mexican-American because there's a photo of him in vegas and photos with white-looking people" for a very specific reason - I'll leave it for you to figure out why. I have since taken it out because he's probably not Mexican-American and the information isn't really relevant or useful anymore.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
LeNoir•

Fuck! I have 2 friends in common with him. I guess I'll have to send them the video. What should I do?

10
sdsdsdsdsd•

You should contact him directly and see if he sounds like the guy in the video. Ask him if he uploaded the movie. That is, give the guy a chance to defend himself before pouncing on him. There is a possibility the lynch mob has the wrong guy in their cross hairs. Yeah, he's Mexican, so they think it doesn't matter, but it actually does.

4
judgej2•

And that is why finding 'terrorists' by linking e-mails and websites is not a good idea. Now you are guilty of this by association.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
sdsdsdsdsd•

Oh, a YouTube comment you say? Why then, guilty as charged, case closed!!! What more reliable source of information is there than a YouTube comment?

6
[deleted]•

A /b/ one :-)

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
hyperbolic•

Why not send all his friends the video?

That may be the best way to fuck with him. Some of his buddies are probably all into it but I bet most of them will hate him for it.

Ruin his life.

1
SaydrahOP•

Fuck yeah! Okay, now any Redditors familiar with Mexico and Mexican law know anything we can do? Wikipedia suggests there is a federal law banning "unreasonable suffering" but that it is rarely implemented-- maybe a barrage of phone calls, or pressure on the Mexican Embassy in the US could convince someone to implement it? Failing that, can we get some identifying information and sic the general internet masses on this guy (not advocating violence here, but contacting his employer demanding that he be fired for criminal conduct would be appropriate IMO)?

0
hyperbolic•

How about sending the video to all his friends?

0
[deleted]•

They're probably going to love it.

0
wreelp•

if anyone has the software, they should download his facebook page. either way, facebook keeps a permanent record of everyone's account after its closed. but this would only elongate the process. I hope he goes to prison.

-2
NadsatBrat•

We appreciate you contacting us regarding the video in question. Early this evening we first learned about the video that has been posted by an individual who presents himself as an employee of Hirzel Canning Co. and Farms. We genuinely appreciate your efforts to bring this video to our attention.

We, like you were saddened and disturbed to see this video. However, it is important that you know that this individual in question is not a current employee and has not been employed by our company since the summer of 2008.

We will be cooperating and providing any help to the proper authorities in bringing resolution to this disturbing matter.

Thank you for bringing this to our attention.

Sincerely,

Stephen Hirzel President Hirzel Canning Co. and Farms

pulled from here

41
[deleted]•

[deleted]

17
taste_my_jesus•

Fuck him up.

17
[deleted]•

nice work.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-21
derp_derp_derp•

That's what we do on craigslist posts that aren't bestof in case they are flagged and taken down.

22
atomicthumbs•

and we do it on bestof posts anyway because some people can't view Craiglist at work

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Your work gives me hope... thanks for that alone.

4
franksvalli•

The video has been removed from YouTube, so here's a copy someone uploaded: http://www.megavideo.com/?v=J79RENM2

Link to original YouTube video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_p9RlJMqHyo YouTube User: http://www.youtube.com/user/carlossujohz

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
abyssalzone•

"and they didn't think at all to add their employer on the Youtube channel to which it's uploaded." I find this disturbing as well. Does anyone else wonder why that is?

0
mrpeenut24•

Hey I just started a subreddit for this kinda thing. Maybe you'll want to join?

-1
[deleted]•

Sorry, I can't figure out how you came up with "Hirzel Farms" or the guy's name, other than somebody on Youtube said so. And you can't see shit on that billboard, not that it matters.

Some guy named Carlos is going to be beaten up, maybe killed because of a youtube comment? Is that right?


Edit: Do any of you automatons want to actually explain why you're voting this down? Can any of you tell me how your little lynch mob isn't based on total jack shit?

-3
Llewdin•

The logo in the video is definitely Unifrut. http://www.unifrut.com.mx/

Underneath it is the Cosmocel logo. http://www.cosmocel.com/eng/home.html

EDIT: This too apparently :| http://www.reddit.com/r/Internet_Justice/comments/8a93f/warning_graphic_video_man_kills_a_cat_with_his/

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Llewdin•

No. It means you have crappy eyesight and there is plenty to see on that billboard. xD

oh, and the other info (besides his name) came from someone on /b/.

2
infinitysnake•

Lurk more.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-16
chabreck•

Fuck You.

8
[deleted]•

Fuck you back you little twit. Get off your ass for something real instead of this Barney & Friends sideshow.

-1
[deleted]•

I agree with you. That these morons fawn over one cat like this, when they ignore all of the real issues in the world while it goes to hell, is why we're doomed as a species and we're taking as much of Earth with us when we go.

1
hyperbolic•

How many fucking times will someone claim that outrage can only exist for one thing at a time?

Most redditors care about quite a few of your important issues, while still being fucking enraged at this ass hole.

2
[deleted]•

Right, which is why your priorities are seriously fucked up.

1
[deleted]•

Cause it's impossible to care about the big AND little issues, right? People all over are enraged over genocide and human rights violations, it's just much easier to flag a video and call the cops than it is to take down an entire government or restructure its policies.

Also, chill the fuck out. If you don't care about the cat, ignore the post.

2
[deleted]•

Let's see your rage at a real issue, and I'll believe you.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

The dog needs a new home and the dog's owner needs to be euthanized.

66
Nimbus2000•

I hear you, and this is disgusting. I couldn't even watch after the cat kept getting knocked out of the tree.

What is it about human nautre (or redditor's nature) that gets us so emotional about a cat, but we sort of skim over the news about thousands of starving children and child prostitution rings, etc etc? I'm not being a jerk, I'm really truly curious about this.

31
SaydrahOP•

If there was a video of one child being abused on YouTube and a chance of doing something about it, I think the result would be the same. Thousands of children is such a depressing and enormous problem that it's hard to get excited about "Hey let's do some small thing that might maybe someday help these kids... or might not." But one child, cat, dog, homeless guy posting on Reddit, we get excited about helping, because it's more likely that we actually can eliminate the entire problem [for that single individual.]

60
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
Yst•

To paraphrase the popular saying, "if ten men die, it's a tragedy. If one million people die, it's a statistic."

One million people simply can't be integrated into our monkeysphere.

4
phoenixankit•

That is THE most accurate saying I've read in years. Bravo.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
JenM•

Here's something you all can do that is easy and free to help those 'thousands of starving children." Every comment left here equals a dollar for Heifer International, which gives cows and goats, etc, to families and teaches them how to sustainably tend to the animals. Every dollar helps. :) http://travelingmamas.com/2009/04/02/traveling-mamas-give-back-heifer-international/

0
[deleted]•

Every reader who leaves a comment under the relevant post on all three sites will see a dollar donated to Heifer International, with a cap of $1,500.

7
[deleted]•

I can't speak for others, but I think you are assuming that this is the only thing I get upset about. I donate to the SPCA, and I also donate to a lot of human causes like the Cancer Society and Plan Canada and Darfur relief efforts and the Palestine Red Crescent Society, and I walk in the Aids Walk, and Run for the Cure, and other stuff too. I don't think that I'm special, or the only Redditor that does take action in real life.

But to try and answer your question, while I cannot answer for others, the reason this story in particular gets to me is that I grew up with cats in the house and I know from experience that they have distinct personalities and are capable of forming loving relationships. While they are large in personality they are physically small and basically defenceless before a human or a large dog, let alone a human and a large dog working as a team. Having been teased by bullies as a child I understand the terror that this cat must have been feeling and empathize with the cat even if it is not human. The fact that it is so small and basically helpless, and the human is a fucking sadist who has trained and twisted a poor dog to be his personal torture machine, and is so proud of this that he posts videos of his torture session online, obviously enrages me.

I guess I have a special place in my heart for small, loving, furry, purring creatures that have the temerity to take a swat at me if I pat them the wrong way.

EDIT: If you want to stop feeling helpless, set up a monthly donation to something like Plan Canada : http://plancanada.ca

26
vishtr•

You are a good person.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kromlic•

Amen.

1
[deleted]•

would you feel the same way if it were say, alligator abuse, or rat abuse? Should we have "cuteness auditions" to determine which animals to form a lynch mob over as you sit there eating eating a big mac? "Fuck cows dude! They're so delicious! I don't care if they're slaughtered in the most inhuman way imaginable. Just don't fuck with my cute fluffy kitty cat, or I'll track you down!" here ya go http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zZy3biFph9E&feature=related

4
icanseeyourdoodle•

Had to login on a public computer just to upmod you. :)

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

I would say the main reason I get so emotional about a cat (or dog, or for myself any other animal) is that humans have the obligation and capability to treat animals with dignity and respect. The fact that humans have higher reasoning capabilities means absolutely nothing if they cannot treat animals (and fellow humans) with nothing but love and respect.

For me it is especially egregious when you see anything (whether it be human or animal) who depends solely on the good nature of humans to care for it be mistreated. I think reason you see the anger more prevalent in animals being mistreated has to do with the fact that animals are totally innocent to the disgusting ways of humans. When the same shit happens for humans, I hate is just as much--but it just feels a little more vile and sick to hear of defiling creatures that should never know the dark and grimy nature of humans. Yes, humans should never know this either, but eventually they will discover it--with animals it seems more unnatural that they should know the horrors of humans.

9
[deleted]•

humans have the obligation and capability to treat animals with dignity and respect.

Dignity and respect are concepts we apply to the human condition! Do you propose that we treat dirt and rocks with dignity and respect too? What's next in the ontologic equivocation queue, dry water?

(also, a second observation -- you have several rights by virtue of being a person, but among them there is certainly no right to respect or dignity. remember, the word "right" does not mean "nice-to-have" at all. so, if not even you as a person has these "rights", how asinine is to ascribe these rights to animals?)

-1
GorillaJ•

Rights only exist because we desire them and have establishments that will safeguard them. If people want to give those same rights to animals, they're more than capable.

5
[deleted]•

The Internet is our house. When dirtbags bring their show to our house, we feel personally responsible to clean things up.

4
kromlic•

I think this explains the 4chan mentality too... Albeit scrambled pictures of kiddy porn and naked animated girls seem to occupy most of their thought-process.

4
[deleted]•

Well said.

1
waxpoet•

I think it's partly because I trust that if there's evidence of a human being abused the authorities will be all over it until someone's prosecuted. Animal abuse isn't a high priority on most city's agendas, and the thought of someone getting away with that shit sickens almost as much as the acts of abuse themselves.

3
wreelp•

i think its because animals are completely helpless. its almost like we are all responsible for taking care of animals and making sure theyre safe. The other day I saw a homeless person downtown and it didnt phase me one bit, BUT he had a dirty cold little shaggy dog with him and that just killed me! I went across the street to a supermark and bought a can of dog food for the dog.

2
GorillaJ•

I'm not sure what you see, but whenever a story like that pops up I see plenty of outrage. You likely think there's a greater response here because something can be done by normal Redditfolk, as opposed to starving children in another country or child prostitution rings.

2
[deleted]•

Because nobody ever got accused of being paedophile for wanting to help a cat.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

I skipped to the end after he knocked the cat out of the tree the second time, and I wasn't pleased with the results.

Not. At. All.

1
[deleted]•

Because we already are trying that? Because some of us would end up in jail if we lost our cool over a child? I dunno. I for one just pick my battles. Maybe if each child that died were posted on an individual level we'd come to our senses. My feeling is we're overwhelmed.

1
revb•

I wonder this very thing myself. It's actually kind of disgusting to me.

0
kuhawk5•

Unfortunately that dog may need to be euthanized too.

2
revb•

Also cats that shred birds and mice should also be euthanized! We can't have animals attacking other animals. It's unnatural.

5
kuhawk5•

Cats prey on birds and mice. Domesticated dogs do not prey on cats. This dog was trained to viciously attack other animals and kill them. Cats are not trained to kill birds and mice. Two completely different scenarios.

2
revb•

The hell they don't. I have a dog that will definitely shred cats. I didn't train her to do it - she just does it. I know of many dogs that do the same thing.

EDIT: downmods for telling the truth. Classy.

6
revb•

One other thing. Have you never seen a cat toy with a bird or mouse - basically torturing it? Never eating it, mind you. Just torturing it until its dead. Shouldn't we euthanize cats that do that? They aren't preying on them for food. They are clearly doing it for amusement.

5
[deleted]•

Domesticated dogs do not prey on cats.

Dude:

  1. you have never owned a dog,
  2. your parents ersatzed your real dog with a stuffed toy,
  3. your dog was on a permanent Ativan drip.

Domesticated dogs do pursue cats.

0
stfudonny•

Quite possibly. If he's been trained to pounce on every cat he sees and shred it to bits, I don't see another way.

-3
lenolaj•

Many dogs have a hunting instinct. My dog killed two cats unfortunately. He wasn't trained to do that, and the instinct to chase small animals cannot be untrained from him. Those cats were unlucky to be too slow/catched off guard. :( You can say that he must be euthanized then. But, so every cat that kills a mouse or a bird must be euthanized too? Cats kill a great many more animals than dogs, generally.

14
TyPower•

Prepare, my friend for the downmods. Your statement of fact here is unwelcome in the collective grief fest for the dead cat. The same people downmodding you are many that giggle at the "Hmmmm Bacon" meme here on Reddit as if that's not a pig (A far more intelligent and sensitive animal than a cat by the way) marching to it's death in a slaughterhouse, knowing it (smelling the blood) and going catatonic in fear and dying a horrible death just like this cat. Of course it's all okay for the pig, because it results in a sandwich which benefits our stomachs and is therefore cognitive dissonantly "acceptable".

The cat's death is not okay because someone made a video of it and brought the reality of slaughter home. Talk about kill the messenger. The ignorant Mexican who did this that you all wish to hang is actually a sick messenger of death.

This shit goes on every day.

Civilisation pastes over and hides horrible, cruel, agonizing, unnecessary death every second of it's existence. How many upmodded this story over burgers or a late Sunday ham sandwich?

Only if you are a vegetarian do you have the right to downmod here. Nature is cruel. One thing kills another, most do it for food, only humans do it for sport.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
[deleted]•

and shred it to bits, I don't see another way.

You clearly don't know anything about dogs.

1
stfudonny•

Not really. Never owned one. Sorry if I misfired earlier.

1
[deleted]•

I had heard about anthropocentrism, but antianthropocentrism? I seriously hope you're being exaggerative when you call for another person to be killed for letting a dog loose on a cat.

0
[deleted]•

It's called hyperbole.

1
[deleted]•

Good to know. That's why I said "I seriously hope".

1
bobpaul•

This sounds like something I saw on reddit the other day. Apparently PETA euthanizes 95% of adoptive pet owners or something like that. I don't remember; I voted up without reading the article.

-1
ChunkyLaFunga•

You should have read it then, it was a false statistic from an organisation that's a front for corporate interests.

reddit is a terribly inaccurate place, if something hits home enough to vote you should check it out.

-1
bobpaul•

95% of pet owners

Just making sure you caught that.

2
ChunkyLaFunga•

Argh, meddling kids. You got me.

1
[deleted]•

That is beyond cruel.

I'm downloading the video and rehosting it, seeing as Youtube will take this down pretty fast. I'll edit my comment when it's rehosted to Liveleak.

MIRROR:

EDIT: I had to settle for MegaVideo: http://www.megavideo.com/?v=J79RENM2

31
PhilxBefore•

I've got a copy on my HDD in case they scrub the websites, should it be needed as evidence in a court arraignment or for prosecution charges.

No one ruins my day with a snuff film and gets away with it.

8
[deleted]•

I'll host it on my .com if needed. 3 terabytes of b/w a month.

1
stringer4•

so...it's been two hours. how's that reposting coming?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

10
stringer4•

ah, thanks honey. I was just making sure you were alright.

14
thibit•

It's up now!

4
westlib•

Hope they don't euthanize the dog.

To clarify: Not the dog's fault the owner is a douche.

27
Lavender•

Yes totally... dogs love their owners, even if their own beats them and it is totally sad.. I hope the dog gets a new loving home and is taught better.

2
Tommstein•

This is possibly the first story I have ever upmodded where the title asked or even implied that it be upmodded. I aspire to kill this motherfucker.

24
LeeJunFan•

I'll need a spotter. I can't pay you but I'll teach you a lot.

15
Tommstein•

That'll be too swift. I was planning on doing it manually.

8
LeeJunFan•

I never said the first shot would be the killshot.

13
[deleted]•

You selfish people are gonna deprive me of a free meal. shame on you. He's mine.

9
Tommstein•

Very well then, I accept this apprenticeship. As long as manual asswhooping is involved before he dies.

-1
[deleted]•

I'll hold him for you.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
troubleondemand•

I say we tie him up over a fire ant hill and smear honey all over him ...

1
Tommstein•

Your ideas intrigue me.

1
revb•

Yes he deserves to be killed because we don't tolerate violence in our society. Um. wtf?

1
GorillaJ•

No, no. It's not 'violence' that isn't tolerated, it's undeserved cruelty.

3
revb•

So to be clear, you are in favor of the death penalty for cases of animal cruelty?

0
GorillaJ•

Not really. I did not advocate any punishment at all, merely clarified what you were saying.

2
[deleted]•

People are too busy openly displaying their Internet Tough Guy creds to take part of a reasoned discussion.

0
Tommstein•

wat

0
revb•

English, please.

0
Tommstein•

Intelligence, please.

0
demeteloaf•

Ok, I know I'm probably going to get downvoted mercilessly for this but here it goes.

What is the internet's obsession with cats? If a guy had filmed a video of his dog attacking and killing a wild raccoon, weasel, possum, pigeon, rat, etc. absolutely nobody would care. Sure you may get the comment that "who would want to film that" and say he's sick, but it would get nowhere near the reaction that this does, simply because it's a cat.

Look, i despise needless animal cruelty but this video is very different than taking your pet cat into a shower and beating it. A feral cat (and I'm assuming it was feral, if not that's a completely different story) is just as much a pest as a rat is, and to say it's perfectly okay to kill rats, but we can't kill cats because there's a possibility that they can be pets is just absurd. For all we know, this guy could have been told to go kill the feral cat that's been living in the orchard.

Animal cruelty is one thing, but i don't consider killing a feral cat as animal cruelty. Sure shooting it would probably be more humane, but i don't really have that much of a problem with having the dog kill it.

*prepares for downvotes*

24
morish•

People have a symbiotic social relationship with cats that's at least a few thousand years old.

26
[deleted]•

Mainly because cats are much tighter than dogs.

-4
mig174•

This can be interpreted in several ways...

2
reginalduk•

My symbiotic social relationship with the local cat population revolves around my foot and their arse. Nasty spiteful little vermin who shit where they like and destroy bird life just for fun.

-14
[deleted]•

You fight the...power?

1
atomicthumbs•

He fights the kitties

2
reginalduk•

downmod all you like redditards but cats are one of the reasons for the decline in the British garden bird population, a vital part of the eco system.
Cats? not a single one native to Britain.

0
Amendmen7•

My symbiotic social relationship with the local bird population revolves around my cat and their spine. Nasty spiteful little vermin who shit where they like and destroy plant life just for fun.

-1
reginalduk•

Do you want me to tell you about the birds and the bees?

1
kousi•

See I'm pretty sure you're going to get downvoted too.. Though I agree with you...

I do wince at a cat being killed, and it makes me wonder why there's more outrage for a cat than a raccoon, a squirrel, weasel, possum?

19
[deleted]•

Perhaps the species name of "Felis domesticus" could offer a clue. Our species created the domestic cat by adopting and selectively breeding small, docile members of the wildcat populations. Because we selectively bred away the feline's best natural defenses in return for our protection as domesticated pets, seeing the human/domesticated animal social contract broken provokes disgust in non sociopathic humans.

40
the_trout•

Really? You honestly don't understand how a cat is viewed differently than a weasel? I find that kind of ignorance fascinating. But whatever. Anyway, I don't think weasels, possums or squirrels should be abused, tortured or mistreated, either. And yes, it might be "just a cat," and there are starving kids in India or wherever. The Internet might find this hard to believe, but I can be upset about more than one thing at once.

22
kevlarbaboon•

what a special talent you have!

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Borgismorgue•

How often do you have one of those in your home, bond with it, and have your children bond with it?

That reason alone puts any "pet" species above others on the sympathy meter.

I wouldnt say theres no outrage for the senseless killing of other animals too though.

For me its not about species. Its about senselessness and innocence and defenselessness. It just evokes something. Im not a violent person, but the idea of someone cornering something defenseless and innocent and then getting their jollies off of watching it be tormented... well lets just say if you happen to be one of those people and are lucky enough to see me in such a mood, its not a mood you will likely witness for very long.

17
demeteloaf•

So where's the outrage over this video. How about this one. this video?.

This cat is pretty clearly tormenting that rat, isn't it?

But for some reason, if it's a feral cat (which is just as much a pest as a rat or a rabbit) being killed, people are all up in arms.

27
[deleted]•

This cat is pretty clearly tormenting that rat, isn't it?

That's not even a rat, it's just a poor little mouse. :(

Oops, now I'm showing my favoritism (I have a huge cage with 4 mice in it). . .

11
dys-net•

Quite frankly all of those videos are disgusting but there's not much to be done about it.

The real outrage is that this video was recorded for entertainment purposes and uploaded to a website that is meant to be child friendly, THAT is frankly disgusting.

If you happen to condone the recording and displaying of such acts then you're one step away from teaching children how to curbstomp ethnic minorities because frankly, there's little difference between displaying the brutal execution of an animal by a trained pet and displaying the brutal execution of a human by a trained soldier.

There are plenty of humane options for euthanising all feral animals and pests so there's simply no need for this sort of behaviour.

I'm no bleeding heart, I've had to kill my fair share of pests, but i'm not about to start training my dog to kill other animals. It's not a wild beast and I intend to be a responsible owner.

4
jeremybub•

Please post this as a top level comment. More people need to see it.

2
[deleted]•

Each of those videos is showing a creature that we specifically breed cats and dogs to hunt.

1
[deleted]•

Because we have the perfect storm here: a mexican with an annoying voice using a big, black rotweiller to kill a cat.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kousi•

I wasn't saying cats should be killed, or anything. I just don't understand the moral outrage about which 4-legged, two-eyed, two-eared mammal is being killed.

-1
astrawso•

for me, its more about the sick sadistic rage that this guy thinks is ok. if the same kid were doing the same to another animal and getting some filthy disgusting pleasure about it, it would be the same. it just so happens that it most often is our feline friends

6
dys-net•

Most people give the wrong meaning to the word "pet" and that's where the outrage stems from in 99% of the cases. Which honestly is just as blind and ignorant as people who train their dogs to kill feral cats for their own amusement.

4
Tommstein•

Sounds like a personal problem.

2
[deleted]•

Because my cat is more like a dog?

My outrage is more akin to seeing someone hitting a dog on purpose or something. Just because some cats live outdoors doesn't mean they don't also have a family they go back to.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Because a domesticated feline is much closer to us than most other animals. That is why we cringe over the idea of foreign cultures using them for food. The very fact that we choose not to eat it should be a sign we have a higher respect for the creature. You see, we'll make rabbit stew, and most other rodent and smaller mammals. But we domesticated cats, they are our burden, and as such we usually treat them more like humans than we do other feral beast.

0
reginalduk•

Or perhaps the dwindling garden bird population.

-3
[deleted]•

He's got a point there, Jim.

Cats are decimating the bird population - if you own a cat, please keep it inside.

signed,

-a birder

-1
reginalduk•

Fat chance, cats are cute. Birds are essential.

2
thibit•

Our extensive use of electricity has something to do with it also.

1
[deleted]•

Its because cats are cute and great companions.

Thats it.

16
FruitFly•

I do not necessarily agree with your sentiment, but I upvoted you because it is definitely a valid point. (And the people who are downvoting it are being rude jerks.)

I have not watched the video (this is one of those rare cases where I'm glad I'm at work where YouTube is blocked) but from the descriptions I can glean a few issues:

  1. We don't know if it's a feral cat, or someone's pet, but either way cats do have a different place in the human world than do the other creatures you mentioned, so yes, we think of their pain and death differently. It may not be fair, but it is the way of the world.

  2. To me, honestly, using a pet dog to harm another animal that could possibly be someone else's pet (or even if it's a feral cat) for entertainment purposes just shows a sickness. (There's a reason you hear about people that hurt people having a history of hurting animals.) That deserves the outrage - though I will agree that anyone that records killing any kind of animal just for fun and shares it for entertainment should be just as outrageous. That is the biggest problem I have with things like this.

I personally have issues with killing any animal (even rats - I think those buggers are cool little scavengers) needlessly (for sustenance I get it - food chain and all - but when you could set them free somewhere...). Pests or not, it bugs me. Hell, I don't even want to kill the skunk that's been living under our front porch, even though it sprays often and stinks up the whole place. I understand why people do it, and the need for it, but it still bugs me. But that's just me, so I can't use that to make a case.

I think that people who are convicted of animal cruelty - no matter what animal we're talking about - should face much stiffer punishments and penalties than they currently do.

Edit: It not if. I hate typos.

13
[deleted]•

I upmodded you because I can see your argument is also rational and because someone downmodded you.

As to rats and cats though, there are countries they were introduced to like Australia where they have no natural predators and destroy indigenous populations of lizards and other creatures.

Your average house cat will kill over a hundred small animals a year, and while they may make good pets, feral cats can cause significant problems in neighborhoods and out in the wild. Some people keep farm cats to control mice and other pests, but other farms raise birds and such that cats will kill, so they do everything they can to keep the population under control.

My grandfather owned such a farm and his brother raised animals that cats would kill so he'd regularly gather wild cats, throw them in a bag and drown them in the river. That's just the way it was done in his time. I suppose when you raise animals of your own for food or whatnot and you depend upon them for your survival, you'll do whatever you can to keep any pests out, even cats.

10
mexicodoug•

Right on.

0
hollywoodphony•

What part of this don't you get? This shithead brings his dog into a field where there's a treed cat and he repeatedly shakes it out so that his dog can attack an animal 1/5 its size. For fun, he does this. Why else would he videotape it? For scientific purposes? If these feral cats are really a problem, lay traps. Let the dogs loose in the area. This is done for kicks. That is the reason people are upset. It's masturbatory cruelty at its worst. Seriously, this guy is obviously a fucking psycho and his life is probably about to get real shitty real fast, but you seem to at least have some sort of sense. And yet, you can't grasp why this would upset people? That a person like this, who enjoys things like this to the point where he would post his exploits on a video sharing website is out there, unchecked? This is sick. This is cruel. This is not sporting. This is not letting nature run its course. This person belongs in jail. This person should not be allowed to own another animal as long as he lives. If you can't get that, I feel sorry for you.

9
demeteloaf•

As I said in another comment, if you feel that way, where's the outrage over this video. I'm pretty sure those guys are filming their dog kill that rat for fun. They even force the rat out of it's hole. Should we start an internet campaign to get them? How about calling the SPCA?

Or these guys? That possum was minding his own business before the guy knocked it down for his dogs to kill and drag into the pool. They were laughing as they filmed it. The comment for the video even says "funny vid of dog killing a possum." But look, that video has been up for about 6 months and there's 0 outrage.

Here's another one, and the comments for that video are supportive of them for filming it.

I could go on and on, there are probably 100+ videos like that, but the only one that draws outrage is when the dog kills a cat.

Honestly, i fail to see the difference between having a dog kill a feral cat, and having a dog kill any other pest. But apparently, if it's a cat, the internet is up in arms, any other small animal, who cares.

1
atomicthumbs•

I'd care if it was a rabbit :<

5
hobophobe•

Speaking personally I have a problem with human animals killing animals or helping animals kill animals. The exceptions I am comfortable with are where it is serving some real purpose like food, population regulation, and euthanasia. In all cases the animal should be killed swiftly and with as little pain as possible.

Any video of the activity should be clearly labeled as such.

4
trevorx2500•

The question is, can they suffer. Terror is equally as bad for a feral cat a it is for you or me.

4
CritterM72800•

I don't see any difference between a dog attacking a possum and a dog attacking a cat (assuming it's feral...a house cat is a different story). Either way, it's disgusting and needs to be reported.

2
darkreign•

Because killing cats is wrong!

/eats bacon bacon cheeseburger

2
MollyRingwald•

What is the internet's obsession with cats? If a guy had filmed a video of his dog attacking and killing a wild raccoon, weasel, possum, pigeon, rat, etc. absolutely nobody would care.

For me, this isn't about a cat -- I don't care about cats any more than I care about any other animal -- this is about a psychopath who gets off by tormenting things weaker than himself. Raccoon, weasel, possum, pigeon, rat, whatever, I'd care as much because this individual is a worthless piece of shit who I am ashamed to have to admit is a member of my species. The fact that people like this even exist should be troublesome to anyone; if it's not troublesome to you, then fuck you also.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
[deleted]•

as predicted, you were downvoted for having any amount of pragmatism or rational consideration in your approach to the situation.

clearly, its a CAT, a DOG, and a HUMAN, so the general brutality and indifference of organisms interacting doesn't apply.

-6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

24
mariox19•

Don't forget -- the garbage should be repeatedly knocked out of a tree.

2
[deleted]•

I'd gladly support "eye for an eye" type punishment in a case like this: film a hungry lion or tiger chasing and eventually killing the piece of human garbage responsible for that cat's death and post a video of it online.

I hope some day you return to this site, having matured a little bit, and sorely regret the day when you called for the death of a fellow man, an action the morals of which should be self-evident.

0
godskitchen•

I hope some day you return to this site, having become less condescending, and sorely regret the day you called for mercy for a mad man.

-2
[deleted]•

less condescending

How is it condescension to oppose violence against humans? And, seriously, dude, is a response to the supposedly condescending tone of my comment all you got?

2
MarshallBanana•

And as usual you get downmodded on reddit for suggesting it is bad to kill people you don't like.

-3
[deleted]•

I appreciate your words. It is the type of comment like yours that keeps me repeatedly coming back.

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-18
temp_account•

I'm not sure if you're joking, but as someone who feels quite strongly about animal rights, I would say your proposed punishment is way off. It's at least an order of magnitude worse than the crime.

I don't view this as being much worse than, say, hunters who legally kill large bears. In that case, even though the bears go through less fear and pain, they still suffer, and they're being killed for some guy's enjoyment.

6
Prysorra•

I don't view this as being much worse than, say, hunters who legally kill large bears.

People that end life for amusement are dangerous.

9
[deleted]•

"I don't view this as being much worse than, say, hunters who legally kill large bears. In that case, even though the bears go through less fear and pain, they still suffer, and they're being killed for some guy's enjoyment."

Bears suffer? One shot, one kill - or you don't take the shot.

Yes, we hunt for enjoyment, we also hunt for the connection it brings to the land, the challenge, and food.

*edit

lulz. -6 for saying I'm a hunter.

Also, I should clarify - the pleasure in hunting comes through the challenge, being in/one with nature and the food, not in addition to it.

-2
moodswung•

Bears suffer? One shot, one kill - or you >don't take the shot.

Riiight. You might HOPE for this to occur, but it's doubtful the case.

Yes, we hunt for enjoyment, but we also hunt >for the connection it brings to the land, the >challenge, and food.

Sorry, but this is just been a lame excuse to justify your desire to kill animals.

You want a fair fight, go toe to toe with that bear and see who wins.

8
temp_account•

I'm sorry- I didn't mean to attack all hunters. I actually don't mind hunters who kill for food- at least the animals weren't factory farmed, and the people eating the meat are actually killing the animal.

I mentioned bear hunting because I read that experienced hunters aim for the shoulder first, to disable the bear, and then go for the kill. And with bears being extremely large animals, I imagine it takes them longer to die. I've also seen some pretty nasty bear hunting videos, but I accept that these may not be representative.

I also figured people hunt bears just so they can put a bearskin rug in their hunting lodge, but I accept again that may not be representative.

EDIT: I don't feel youredoingitright's comment should be downvoted. He (and let's be serious- most people on reddit are guys) is thoughtfully putting across his viewpoint.

7
[deleted]•

While I may not support an exact 'eye for an eye' criminal justice system, I understand your sentiments, and share most of them.

2
notcaptainkirk•

So you're saying that you're part of the reason that animals in the US can get better health care than a lot of people there?

In that case, FUCK YOU, ASSHOLE.

-20
Siksay•

I really want to think that you're just trying to be funny and failing.

Because if you were being serious, I'd have to accuse your argument of being fallacious in the extreme.

6
chz•

I hope you're sterile.

4
emmster•

How does HostileMeatWizard have anything to do with the sorry state of health care in the US?

He didn't personally raise malpractice insurance to insane rates. He doesn't make veterinarians have a lower income and lower expenses than doctors who treat people. He didn't make the decision to subsidize and price cap animal vaccines, but not human ones. He didn't create the HMO mess that raises costs of human health care services.

He just likes cats a whole lot. I don't see the problem there.

2
[deleted]•

Edit, those look like pecan trees, could be mexico. If it is Mexico, nobody is going to care. Cock fights, dog fights, bull fights, bug fights. Ive seen some swerve to hit cats with their cars.

20
[deleted]•

Cock fights, dog fights, bull fights, bug fights.

Duck fights, pig fights, cat fights, bird fights!

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

31
[deleted]•

Pineapple fights, lemon fights, coconut fights, pepper spray fights, soup fights, food fights, tomato fights, fights and potatoes, and creole fights...

-4
PhilxBefore•

Never seen Forrest Gump, huh?

10
a_redditor•

Um...fight club?

1
Jinbuhuan•

No! Not soup fights! Now you've gone too far.

1
Jinbuhuan•

amoeba fights, paramecium fights, virus fights...

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

"Good Lord - I've heard about this - cat juggling! Stop! Stop! Stop it! Stop it! Stop it! Good. Father, could there be a god that would let this happen?"

http://catjuggling.ytmnd.com/

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
satx•

It's all good; I swerve to hit wetbacks with my car so it all evens out

-6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
[deleted]•

I recognize your attempt at non-PC humor and award you a single upmod, you fucking jew.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
theanswer•

i'm hispanic and take offense for my wetback brothers

-1
satx•

My bumper's got your name on it, pinche frijolero

4
Jinbuhuan•

ooh...perfect place to post this song. (The kitchen staff at my local burrito bar always makes me play it when I DJ there)

Molotov - Frijolero

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qcwaDYc1IWY&feature=PlayList&p=3FCE09356ED258A6&playnext=1&playnext_from=PL&index=1

2
oldno7brand•

Not that I'm defending the killing of cats by the releasing of dogs, but I find it funny how we don't find the same disgust in the releasing of cats for the killing of mice. When does life become valuable?

16
gromgull•

There was also some video of some dudes shooting a mountain goat and laughing as it rolled down the mountain side a while back... but of course they were "hunting" so that was ok.

2
[deleted]•

tiger tiger burning bright

Did He who made the lamb make thee?

or is all morality hypocrisy

2
oldno7brand•

All morality is hypocrisy.

0
ragesoss•

Am not I A fly like thee? Or art not thou A man like me?

0
MarshallBanana•

It's not a question of value, it's a question of choice. A cat does not kill mice by choice, it does it by instinct. That cat was killed by the conscious choice of a human.

1
[deleted]•

...

So are the mice. It's more complicated than that.

3
MarshallBanana•

What

-2
[deleted]•

Yes, or what if this was a wild rabbit? Pet species get special consideration.

-1
ladditude•

No. The cat got away. Then the guy repeatedly knocked it out of the tree. Then, the guy stomped on the cat. Multiple times.

Mice and rats spread terribad diseases and will destroy stuff. So having a cat around to catch them is nice. But I don't help my cat catch them.

Animals are animals. Sometimes they kill each other. That is life. What is fucked up is when I get involved.

6
NadsatBrat•

Looks like it's been brought up over on /an/ too.

14
Dubon•

Several consecutive /b/ threads too

6
Gareth321•

And that place we do not speak.

EDIT: Thread 404'd. There are several threads still running.

3
[deleted]•

More like, "that place we speak of all the goddamn time and emulate half the time."

12
Amendmen7•

I've never been on /an/ before, but I went on /b/ for the first time 2 weeks ago just to see what everyone's talking about.

That website is the shithole where human conscience and nobility crawled off to die but instead turned into zombies.

I've been online since '95 and have seen a lot of things on the internet. I had never seen anything like that. Just knowing that the Anons on /b/ exist depressed me. Even anonymous I have no slight inclination to write or consume the things I have seen written, offered, and requested on /b/.

In contrast, I've been a member of reddit for approaching 2 years

Reddit is nothing like /b/. Ever.

5
laudinum•

My dogs would totally eat a cat. I let my dog eat a toad once. Are you mad about toads or just cats?

13
baconn•

You're lucky the dog didn't die. They can be extremely poisonous.

12
Barrack•

Did you videotape your dog eating the toad and upload to the internet thinking others would be into that sort of thing? Was that toad somebody else's?

If you let your dog eat a toad that my daughter had as a pet and loved I would let my doberman eat you. I also would hope that you would understand and not get upset about my dog doing what comes naturally to it.

7
laudinum•

I would eat your Doberman in like kind.

0
thebamoor•

we humans care more about cats than frogs because we're closer relatives to them than amphibians.

3
haakon•

Then there's the whole domestication thing. A cat is often somebody's pet, in which case the cat depends on its owners, much like a child depends on his parents.

1
TyPower•

Toads are okay to kill because they are not cute.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
reverendfrag4•

This is why I don't upload videos of feeding my snake. Sure, rats aren't as cuddly as cats, but some motherfucker would sic the pigs on me.

11
SaydrahOP•

Cats are hardly the only food available for Doberman Pinschers. That said, I think it also takes a rather sick motherfucker to enjoy feeding one live animal to another enough to videotape it and put it on YouTube, even if, as in the case of snakes and rodents, it's indeed the only way to feed them. It also would show remarkable insensitivity to those who keep rodents as pets, so I'm glad you refrain from doing so.

21
emmster•

Feeding a snake live mice or rats isn't the only way to feed them. There are frozen ones available that you just thaw and warm up. Feeding frozen seems to reduce the likelihood of aggression in the snake, plus the rodents have been gut-loaded with nutrients that are beneficial to the snake.

I can just about handle feeding our python frozen rats, but I still can't look. I used to raise rats, and they have a very special place in my heart.

8
reverendfrag4•

I can't get my snake to eat them if they're already dead. I have TRIED.

2
[deleted]•

Actually, most snake experts recommend feeding killed rather than live rats and mice to snakes. The risk with live prey is that the snake might not feel like eating, and if he doesn't kill and eat it right away, the rodent can end up hurting the snake pretty badly. Most snakes adapt pretty readily to eating frozen/thawed rodents.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
frolib•

You're the pig and a sick motherfucker too. You know you don't have to feed a live mammal to your snake and you sure don't have to video tape it too.

0
reverendfrag4•

Fine, YOU try to get him to eat a dead rat.

1
pelirrojo•

So you take videos of it... that's weird... do you get off on that sort of thing?

-5
reverendfrag4•

The feeding will occur whether I videotape it or not, so why not point a camera at it? It's nature, red in tooth and claw, right there in your basement!

1
gjs278•

Re: Man who turned his doberman loose to kill a cat (UPDATED)

Date: 2009-04-05, 6:22AM MDT

I went to look at the statistics and data link on the Youtube video and it shows a location in Mexico where the video was recorded. Also another Youtube viewer posted that they noticed a billboard in the background and it named a company called UNIFRUT which is in Mexico. It may be that this guy who uploaded this sick video is getting videos from friends in Mexico to upload (note his other video on his channel also from Mexico) - and besides, how on earth would he get an employer name like Hirzel Farms & Canning Company from the U.S. unless he probably works for them and doesn't feel he he's doing anything wrong and just pulling a sick prank?

Either way, that employer needs to know that someone is on Youtube with an animal cruelty video who claims to be their employee. And perhaps the Toledo Humane Society can assist in prosecuting this guy any way for this.

I've left the rest of my post below just in case anyone wants any of the information I gathered prior to this update.


I contacted the Maumee Ohio police dept (closest to this small town) and they referred me to the Toledo Humane Society at this link

http://www.toledohumanesociety.com/tahs/faqs/display.asp?id=185&subj=faqs

I found out that the Toledo Humane Society is OPEN TODAY SUNDAY, APRIL 5th from 10am - 6pm (eastern time zone)

Please email them at the address given on the link above with the following information:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_p9RlJMqHyo

(video of him turning his dog loose to document his dog killing a cat)

Please note the youtube channel it was uploaded onto:

http://www.youtube.com/user/carlossujohz

*His name is apparently listed as Carlos - age 21 - located in Monclova Ohio and his employer company Hirzel Farms & Canning Company. I found a link to his named employer here http://www.cift.eisc.org/local/mfg-info.php?mrkt=Hirzel%20Canning%20Co.%20and%20Farms&county=wood

Let's all phone the number listed there for his employer at (419) 693-0531 tomorrow, Monday morning and tell them to turn this employee of theirs named Carlos into the police and/or the Toledo Humane Society.

*Whether this employee is the owner of the dog, someone, an employee of theirs has uploaded a video of animal cruelty onto Youtube and this company NEEDS to know about this. Any decent employer (and they list themselves as a family owned company on that link above) would be outraged to know that one of their employees is somehow related to this video - participating in filming, or uploading, makes no difference and they didn't think at all to add their employer on the Youtube channel to which it's uploaded.

Although he could change the information by the time you are in receipt of this, I wanted to document the information for you.

*Please also call the Toledo Humane Society's phone number listed as 419-891-0705 ext. 301 - Please call them today.

I'm going to try the phone number at 8am Mountain time today without entering the extension first to see if I can get someone.

I've also contacted The Humane Society of The United States on their website at http://www.hsus.org/contact_us/contact_cruelty_fighting.html

I would copy/paste the same information that you email the Toledo Humane Society for the HSUS - they will pursue things often when others do not.

Hopefully together they can get the guy's ip address information through his phone company and locate his address, etc and seize his dog who has sadly been trained to engage in this behavior and prosecute this man to the fullest extent of the law. He is in violation of animal cruelty laws as well as Youtube's terms of agreement.

Please everyone, let's help with this.

Thank you

Location: UPDATED it's NOT ok to contact this poster with services or other commercial interests

8
gfxlonghorn•

I don't see how this is different than a dog doing this to a rabbit or the like. All this outrage over a cat, but nobody gives a shit about rabbits, squirrels, or the like. It's one thing if you are all gung ho PETA like, but just because a type of animal has been domesticated, you make it seem more important than another one. Seems a little bit excessive if you ask me.

edit: FYI, I am a vegetarian, so I find it hilarious that all you meat-eaters are disgusted by this more than me.

8
vanillazilla•

I also thought people were overreacting at first until I watched the video.

I don't think it's the fact that the cat got killed so much as how the cat got killed. The humans egged the dog on and even knocked the cat out of the tree so the dog could maul it. It doesn't matter that it happened to a domesticated animal or not (at least not to me). I'd be upset to see people doing that to any animal.

39

You're also forgetting the part where the cat actually dies in the end because that fucker keeps kicking it around. It's not like the dog went out hunting and brought back a dead cat - the guy is the one who killed it.

25
fr3ddie•

dood i think you missed the point of his comment because I dont think anyone would have given a fuck if it was a bunny instead of a cat.

-3
kromlic•

dood i think you missed a couple commas and periods here and there but whatever its all good amirite yay coherence

Most people would've likely "given a fuck" if it were any animal that the human had trained a dog to attack. The worst part is how the human pointlessly tortured it afterward.

4
vanillazilla•

...did you read the last part of my comment?

It doesn't matter that it happened to a domesticated animal or not (at least not to me). I'd be upset to see people doing that to any animal.

3
Dubon•

Deliberately setting a doberman on cat is not "letting the nature take its course". Do you not see the difference?

19
uriel•

Do you not see the difference?

No. And people that do think it is different know very little of how cruel nature really is.

-9
kromlic•

Merely by claiming that "nature" is some sort of mystical, meta-force proves your naivety. "Nature" is not cruel. Cruelty is subjective, and we as humans define this act as cruelty.

Society has defined the parameters for what construes needless torture. This is violating that construct.

3
springtime•

"Cruel nature" would be, when a dog would see a cat and start hunting it. The cat would either make it to escape or turn around and would give the dog a nice hit with her very sharp claws.

Ever seen a dog that's been caught in a fight with a cat? A dog nose and eyes can look pretty nasty after that.

Other outcome could be, the dog catches the cat. Now, either the dog doesn't know what to do with the cat or, yes, indeed would kill the cat. But without the help, support or influence of a human.

Letting a dog loose on a cat (or the other way around) is not the "course of nature".

2
uriel•

Ever seen a cat 'play' with a mouse? It is hard to get more cruel than that...

1
Barrack•

Lol. And if I let my doberman loose in your presence I would wager that you would quickly change your mind and plead me to make the dog stop.

1
vishtr•

I am a vegetarian too, you'll have to take a different holier than thou approach. Finding humor in this is sickening.

It's disgusting if it's a squirrel or a rabbit as well.

For most, it's more disgusting to many that it's a cat as many people have held close personal relationships with cats and understand them to be loving feeling creatures. I'm assuming your food choice stems from an extrapolation of this assumption from animals you know to animals you don't know. Not everyone makes that connection, and I see no humor in it.

Now I sound like I'm on a high horse.

12
gfxlonghorn•

I find humor in the outrage rather than the video itself. I have seen far worse things than animals killing animals, so excuse me if I am not deeply offended by it. It is nature, the guy is clearly helping the dog fulfill the dog's natural instincts and I will concede he is an asshole, but it still is nature.

No, it was never my choice to become a vegetarian(although I guess I chose to stay one) so maybe that's why I am not all high and mighty about animal rights and so forth.

It seems like a pretty ridiculous double standard that people will go so far as to harass a guy and ruin his life and then go back to eating their steak dinners.

-3
emmster•

My dogs kill small animals pretty regularly. I can't tell you how many times I've found them playing with pieces of birds or squirrels. (But not cats. A cat kicked their asses once. They don't mess with cats.) Nature is ugly sometimes.

But, the key difference in my mind, is that my dogs do that because of instinct. They like to hunt little things and play with them. I haven't trained them to kill birds and squirrels, and if I caught them at it, I would not encourage it, but rather throw a frisbee or some other toy that's less, you know, alive. Them having a prey drive is one thing. Humans getting a kick out of watching their dog kill is another entirely.

Plus, you know, a lot of times, cats have people who will be sad at their demise. Not so true for wild critters.

7
baconn•

People (should) have different attachments to domesticated animals than wild ones. That said, I dislike lynch mobs.

6
gfxlonghorn•

Illogical favoritism: brought to you by the rapists of the Aboriginal, Native American, and African American cultures.

1
mexicodoug•

They're downmodding you because they know that they're still involved in doing it, and not downmodding would be an admission of complicity.

0
[deleted]•

Why? All animals are potentially domesticatable---see the tame fox studies for more. And all domestic animals can easily go feral. This may very well be a feral cat, no more or less a pest than a feral raccoon.

1
baconn•

For the same reason we are more attached to our family members than strangers.

7
swaggums•

monkey sphere

2
[deleted]•

Indeed, but I would still say it should be criminal to kill strangers despite my not loving any in particular.

On the contrast, people want to criminalize the killing and eating of pet animals (cats/dogs/horses) but not any other kind of domestic animal (sheep/goats/cows).

0
[deleted]•

read guns, germs and steel. you're wrong

-1
[deleted]•

I know what you're getting at. For 1000s of years, people lived with say zebras but never managed to tame them while horses were tamed in Europe.

However, for 1000s of years people lived with foxes and never tamed them either... till in the 1950s, intensive selective breeding was able to produce tame foxes in a small number of generations. What kept us in the past from taming zebras is simple lack of a good methadology, and (now) vast amounts of breeding stock to iterate over.

0
[deleted]•

I give a shit about rabbits, squirrels, and the like. Look before you leap man. Not everyone is outraged simply because it's a cat; I for one am outraged over the blatant cruelty.

2
gfxlonghorn•

"It's one thing if you are all gung ho PETA like...."

Then I wasn't talking about you?

0
[deleted]•

I don't know how to reply to that statement with a question mark.

/pet peeve.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
waxpoet•

get off your fuckin high horse.

0
[deleted]•

And get a pony instead...

1
funkpucker•

Seconded. The selectivity of the morality-brigade is rather ridiculous. It seems as if these people believe a cat dying is the most horrifying thing imaginable. There are millions if not billions of cats in the world. The only thing that makes one special in any way is the positive emotions its owner feels for it, and that is only significant if you care for that person.

-3
rogue417•

Again, the issue is not that the dog attacked a cat, it is that the person involved caused this to happen for amusement. It's low, it's sad, and it is aggravating.

7
funkpucker•

Many people hunt many different creatures for amusement. I know of many people who "plink" squirrels for amusement and think nothing of it besides mild amusement.

By letting the unfortunate souls around us aggravate, change, bring down, etc.. us we let them win. Sure it's unfortunate that there is a guy down in Mexico who encourages his Doberman to kill felines for sport, but allowing that to bring you down is the real tragedy.

-2
rogue417•

I would hardly call that sporting...

0
Kream1•

That's a brutal video.

The dude says stuff like "wait up I'll get him down" "fuck him up" "kill him already".

I live really close to Mexico and met neighborhood kids from just walking around. This kind of horseplay isn't surprising over there and unfortunately I don't think the authorities would care.

But if the uploader is tied to a U.S. company he'll be in trouble, since the video exposure is high now.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
ArcticCelt•

I was only able to watch the dog catch the kitty then I forwarded and when I saw the poor kitty lying down I had to close that thing :(

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
mexicodoug•

Why do you hate trees?

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
mexicodoug•

I like your reasoning. At least we agree on something.

1
genuinepolitician•

This is why I own a Labrador. I don't think he could kill anything if he wanted (except maybe in extreme self defense). They naturally have a "soft" bite. He could bite you all day long and it'd feel like nothing more than a tickle.

5
itsnotlupus•

They naturally have a "soft" bite.

Err.. Every dog as a soft bite when they want to.

If your dogs ever ends up having to hunt for his food, I guarantee he'll remember how to use his jaw just fine.

4
vonjean•

I own 4 dobermans and 2 cats. I am a volunteer for Hand Me Down Dobes a non profit organization to rescue dobermans and place them in their forever loving home. Dobermans are working gaurd dogs and are very very loyal and loving to the owner. They have to be trained to be attack or even be taught to be mean. It is DEFINITEY NOT in their nature. This dobe had to be encouraged by the owner to do that. That is a sad twisted thing to teach such a loyal animal. Dobermans are NOT a hunting animal!!! Evoking terror in any animal or human is something America is fighting against!!!

2
genuinepolitician•

No, Labradors are bred to have this ability. They're bird dogs. Owners didn't want the dog to bite down on the prey, only to use it's mouth as a hand and bring it back. So dogs that had "soft" bites were bred for that characteristic.

I think my dog would have a problem if he ever had to hunt for his own food. As a Labrador he'd be more apt to play with everything than to kill it and he's scared of most animals if they become threatening. I'm sure that if it came to it he would probably kill a few birds if he could find them, maybe some mice and the like, but he's not much of an aggressive beast. Labs are known and bred for their temperament.

1
Livpaamars•

Even though it's rare, even Labs have killed humans in the past, so I'm sure your lab would be able to kill a cat if it was hungry enough.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
rebel•

I used to raise labs, and although I cannot remember the exact source (a book I had on the breed), mentioned that labs had one of the highest jaw compression per square inch of all dog breeds.

I have seen labs on the attack, and you are right, they can be ferocious. Esp one not trained to hunt when they go after game.

They can't help it, they are bird dogs, it's been bred into them. My last lab would roll in and eat goose shit so he could sneak up on them and grab one. He'd come home with a goose (totally illegal btw), COVERED in geese shit. Ugh. Talk about a mess. And reporting to the game warden that Frodo killed yet another protected species. They give you a tag for the bird and threaten to fine you. Gooses were tasty though. The ducks too. Eventually we put a fence in. Then it was chickadees and other random little birds.

2
genuinepolitician•

I'll definitely concede that Labradors love birds, he has a toy one he'll whip around as you describe. However, that's a different story than with kittens or rabbits and the like (which I didn't distinguish and should have). Labradors still have one of the softest mouths you'll ever find, I think.

1
youenjoymyself•

We're going to find you and you will get what you deserve, fucker. Karma's gonna be a bitch to you, esse.

4
inappropriate_joke•

Karma's gonna be a bitch to you, esse.

He's already in Mexico.

22
mexicodoug•

There are people in Mexico, most of whom were born here, who feel that treating animals cruelly is wrong.

Not enough, but we're working on changing that.

Your support would be more useful than your blanket derision.

6
CritterM72800•

Oh, ok.

3
PhilxBefore•

This time your name was wrong. Have an upvote.

0
[deleted]•

seems to me he's in OH

0
jeremybub•

I was about to downvote till I saw your name, have an upvote!

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ENOTTY•

What's that on his fingers?

4